SOME RECENT GEOLOGICAL RESULTS FAVORING THE BIBLICAL ACCOUNT OF THE AGE OF MAN.
The following article is from the March number of the Rugby Monthly, a journal published by Dr. Samuel W. Murphy, Wilmington, Del. We would commend it to the attention of those who seem to think that geology is an exact science, and that its followers are unanimous in the opinion that man is many ages older than would appear from the Biblical account:—
“There has been no question of modern science so much the sport of the half informed or skeptical fanatic as that of the antiquity of the human race; for left, as it has so long been, without any authoritative settlement, the elasticity of its possibilities has been frequently made to serve the purpose of scorners of revealed religion. They say, ‘We have abundant evidence that early man in Europe saw the retreat of the great glacier, and that he was the contemporary of the mammoth and woolly-haired rhinoceros. We further know upon astronomical grounds, that this ice era was inaugurated at least 100,000 years since, thus determining the antiquity of man to be far beyond the 6,000 years measured by Biblical history.’
“Now the proposition which I hope to establish in the present paper is, that whatever may be the future discoveries in the field of anthropology, there is, as yet, no authentic evidence that man’s origin was much, if any, more remote than the Mosaic record declares it to be.
“Taking the oldest records of human remains, we find that no reliable scientist has been able to trace man’s origin to a period farther removed than the Pliocene Tertiary. In Europe there is really no evidence upon which any dependence may be placed, that would point to such antiquity, and but few anthropologists have made any assertions concerning Tertiary man in the old world. In America, the famous Pliocene (?) or Calaveras skull is generally recognized as genuine proof. It was found imbedded in the auriferous gravel, which was removed in the presence of two distinguished naturalists. Analyses showed that the osseous matter had been completely changed from phosphate to carbonate of lime, this proving beyond a doubt that the skull had remained in place for a number of years amounting to centuries.
“The gravels in which the skull was found imbedded have been referred to the Pliocene by Professors Whitney and Lesquereux, because of the remains of plants and mammals found in them. But Professor Joseph Le Conte is inclined to take exceptions to this view, holding that the mammalian bones furnish quite as clear evidence regarding an early quaternary age. He says: ‘The mammalian remains are a mixture of the characteristic Pliocene species still lingering, and of characteristic quaternary species just coming in. They undoubtedly, therefore, indicate a transition from Pliocene to Quaternary. The plants, it may be admitted, are Pliocene; but plants are far less delicate tests than mammalian animals.’
“Besides this imperfect paleontological evidence, there remain certain geological considerations which have great weight. It is known that these old auriferous gravels fill the channels of ancient river beds, now entirely buried beneath great sheets of volcanic lava. Regarding the history of these ancient rivers, Professor Le Conte has been able to trace out the following sequence of events:—
“Just after the elevation of the Sierra Nevadas, a drainage system was inaugurated which continued up to the later part of the Pliocene, when, owing to the increasing cold, great glaciers began to cover the summits of the Sierras. But these glacial conditions were cut short by the opening, in early quaternary time, of an era of volcanic energy. The great masses of glacial ice began to melt, so that the river beds were filled to overflowing; and put in motion by the swift currents were vast quantities of debris, which rapidly filled up the channels. There came the grand outburst of volcanic matter, covering the old rivers and the gravel which filled them.
“Of the many hypotheses put forth to account for the auriferous gravels, this is by far the most rational, and one which, if true, would make them of post-glacial age, remembering that glacial conditions must have been cut short by volcanic heat early in the quaternary. Thus far we are led to discard the whole theory of Pliocene man, the oldest authentic records reaching back not beyond early, and perhaps middle, quaternary.
“Passing on from this earliest Calaveras skull, we read of hundreds of cases where man and his works have been found, but all exhumed from deposits of decidedly post-glacial origin.
“Among the many reliable discoveries in continental Europe, those in the valley of the Somme river suggest the greatest antiquity. Here, human implements were found in a deposit, made when the river, owing to the melting of the ice-sheet, was greatly swollen. This ancient stream must have filled nearly to the brim the present valley of the Somme, along whose banks lingered this early people, in the cold of a retreating glacier. In England, the oldest remains of man were found in a gravel resting upon a boulder clay, or, in other words, in a post-glacial deposit.
“In Eastern America, the earliest record of the human race was found in the valley of the Delaware, near Trenton, imbedded in a yellow gravel of undoubted post-glacial age. All the discoveries yet made in the Danish peat marshes, however deeply buried, have indicated an origin still more recent than the close of the glacial epoch.
“The age of the cave fillings cannot be determined with exactness, but anthropologists are united in the opinion as to their post-glacial origin, the filling being probably due to the flood caused by the melting of the great ice-sheet.
“Thus we see that from the utmost extent of evidence obtained, we are unable to trace the antiquity of man farther than to the close of the ice reign.
“Yet many are inclined to claim an enormous antiquity, because of the remoteness of the glacial epoch.
“Whatever may be the extension of time since the inauguration of glacial conditions throughout Northern Europe and America, this much is established, namely, that the period since the final melting of the ice-sheet has been a recent one, and quite upon the verge of Mosaic history.
“Man, then, being a post-glacial being, a measure of his antiquity may be found in some calculation of the time since the close of the ice reign. Many calculations as to the amount of erosion since the close of the glacial epoch, have quite recently been made, which lead to important results.
“Of these, the most interesting is in the retreat of the Falls of Niagara, due to the enormous eroding power of the water. Of the many estimates concerning the rate of recession, the most reliable is that of Mr. James T. Gardner, director of the New York State Survey, who places it at an average of three feet per year. The gorge between Queenstown and the Falls was made by this recession. But of the whole seven miles in the length of this gorge, but three miles of it has been eroded in post-glacial time, thus making it, at the rate of three feet a year, 5,280 years since the close of the ice reign.
“The gorge below the Falls of St. Anthony is regarded as an example of post-glacial erosion, its length of eight miles, and the rate of recession, 5.15 feet per year, making it 8,202 years since the ice age.
“The rate of recession of the bluffs bordering the south shore of Lake Michigan has been calculated by Professor E. Andrews at 5.28 feet per year, taking 2,720 years for the recession. Back of the above terrace are two others, each successively higher than the other. By comparing their contents with the amount removed in the recession, the action having necessarily covered a period of 2,720 years, we get 2,570 years as the time consumed in the accumulation of the upper beaches. The sum of these two periods, 5,790 years, gives the time since the close of the glacial epoch.
“The volume of the Mississippi delta has often been used as a measure of time, Messrs. Humphrey and Abbott having calculated the amount of sediment annually carried down by the current, and estimating its age at about 5,000 years.
“Little dependence, however, can be placed upon such experiments, owing to the conflicting statements in regard to the true depth and extent of the delta. But, taking the average of these calculations of age, we obtain a period of about 6,000 years since the close of the glacial epoch.
“Aside from these definite time measurements, there are other considerations which point in a general way to the recency of the ice period, one such having come under the observation of the writer.
“Covering the entire Delaware and Chesapeake peninsula is found some twenty-five feet of gravel, deposited towards the close of the glacial epoch. Into this deposit all the streams of the peninsula have cut slightly, the depth of erosion rarely exceeding 10 feet. Now, since the age of any land area can be measured by the depth of surface erosion, this slight depth of stream erosion must indicate a very recent period since the melting of the glacier.
“Professor G. F. Wright, in his glacial studies in Ohio, has testified to the same thing in the strongest terms. The streams everywhere flowing over glacial debris have cut but a short distance into the latter, while pre-glacial creeks and rivers have carved for themselves wide and deep valleys.
“The student of erosion in the lake region of Western New York cannot fail to observe the short distance which the waterfalls, inaugurated at the close of the ice reign, have retreated. In most cases the erosion has worn them back to a distance of but less than a mile from their original position.
“In fact, it may be said with all truth, that every American geologist is coming to look upon the completion of the glacial epoch as an event having been but just at its close—an event still in the last stages of its decline, when Adam received the breath of life.
“In anticipation of the objection that we have no record of any migration of man from the East to Europe and America, I would ask, Have we any assurance that Moses recorded every fact of early Hebrew history? Owing to the remoteness of many of these facts, it is probable that he did not. Looking backward, as he must, through a protracted period of years, with no historical records to guide him, it is almost certain that he omitted many minor points of history.
“Again, it has often been maintained that, because the remains of man and his works have been found associated with the bones of animals now extinct, his origin must have been remote. But this is easily refuted by the consideration that among the bones of animals that have been found associated with those of man, by far the greater number of species are those still living. If on the Western plains we should find the skull of a man associated with the bones of the American bison—an animal now quite extinct—we should not be justified in attributing a great antiquity to the skull, inasmuch as we know that the extinction of the bison has occurred within the remembrance of one generation. In other words, the extinction of a species may be a rapid process, an event accomplished in a few hundred years, and one which can tell us nothing of man’s antiquity.
“Thus the whole fabric of these zealous fanatics may be reduced. Time was when this question rested upon vague generalizations only; but the patient investigations of the naturalist have enabled him to know whereof he speaks, and it is the opinion of many modern geologists that the Biblical records conform with the facts.”