AdventAI

REVIVALS—TRUE AND FALSE.

By Rev. G. Nelson

From Review and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 13., March 31, 1885

TEXT:—“From that time Jesus began to preach, and to say, Repent, for the kingdom of heaven is at hand.” Matt. 4:17.

THE word here rendered “repent” means to change or amend the life; and the marginal reading (Matt. 3:4) more correctly renders, “bring forth fruits answerable to amendment of life.” And this marks the preaching of the Lord and of all his disciples and true ministers as really what it is called, a “preaching of righteousness,”—an actual means of the Lord’s “blessing us by turning every one of us away from his iniquities.” The popular idea of these words obscures all their practical power by the supposition that repentance is an emotional rather than a practical work; that it is a work done, not in “ceasing to do evil, learning to do well,” at the counter, at the anvil, at the plow, at the bar, in the pulpit, but in a moment’s passive emotion on the mourner’s bench.

There is a word in the original that has an emotional element in it—an element of remorse, the Judas style of repentance. But the word used here, and in all parallel cases, has no such reference. It means a change of mind, of principle, and thence of practice. It requires this change of principle to change practice. A sensation is not a principle, but only a flood-tide whose ebbing leaves the soul stranded where it was. Every one knows that men are every day wrought upon by the professional revivalist’s skillful manipulations of their feelings till they are brought down to the depths of sorrowfulness, then up to the heights of rapture, only to come back to the dead level of their unexcited state, without a single change of principle or practice. But a change of principle, which can be truly effected only under the calmest and most rational and deliberate purpose, will affect the practice. The true conviction is a conviction of the truth, and that not in the sensibilities, but in the understanding. It is a conviction that the Lord is the only Saviour, and that his commands are the only true and right things to be done, and all else ought to be shunned as sins. And when it is practically carried out, it brings the repentance that is the amendment of life.

John the Baptist, as the model preacher, showed how this is practically to be done in his instructions to the people that flocked to his “baptism of amendment of life.” Luke 3. He made it a much more practical matter than the modern momentary and sensational affair that so often usurps its place. The true repentance that involves amendment of life must go on, day by day, as the amendment of life goes on—on till the life is amended. What can only be done by living, cannot be compressed into one immense throe of feeling, and all be over, as is expected by the popular plan of getting religion all in a lump, for once and forever. Of course it is impossible that the summary process of the revival plan can involve the actual resistance of its evils till they are suppressed, and the actual choice and practice of goodness from the Lord till it is acquired, as the actual amendment of life must involve; for evidently no actual work is done or is contemplated in the proper process. It depends not on the practice, but the theory of the matter; that is, not on actual knowing and shunning of evils as sins, as they come up to be known and resisted in real life, but a sort of wholesale dispatching of them under a sensation of general guiltiness; and that that guiltiness is canceled on the ledger of heaven by substitution. This is the chief mistake in the popular plan. It leads men to trust in a substituted instead of a real religious work; to put a summary emotional substitute in place of the perpetual, practical life itself, “doing justly, loving mercy, walking humbly.” It encourages men to think that if they go through the prescribed emotional exercises, and get a substitutional washing from the guilt of sin, they are pure and saved from hell and made fit for heaven, all by feeling instead of living. They are, in fact, not saved from hell and made heavenly as they expected to be, as their subsequent experience in fighting against its power in themselves, and vain efforts to obtain the hoped-for heavenliness, so clearly proves. If they were really saved from hell, they would not find its life still so strong in them that, if they resisted at all, it must be done by a perpetual life-battle. If they were really transformed into a state of heavenliness, they would not find themselves so far from its reality, and so unable to attain it by the best efforts of their lives.

There would be less of fiction in this, and the fiction would be less harmful, if no more was claimed for it than there could possibly be in it; that is, nothing but a simple start in the right direction. A conversion, turning around, it may be; a re-generation; a re-birth into heavenly life it cannot possibly be. One may take a step and reverse the direction in which he is going, but he cannot thus do the going all the way from hell to heaven. Between these two states “there is a great gulf fixed,” and not one step but the daily walk of a life can span the gulf. It is a long way from the love of self to the love of the Lord; from the love of the world to the love of the neighbor. Life’s changes are not lightning shocks, but regular progressive processes. They do not very well accord with the idea of instantaneous regeneration. We would not expect an invalid to recover his health instantaneously. It is the same physically or spiritually. No birth is accomplished except as the result of a growth. The heavenly birth is no exception. Ignorance is not flashed out and wisdom flashed into any mind instantaneously. Neither is goodness in the heart. Conversion is not regeneration, any more than the crisis in disease is recovery, than the generation of life is birth, than the first glimpse of truth is wisdom. And, what is more, the sensational work of the common revival is often not even conversion; nothing indeed at all but an excited feeling, which passes away without leaving a trace behind.

It is a most unfortunate and disastrous mistake that has led to the so general impression that the only way to get religion is through this prescribed state of emotional excitement; that one cannot begin the Christian life except by being broken on the revival wheel; that this is his only hope of heaven. Multitudes who, if taught the truth, would without delay make a quiet, rational, and well-advised beginning of a better life, it deters from ever making an attempt till a professional revivalist comes around, and they go through the prescribed “experience,” to come out, after all, perhaps, only with the delusion that sins are washed away that never have been even once seen, much less resisted; that to feel very sorrowful, and then shoutingly jubilant is the whole of the work of putting away sin and receiving heavenliness that fits the soul for heaven. This is discovered to be the delusion that is believed by so many of the unfortunate victims of the popular revival machinery, who learn to their disgust and discouragement as soon as the excitement is over, that, instead of being the whole work, it has been nothing at all to them. This wholesale way of balancing sin accounts, never disposed of an actual sin in the world. It all can never make a worldly man less worldly, as long as he is unconscious that he is worldly, and that worldliness is a sin. Otherwise, why does it breed so many of exactly this kind of Christians, that are in particular very worldly, or grasping, or dishonest, or hard-hearted, or passionate, and yet have never known and shunned these evils once, perhaps, in all their lives, but trusting in the wholesale disposition of their general sinfulness, have gone most confidently and shoutingly down to death? Their particular evils of actual life get no recognition, no resistance. They never dream of its necessity. Under the washing they have had, what need? Such men never perform an actual work of repentance, nor have an actual sin washed away in all their life; and the delusion that they do is most deadly, and the idea that fosters it is the most fearful mistake in all the world. Its effect is hardening in the extreme. Take, for example, a girl in our city who had been in the habit of telling untruths; was, in fact, famous for it. She went through a popular revival, and experienced the popular substitutional religion. Reminded of her fault one day, she said, “Oh! that is nothing any more; it is washed away in Jesus’ blood,”—a fact that no one could see but herself. All that this fearful delusion had done for her was to make it nearly impossible ever again to convince her of the necessity of actual repentance and amendment of life in regard to this particular evil, since a general dispatch has been made of all. The only true and safe religion is one that teaches that no other repentance is of any avail but that of each individual, actual sin, as it comes up in the daily life;p. 194 that no other will break the hold of a single evil on any life; that no other will give remission, or, as the word means, sending away—removal—of sins. Remission of sins, like repentance, is not fiction, but a fact. Sins are not remitted or removed while they are still in the life, while their power is still unbroken and their practice unrestrained. These are not imaginary cases, but real and common ones, and perpetually fostered by the false idea that underlies the whole present revival system. It all is an evil, that demands abatement. And it will be abated as men are taught the truth, that the right and sure and effectual way to get religion is to begin and live it calmly, rationally, intelligently, and faithfully, in the daily life. Any one can begin who can simply think, “That and that is wrong, a sin against the Lord. This and this is right, and from the Lord; he being my help, I will shun that; I will do this.” And then after the thought shall have been repeated till it grows to purpose, purpose to practice, practice to love, and love continues to the end, the work is done; then hell is escaped and heaven attained. Experiencing religion is living it; living it is doing it; doing it is possessing it, and in the end heavenliness it brings. When the church comes to teach these truths it will have a perpetual revival that is a fact, not a fiction, that will save men and not delude them.—Rev. G. Nelson, in Watchman.