A REVIEW.
BY ELD. J. O. CORLISS.
(Concluded.)
Our Fairfax friend says there was no Sabbath for 2500 years; that Adam, Enoch, Noah, none of these kept the Sabbath. Again we inquire, How does he know? what proof does he offer to make good his assertion? Simply this: That the Sabbath was not mentioned in all that time, therefore was not known. This is no doubt conclusive to his mind; but let us see to what such deductions will lead. There is not a single mention of the Sabbath in the Bible from Moses to David. According to the logic of our anti-Sabbatarian friend, this proves that no Sabbath existed during the entire time,—a period of 500 years. But he has already admitted that the Sabbath law was in force in Moses’ time, and existed till the death of Christ. Was it re-enacted in David’s time? Let our reviewer answer. Again, there is not a single instance of the observance of the day of atonement recorded in the Bible; yet the Jews now observe it. Does that prove it was not observed by the children of Israel? Every one knows it does not. Neither does the failure of the book of Genesis to mention the actual observance of the Sabbath prove its non-existence during the time that book covers.p. 179
But the book of Genesis does speak of the institution of the Sabbath: “And on the seventh day God ended his work which he had made; and he rested on the seventh day from all his work which he had made. And God blessed the seventh day and sanctified it: because that in it he had rested from all his work which God created and made.” Gen. 2: 2, 3. But, says our friend, “This is no command, only a statement of what God did.” We answer, Partly wrong, and partly right. While it is a statement of what God did, the statement emphatically shows it is also a command. Let us see. It says first, that God rested on the seventh day; secondly, he blessed the seventh day; and thirdly, he sanctified it. To “sanctify” means “to make sacred or holy; to set apart to a holy or religious use; to consecrate by appropriate rites; to hallow.”—Webster. Now if God set apart the seventh day to a holy or religious use, it is manifest that man was the one to so use it. To set it apart, was certainly to separate it from the others as a distinctive day. It does not take more than ordinary mental acumen to perceive that there was but one way to do this for man’s benefit, and that was by a proclamation to man. Otherwise, God’s rest, and his blessing upon the day of his rest, and also its sanctification, would have remained a simple resolution in his own mind. But the proclamation of that resolution to man invested it with the force of an appointment or command. The Sabbath, therefore, was recognized from that time forward. That the Gentiles did not observe the Sabbath in that age proves no more against its existence and the law for its observance, than that many now rob and murder proves there is no law in the land against those crimes.
For more than a month before the law was proclaimed on Sinai the Sabbath was known, being pointed out by the falling manna. More than that, it was regarded as a part of God’s law at that time. In Ex. 16: 4, the Lord said he would prove whether his people would walk in his law or not by sending the manna in their midst. In verses 22, 23, we learn that on the sixth day of the week they gathered a double portion of the manna. Some found fault, and complained to Moses. In reply he said: “This is that which the Lord hath said. To-morrow is the rest of the holy Sabbath unto the Lord.” It seems from this that the Lord had said before that the seventh day was the Sabbath. Moses here refreshes their minds upon this point, and briefly tells them to prepare for it; for on the morrow they would find none in the fields. But some of the people did go out on the Sabbath to find it. Then the Lord reproved their act in the following words: “How long refuse ye to keep my commandments and my laws.” It is plain from this that the Sabbath was a part of God’s law and commandments long before they were proclaimed from Sinai. When did it become such? It is evident that since there is no mention of its institution prior to that time only in connection with the creation week, then and there, as recorded in Gen. 2: 2, 3, the Sabbath became obligatory by the command of God to Adam. Let any one who disputes this point, show when it did become one of God’s commandments, since we have found it recognized of God as one of his commandments before he proclaimed them on Sinai.
Now with reference to the morality of the fourth commandment. No one doubts the morality of the commandment that says, “Thou shalt not steal.” That precept does not specify anything, but it is general in its application, and prohibits the appropriation by one of anything and everything that belongs to another. The morality of that particular commandment consists in showing a regard for the right of property. The fourth commandment, however, not only points out the right of property, but specifies the particular kind and amount. In that precept man is prohibited from appropriating the seventh day to his own secular use. Certainly, if a command is moral that recognizes the right of property between man and man, there is no reason why a command recognizing God’s right to property, and an injunction prohibiting man’s appropriation of it, is not moral also.
Again, take the fourth commandment from its place in the decalogue, and the force of the other commandments is lost. This must be true from the fact that none of the others reveal the Author of the law. It is true the name, “God,” occurs in some of them, but it is also true, as the apostle says, that “there be gods many and lords many.” He adds: “But to us there is but one God, the Father, of whom are all things, and we in him.” 1 Cor. 8: 5, 6. The commandment that says “Thou shalt have no other gods before me,” unless some particular being is specified, is just as applicable to any god of the heathen as to Jehovah. So with all the other precepts that simply refer to the name of God. Not so, however, with the fourth. That is the only one of the ten which tells who is its author. It says: “For in six days the Lord made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day: wherefore the Lord blessed the Sabbath day, and hallowed it.” In this God proclaims himself the maker of all things, the only one who has authority to command. This precept was therefore given for the express purpose of keeping in mind the only true God, who made all things. This is forcibly expressed by God himself through his prophet: “Moreover also, I gave them my Sabbaths, to be a sign between me and them, that they might know that I am the Lord that sanctify them.” Eze. 20: 12.
If the Sabbath could point out the true God to the Israelites, it could and would do the same for all who would embrace it. It was highly proper then that the Sabbath should be given to the representative of the human race, and thus secure a knowledge of God in the earth. Surely if any one would keep the Sabbath each week for the reason assigned in the commandment itself, he could never forget the creative power of the true God, and turn to the service of false gods, because the command expressly says that the author of the Sabbath made all things. As often, then, as one keeps the Sabbath, he remembers God as the only true and living God. Without the fourth commandment in the decalogue, we repeat that the remaining precepts have no force. If the fourth one of the ten gives force to all the rest by identifying their Author, it is certainly moral in the highest sense, and the Lord made no mistake when he put it in the bosom of his moral law.
We come now to notice a few statements with reference to the New Testament. The author of the tract under consideration, after speaking of certain parts of the ceremonial law, says: “Here is a little of the ceremonial law, but no Sabbath.” Certainly; why should Paul mention the Sabbath in connection with ceremonials? One was no part of the other. We have shown in this review, and that clearly, that the Sabbath was given before the ceremonial law or any part of it existed; that it is as moral in its nature as any moral precept in the Bible, and is therefore just as binding as any other. But in his zeal to overthrow the Sabbath, our friend has committed the fatal error so common among those of his class. While trying to make a distinction between the Sabbath precept and what he termed moral, he said that moral law needed no special enactment in words, because it is always in existence. (See page 5.) But in order to make out his case at all hazards, he says on page 8, that all these things (meaning the ten commandments) are done away, and then quotes 2 Cor. 3: 6–15 to sustain his assertion. How strange that all the moral law in existence was contained in the tables of stone; that it must always exist from its very nature, and yet by some unaccountable method it was all done away at a stroke! We sometimes wonder how that scripture would have been explained if there were no Sabbath in the law to be gotten rid of.
Let us examine that scripture carefully, and see if our friend did not read it wrong. We will first examine verse 6. In that Paul declares he is an able minister of the new testament (covenant), not of the letter, but of the spirit. Paul talks of the new testament altogether in this verse, and says he is not a minister of the letter of the new testament, for the letter killeth. Notice, he did not say the letter did kill, and was therefore done away; but he says: “The letter killeth,” that is, in the present tense; and he is sent to preach repentance to men that the spirit may give life—to whom? to those who are already alive, and have no fear of death? No; but to give life to those who are dead through the letter of the new covenant. He then tells what it was formerly that brought death; namely, the law written on the tables of stone. But mark one thing,—the entire ten commandments—that part with the rest that some concede to be moral and of everlasting obligation—were written on the tables of stone. The violation of any one of these brought death. They do the same now. Paul says: “The wages of sin is death.” Rom. 6: 23. “Sin is the transgression of the law.” 1 John 3: 4. The difference between the two dispensations, however, is this: In the former, death was administered to the incorrigible at the time of the transgression. In the present dispensation, the punishment is deferred till the Judgment. Yet that ministration, the apostle says, was glorious; this one excels the old, not by being in contrast with the old, but when compared with it, as being simply more glorious. The glory of the former ministration was done away because the ministration itself was superseded by another ministration more glorious. The ten commandments were not done away in the change (though the ministration of death did cease), neither is there the least intimation to that effect in the chapter under consideration.
After cutting off all the commandments in order to get rid of one that is offensive, the necessity appears to re-instate somehow the others that are palatable, and so in the next paragraph, our friend has Paul give commandments for Christians to keep. To make this appear, reference is made to Rom. 13: 7–9, where Paul quotes a portion of the law to enforce the duty of loving one another. He then asks in apparent gusto, “Did Paul enjoin upon Christians the duty of keeping the Jewish Sabbath? I think not. Did Christ or any apostle? I think not.” To say nothing of the absurdity of making Paul a law-giver, thus elevating him to the place of God (see James 4: 12), when he was only chosen to be an apostle and teacher, we cannot think that our friend, carefully and without prejudice, read what the writer to the Romans said in other parts of that epistle, before penning what he said in reference to chap. 13: 7–9. We cannot believe that Paul would be so inconsistent as to contradict his own statements in the same letter. Yet we find him saying in chapter 3: 19: “Now we know that what things soever the law saith, it saith to them who are under the law: that every mouth may be stopped, and all the world may become guilty before God.” Notice the strength and scope of this statement. He says he knows that what things soever the law saith (not what it may be construed to mean), it is that every mouth may be stopped, and all the world may become guilty before God. He is not talking of what the law said once, sometime in the past, but in his own day. Moreover, this was written as late as A. D. 60. Paul did not in this text say a word about the old law being done away, and that he would give them another. No, he was writing about the same law he wrote of in the second chapter. In Rom. 2: 18 he tells them that they know God’s will by being instructed out of the law. Then he adds in verse 22: “Thou that sayest a man should not commit adultery, dost thou commit adultery? thou that abhorrest idols, dost thou commit sacrilege?” This shows to what law the apostle refers, and proves that, when taken with chapter 3: 19, he considered the whole law of ten commandments binding in his day.
It was not necessary to re-enact a Sabbath law in the New Testament. Had Christ attempted such a thing, it would have shown the institution to be just what some now try to make it, a shadowy enactment. All the institutions that were of that character he did replace by memorials that would point back to him and his work. But where these substitutions were made, the Bible plainly says so. The very fact that the Sabbath had no substitute provided to put in its place, but was incidentally mentioned with other parts of the law of which it was a part, shows it to be moral and enduring like all other portions of that law. Christ always observed the Sabbath of the Lord, as is evident from Luke 4: 16. In this he set an example for all to follow. 1 John 2: 6 says: “He that saith he abideth in him [Christ] ought himself also so to walk, even as he walked.” It was Paul’s custom to keep the Sabbath day. Acts 17: 2; 18: 1–11. In all their dealings with reference to the Sabbath of Jehovah, Christ and his apostles acted as though it was to be observed. And John, when upon the isle of Patmos, said he was in the Spirit on the Lord’s day. Rev. 1: 10. In this last book of the Bible, the existence of one day which the Lord claims is fully recognized. What day that is may be learned by reference to the saying of Christ himself when he said, “Thep. 180 Son of man is Lord also of the Sabbath.” Mark 2: 28.
This ends the controversy. With what our friend has quoted from men who take a position with him, we have nothing to do. But as the scriptures to which we refer refute his positions, they are equally good against those whom he quotes; and we are willing to rest the matter here, believing that those who are candidly seeking truth on this subject will find in what we have written sufficient evidence to satisfy them that the fourth commandment teaches now just as much as it ever did, that the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord, and is still in force.