THE ROMAN DECRETALIA ON THE ABILITY OF THE POPE TO CHANGE THE LAW OF GOD; THE SECOND COMMANDMENT EXPUNGED FROM THE DECALOGUE AND THE FOURTH CHANGED BY ROMANISTS; WHAT THEY SAY IN THEIR CATECHISMS.
BY ELD. W. H. LITTLEJOHN.
Mr. Biblist.—Picking up the thread of our discussion just where we laid it down last evening, I shall proceed immediately to prove that the pope of Rome has exactly fulfilled the prediction concerning him found in Dan. 7:25.
Maud.—What was that prediction, father?
Mr. B.—Why, that he should wear out the saints of the Most High, and think himself able to change the law of God. I propose to accomplish my task by an appeal to the actual facts of history in general, and Roman Catholic authorities in particular. So far as the wearing out or persecution of the saints is concerned, I need only to remark that it is admitted by the most judicious church historians that the papacy has put to death in one way or another more than fifty millions of the saints of the most high God.
Maud.—Why father, just think of it! If that is true, the Romish church has actually destroyed as many Christians as there are inhabitants in the United States.
Mr. B.—Yes, my daughter; as startling as such a declaration may appear, you will find it to be correct if you will consult standard authorities on that point. You will find in the library there a very reliable work entitled, “Dowling’s History of Romanism.” At your leisure you can verify from its pages what I have said. Respecting the claim of the papists to ability to change the law of God, it will only be required that I should allow them to speak for themselves. I have here somewhere a little book entitled “Facts for the Times.”
Maud.—Here it is, father.
Mr. B.—Thank you. I will read from page 136 and onward. The author says: “The Roman ‘Decretalia’ is an authoritative work in the Roman ecclesiastical law. Each pope, when invested with ‘the succession,’ declares the papal decretals to be true.
“The ‘Decretalia’ exalts the pope thus:—
“‘He can pronounce sentences and judgments in contradiction to the right of nations, to the law of God and man. . . . He can free himself from the commands of the apostles, he being their superior, and from the rules of the Old Testament, etc.’”
“‘The pope has power to change times, to abrogate laws, and to dispense with all things, even the precepts of Christ.’—Decretal De. Translat. Episcop. Cap.
“‘The pope has authority, and has often exercised it, to dispense with the commands of Christ respecting war, marriage, divorce, revenge, swearing, usury, perjury, and uncleanness.’—Pope Nicholas, Caus. 15, Quest. 6.
“‘The pope’s will stands for reason. He can dispense above the law; and of wrong make right, by CORRECTING and CHANGING LAWS.’—Pope Nicholas, Dist. 96.
“‘The pope can dispense against the laws of nature, and against the universal state of the church.’—Pope Nicholas, Caus. 15, Quest. 6.
“‘The pope is free from all laws, so that he cannot incur any sentence of irregularity, suspension, excommunication, or penalty for any crime.’—Dist. 40.”
Language could hardly be more explicit or more blasphemous than this. These assuredly are the utterances of Paul’s “man of sin,” who was to oppose and exalt himself above all that is called God, or that is worshiped; so that he as God should sit in the temple of God, showing himself that he is God. You will observe that the decretals quoted assert in so many words that the pope can set aside the decrees of both God and Christ; thus fulfilling precisely the prediction of Daniel that the little horn which was a symbol of the papacy should think to change the laws of God; or as the Douay or Catholic version of the Bible has it, “Shall think himself able to change times and laws.”
I wish now to give you a practical illustration or two for the purpose of proving that the pope has not contented himself with theories merely on this subject. You are aware that Romanists bow down to images despite the explicit declarations of the second commandment of the decalogue against such a practice. Were the ten commandments complete, and conspicuously presented before the laity of the church too often, it might lead to disagreeable questionings. The church, therefore, has guarded against such a danger by providing for the use of the common people a revised form of the decalogue, with the second commandment left out, and one of the remaining ones divided into two, so as to keep the number complete. I read from “Butler’s Catechism,” a Catholic work:—
“Ques. Say the ten commandments of God.
“Ans. 1. I am the Lord thy God, thou shalt not have strange gods before me, etc. 2. Thou shalt not take the name of the Lord thy God in vain. 3. Remember that thou keep holy the Sabbath day. 4. Honor thy father and thy mother. 5. Thou shalt not kill. 6. Thou shalt not commit adultery. 7. Thou shalt not steal. 8. Thou shalt not bear false witness against thy neighbor. 9. Thou shalt not covet thy neighbor’s wife. 10. Thou shalt not covet thy neighbor’s goods.” Ex. 20.
Upon reading such a mutilation of the law of God, you are forced to adopt one of two conclusions: either the Romish church has deliberately come to the decision that it will violate one of the commandments of God as found in the decalogue, or else it proceeds upon the supposition that it has the power to alter the law of God, and has acted accordingly. It is difficult to determine which of these offenses would be the most heinous in the sight of the Lord; but it is natural to conclude that the latter is the one that Rome has committed, since that comports best with her profession of faith, all things considered.
I am aware that some apologists for the papacy aver that the alteration of the commandments as given in Butler’s and other catechisms does not furnish positive proof of a disposition on the part of that power to change the law of God so long as it allows the decalogue to stand intact in the Douay Bible. Such a defense is not valid. It is well understood that the rank and file of Romanists are as ignorant, so far as personal observation is concerned, of the contents of the book of God as they are of the shasters of the Hindoos. This ignorance on their part has, until quite recently, been encouraged and perpetuated by the highest authorities of the church. The catechism to the common people has been everything, and the Bible nothing. The result, practically speaking, is that they have remained entirely ignorant of even the existence of the second commandment as it was written by the Lord. In the meanwhile the wily priests have with sacrilegious hands taken from the law of God whatever they pleased, and changed the numbering of the commandments at will, under the blasphemous pretense that the vicar of Christ upon the earth has a right to alter or amend the law of God at will. The consequence is that to-day the Romish church is a church of idolaters. I think, Maud, that I have somewhere in my library a volume entitled “Campbell and Purcell’s Debate.”
Maud.—Yes, sir, I have my hand upon it now.
Mr. B.—This book contains some words uttered by Mr. Alexander Campbell in his discussion with Bishop Purcell, which are in point. I think I shall find them on page 214. Yes, here they are. Please remember that Mr. Campbell is speaking of the same mutilation of the commandments that we have been considering. He says: “It is a poor apology for this expurgation of the decalogue, that it is not so done in the Douay Bible; for when these catechisms were introduced, and even yet in most Catholic countries, not one layman in a thousand ever read that Bible; the catechism intended for universal consumption contained all his knowledge of God’s law. What myriads, then, through this fraud, must have lived and died in the belief that the second commandment was no part of God’s law! It is clearly proved that the pastors of the church have struck out one of God’s ten words; which not only in the Old Testament,p. 178 but in all revelation, are most emphatically regarded as the synopsis of all religion and morality. They have also made a ninth commandment out of the tenth, and their ninth, in that independent position, becomes identical with the seventh commandment, and makes God use a tautology in the only instrument in the universe that he wrote with his own hand! But why this annulling of the second commandment? Because it is a positive prohibition of the practice of bowing down to images, and doing them homage,—a custom dearer to the Romish church than both the second and the seventh commandment.”
It is not a little remarkable that, while Mr. Campbell could see so clearly in the matter of the dropping out of the second commandment from the decalogue an illustration of the tendency in Rome to tamper with the law of God, he should have been utterly oblivious to another example of the same propensity much more striking than the one he has brought forward. I allude to the change of the Sabbath. You will observe that in the commandments as quoted in Butler’s catechism, the fourth, or Sabbath, commandment is numbered three instead of four, as it should have been; and that it contains but eight words, whereas (according to Ex. 20:8–11) there are in it ninety-four words. From this it follows that from the fourth commandment alone, the papacy has been guilty of expunging eighty-six words, all of which God spoke with his own voice, and wrote with his own finger on the tables of stone. If they did this because they thought that the words in question were irrelevant, then they charge God with folly. If on the other hand, they did it because the words in question inculcate doctrines that they disliked, then they treat God with contempt. One or the other of these motives must have actuated them in this most singular conduct. Let us see, therefore, if we can determine just what consideration controlled them in their action. I read again from Butler’s Catechism, p. 26:—
“Ques. Say the third commandment.
“Ans. Remember that thou keep holy the Sabbath day.
“Q. What is commanded by the third commandment?
“A. To spend the Sunday in prayer, and other religious duties.
“Q. Which are the chief duties of religion in which we should spend the Sundays?
“A. Hearing mass devoutly; attending vespers, or evening prayers; reading moral and pious books; and going to communion.
“Q. The hearing of mass, then, is not sufficient to sanctify the Sunday?
“A. No; a part of the day should also be given to prayer and good works.”
Take note that it is distinctly claimed in what I have just read, that it is duty to sanctify the Sunday. But where is the authority for this? Assuredly not in the words, “Remember that thou keep holy the Sabbath-day;” for these in no way define the day which is the Sabbath. So far as they are concerned, it might as well be urged that it is Tuesday or Thursday, as to insist that it is Sunday. But there must have been some object in curtailing the fourth commandment so that it has been reduced from ninety-four to eight words. Is it possible, then, that this shrinkage was brought about in order to dispose of a portion of the commandment which does define the day of the Sabbath, and which would not be in harmony with Sunday keeping? Let us see. Here is what the “Catholic Catechism of Christian Religion” says on the subject:—
“Ques. What is the third commandment?
“Ans. Remember that thou keep holy the Sabbath day; six days shalt thou labor, and shalt do all thy work; but on the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God; thou shalt do no work on it; thou, nor thy son, nor thy daughter, nor thy man-servant, nor thy maid-servant, nor thy beast, nor the stranger that is within thy gates, etc. Ex. 20:8.
“Q. Why does God commence this commandment by the words, ‘Remember,’ etc.?
“A. To remind the Jews that this commandment is only a confirmation of one that had been always observed by his order, since the beginning of the world. Gen. 2:3; Ex. 16:23.
“Q. What does God ordain by this commandment?
“A. He ordains that we sanctify in a special manner, this day on which he rested from the labor of creation.
“Q. What is this day of rest?
“A. The seventh day of the week, or Saturday; for he employed six days in creation, and rested on the seventh. Gen. 2:2; Heb. 4:1, etc.
“Q. Is it then Saturday we should sanctify, in order to obey the ordinance of God?
“A. During the old law, Saturday was the day sanctified; but the Church, instructed by Jesus Christ, and directed by the Spirit of God, has substituted Sunday for Saturday; so now we sanctify the first, not the seventh day. Sunday means, and now is, the day of the Lord.
“Q. Had the Church power to make such change?
“A. Certainly; since the Spirit of God is her guide, the change is inspired by that Holy Spirit. The uniform, universal, and perpetual tradition of all ages and nations, attest the antiquity of, and consequently the divine assent to, this change; even the bitterest enemies of God’s Church admit and adopt it.
“Q. Why did the Church make this change?
“A. Because Christ rose from the dead upon Sunday, and rested from the great work of redemption; and because on this day the Holy Spirit descended on the apostles and on the Church.”
Doubtless you have observed that in what I have just read, the author recognizes the fact that the wording of the fourth commandment is such that it enforces the sanctification of the last day of the week. He frankly admits, nevertheless, that the church is observing the first day of the week. He does not, therefore, quote the fourth commandment to prove that it is obligatory now; but rather to show that it cannot be binding, since it is in conflict with the traditions and practice of the church. Here, then, we have a satisfactory reason for the omission from the catechisms of all that commandment that defines which day is the Sabbath. In short, he claims that the church has so far changed the Sabbath commandment as to make it harmonize with the enforcement of the first-day, instead of the seventh-day, Sabbath. These catechisms are issued under the authority of the pope, and by his direct sanction. You see, consequently, how completely the papacy fulfills the prediction of Daniel, that he (the pope) should think to change times and laws.
Mr. T.—But does not the catechism claim that the church was instructed by Jesus Christ, and led by the Holy Spirit in making the change in question?
Mr. B.—Yes, sir; but when did you understand the catechism claims that this instruction was received?
Mr. T.—Why, I suppose that it intended to teach that Christ did it while he was on the earth.
Mr. B.—There you are greatly mistaken. Let me read a sentence or two over again. Here is what I refer to:—
“Ques. Why did the Church make this change?
“Ans. Because Christ rose from the dead upon Sunday, and rested from the great work of redemption; and because on this day the Holy Spirit descended on the apostles and on the Church.”
Now remember that one of the reasons assigned for the change of the Sabbath from the seventh to the first day of the week, is that it was on the latter that the “Holy Spirit descended on the apostles and on the Church.” The allusion evidently is to the day of Pentecost. But Christ had ascended to the Father finally, ten days before the Pentecost was reached. This being true,—as the falling of the Holy Spirit on the church on the day of Pentecost furnished one of the reasons for the change of the Sabbath,—that change, according to the Catholic church, could not have taken place until after the ascension.
Mr. T.—I see that you are right.
Maud.—The catechism says that the Sunday is kept by the Catholics because Christ was born on that day. How do they know he was born on that day, father?
Mr. B.—They know it in the same way, Maud, that they know that Christ was born on the 25th of December, or our Christmas day; that is, they know nothing about it. But more about this matter hereafter.
Battle Creek, Mich.