AdventAI

ETERNAL PUNISHMENT.

By R. F. Cottrell

From Review and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 14., April 7, 1885

In the North American Review of February, 1885, is an article on the “Certainty of Eternal Punishment,” by Rev. Dr. W. G. T. Shedd. He holds that future punishment is not reformatory, but retributive; and yet he makes it consist simply in remorse of conscience. He says: “Could Satan really convince himself that his moral character is not his own work, but that of God or nature, his remorse would cease, and his punishment would end.”

Two fundamental propositions upon which his argument is based are taken for granted, and no attempt is made to prove them; first, that man is immortal; and, second, that future punishment consists in remorse of conscience. Admitting these premises, he makes a fair show of argument that sin and misery must exist eternally; because the sinner remains a sinner, and consequently punishment remains still his due as long as his character is unchanged. Accordingly, the wicked are represented as being punished, but the time will never come when they will have been punished,—when God will have rendered to them according to their deeds.

That death without a resurrection is eternal punishment, the writer has well explained. He says: “The human penalty which approaches nearest to the Divine is capital punishment. There is more of the purely retributive element in this than in any other. The reformatory element is wanting. And this punishment has a kind of endlessness. Death is a finality. It forever separates the murderer from earthly society, even as future punishment separates forever from God and heaven.” If the writer had only known that “the wages of sin is death,” he could have made it clear that the “second death”—a death with no resurrection beyond it—is eternal punishment; or, in the words of an apostle, “everlasting destruction;” instead of eternal torment tamed down from the old orthodox idea of hell fire to the eternal goadings of a guilty conscience.

How silly the thought that Satan’s punishment, and that of wicked men is simply “remorse.” Satan has seemed to enjoy that sort of punishment for six thousand years, while he has warred with all his might against the Son of God and the human race. The habitual sinner becomes more and more hardened. The conscience becomes seared. A child’s first convictions of sin cause the deepest remorse; but repetition after repetition will nearly obliterate conscience. Therefore if remorse is the punishment of sin, it is in inverse ratio to the degree of the guilt,—the worse the sinner, the lighter the punishment.

Satan is not now suffering his punishment. He and his angels and wicked men are “reserved unto judgment,”—“the day of Judgment to be punished.” 2 Pet. 2: 4, 9. The demons which our Lord cast out understood it so. Said they, “Art thou come hither to torment us before the time?” Matt. 8: 29. “Art thou come to destroy us?” Mark 1: 24. According to the current theology, these demons were destroyed thousands of years before, as much as they ever will be; but they did not know it.

Satan and his host look forward to the time of their torment and destruction. And well they may; for the fire into which wicked men will finally go, is “prepared for the devil and his angels.” Matt. 25: 41. And a certain being who was once a “covering cherub” in the “holy mountain of God,” and also has “been in Eden the garden of God,” who was once “full of wisdom, and perfect in beauty,” until “iniquity was found” in him, will finally be devoured by fire and brought to “ashes upon the earth;” and the declaration of God to him is, “Never shalt thou be any more.” This is what Satan and his angels expect; for they know that God has said the word. “The devils believe and tremble.” They have “a fearful looking for of judgment and fiery indignation which shall devour the adversaries.”

R. F. COTTRELL.