AdventAI

THE TEMPLE IN HEAVEN.

By W. H. Littlejohn

From Review and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 21., May 26, 1885

THE PERPETUITY OF THE DECALOGUE SETTLED, AND MR. NOLAW SILENCED. MR. SURPLICE AND MR. DIPPER TAKE ISSUE WITH MR. BIBLIST.

BY ELD. W. H. LITTLEJOHN.

Mr. Biblist.—I am glad to-night, gentlemen, to see you all present again. I shall give Mr. Nolaw’s favorite theory a few moments’ attention, and then pass to other considerations. It has been clearly demonstrated that so far as the life and teachings of Christ are concerned, they emphatically condemn everything like Antinomianism. It only remains to prove that his apostles pursued the same course of conduct. I shall do this by reading a few texts of Scripture which are so plain that they will hardly need comment. Here is what Paul says (Rom. 3: 31): “Do we then make void the law through faith? God forbid; yea, we establish the law.” The law here spoken of cannot be the Mosaic law; for Christianity certainly did make that void. It must be therefore that Paul referred to the ten commandments. This being true, the faith which he held rendered them of permanent obligation.

Again I read from the same author, this time from Rom. 3: 19: “Now we know that what things soever the law saith, it saith to them who are under the law; that every mouth may be stopped, and all the world may become guilty before God.” This language was penned in A. D. 60. The apostle writes in the present tense. He makes reference to some law which, at the date of his communication, was, as he represents, speaking to the people. The same law, according to his statement, is one before which all the world is to become guilty before God. Now I submit that the law in question could not have been the Mosaic law for several reasons. In the first place, it is not in existence now, and therefore cannot be at the time of the Judgment. In the second place, it applied to the Jews exclusively, and consequently never could be employed in the Judgment for the condemnation of the whole world. Again, I submit that the law in question could not have been the so-called “law of Christ.” By reading the context it will be found that the code to which Paul alludes was once acknowledged by the Hebrews. Take these words, for example, from chapter 2: verse 23: “Thou that makest thy boast of the law, through breaking the law dishonorest thou God?”

It will not be disputed that the law mentioned in the verse just read, is the same as the one to which Paul makes reference in chapter 3, verse 19. But if this point be yielded, the former, like the latter, was once honored by the Jews, and consequently could not be the law of Christ, which they have ever rejected. Having dismissed the law of Moses and that of Christ as incapable of meeting the demands of the situation, the only alternative left is that of adopting the conclusion that Paul must have referred to the decalogue. There is no code in the Scriptures beside it and the two already discarded, that could by any possibility be the one which he had in his mind. Furthermore, it meets all the requisitions of the case. It is one which, in the old dispensation as well as in the present one, has ever been accepted by the Jews. Believing as they do that it came directly to them from the hand of God, it is a law in which they pride themselves; thus fulfilling the conditions of Rom. 2: 23. Again, being a summary of all moral principles, and being adapted to no age or race in particular but to all in general, it is exactly fitted to become the standard of judgment for the world in the day of God; thus answering also the requirements of Rom. 3: 19. I repeat therefore that beyond all controversy, it is the law of which Paul speaks in that passage. But this being true, its perpetuity is settled beyond dispute; for a law that existed in A. D. 60, and will continue to do so until the Judgment, must be binding now.

I pass now to 1 John 3: 4–6: “Whosoever committeth sin transgresseth also the law; for sin is the transgression of the law. And ye know that He was manifested to take away our sins; and in him is no sin. Whosoever abideth in him sinneth not; whosoever sinneth hath not seen him, neither known him.” It can hardly be necessary for me to prove that the law of which John speaks is the decalogue. The text defines sin to be the transgression of the law. It then proceeds to state that Christ was manifested to take away our sin. In 1 John 2: 2 we learn that Christ was not only a propitiation for our sins, or transgressions of the law, but also for those of the whole world. The world in this connection covers every person from Adam to the last man that shall live. If therefore Christ made a propitiation for the sins or transgressions of the law committed by all these, it must have been some law to which all were amenable. But the law of Christ, so-called, could not have existed before the cross, and therefore could not have been transgressed by those who lived before the crucifixion. This being true, it must have been the ten-commandment law which (if I may be allowed the expression) slew the Son of God. In other words, that was the law which all have transgressed and from the consequence of violating which, Christ was “manifested” to save us. But admitting this to be so, then, as just intimated, the law of 1 John 3: 4–6 is the decalogue. Furthermore it is still in existence and obligatory upon Christians as well as others; for the apostle declares that “whosoever sinneth”; i. e., transgresseth the law about which he is talking, “hath not seen Him [Christ] neither known him”; thus making obedience to the law the test of Christian experience.

With the passage just considered I shall close my argument on the perpetuity of the law. There is hardly a page of the Bible on which I might not find either direct or remote evidence of its binding force; but the passages here quoted are so explicit that they settle the point in controversy.

Mr. Surplice.—In that you are quite right. There is not a plainer question in all the Scriptures than that which relates to the continuation of the law of God. In fact, I think that even Mr. Nolaw himself is about satisfied on that point. I notice that his responses of late are feeble and far between.

Mr. B.—Well, gentlemen, if there is nothing more to be said on that branch of the subject which we have just been considering, I will pass to an examination of the Sabbath question from the standpoint of the fourth commandment. It is agreed, I believe, that we have but one Sabbath law in the Bible, and that is found in the decalogue. If any one has changed his mind on the point, of course he will tell us where another law of the kind can be found.

“Silence gives consent,” so I pass on. It only remains now to examine the phraseology of the fourth commandment with reference to the day that it enforces. The language in which it is couched is very simple. Like that of every other law it must be taken to mean just what the people to whom it was given understood it to signify at the time of its employment. It says in so many words that the seventh day is the Sabbath. Now we know that the Hebrews to whom the law was committed, ever interpreted it to mean the last day of their week which corresponds to our Saturday. They could hardly be mistaken on the identity of the day, as both the Lord and Moses pointed out the latter for them about thirty daysp. 323 before they reached Sinai. Here is the record which justifies me in saying that they did so. I read Ex. 16: 25–30:—

“And Moses said, Eat that to-day; for to-day is a Sabbath unto the Lord; to-day ye shall not find it in the field. Six days ye shall gather it; but on the seventh day, which is the Sabbath, in it there shall be none. And it came to pass, that there went out some of the people on the seventh day for to gather, and they found none. And the Lord said unto Moses, How long refuse ye to keep my commandments and my laws? See, for that the Lord hath given you the Sabbath, therefore he giveth you on the sixth day, the bread of two days; abide ye every man in his place, let no man go out of his place on the seventh day. So the people rested on the seventh day.”

You notice that Moses says distinctly, “To-day is a Sabbath unto the Lord.” He also adds, “To-day ye shall not find it [the manna] in the field.” By these words he not only pointed out the Sabbath in a single instance, but he also called attention to the fact that no manna should fall upon its sacred hours; thus furnishing the means by which it might be distinguished thereafter from the other days of the week. The same thing is substantially true of the Lord. He upbraids the people for seeking manna on the seventh day, notifying them that on the sixth day he had given manna for two days. His logic is this: There is no necessity for you to go out of your tents on the seventh day; since I have caused the manna to fall on the sixth day in such quantities that it will be sufficient for both days. Putting the language of Moses and that of the Lord side by side, it will be seen that the Sabbath was pointed out by them to the children of Israel in three ways: 1. Moses, in alluding to a particular day, declared that it was the Sabbath day; 2. He also informed them that the Sabbath was one on which no manna should fall; 3. God identified the Sabbath for the people by giving them to understand that he had caused a double portion of manna to fall on the day which preceded it.

Under these circumstances there can be no question that when God commenced the Sabbath commandment with the words, “Remember the Sabbath day to keep it holy. Six days shalt thou labor and do all thy work; but the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God; in it thou shalt not do any work,” he designed to perpetuate an existing institution with which all were familiar. Should any one still doubt, however, as to whether the Sabbath of the commandment was the same as that on which the people rested before they reached Mount Sinai, it would be very easy to satisfy them at least that the Israelites, at the time of the giving of the law and during their journey of forty years in the wilderness, were able to identify the day which the law required them to hallow. For forty years Jehovah pointed it out by three miracles which were enacted each week.

Mr. Thoughtful.—If you please, inform me as to what they were. I do not call them to mind at present.

Mr. B.—They were these: 1. On the sixth day the Lord caused twice as much manna to fall as on other days. 2. He preserved from corruption over the seventh day or Sabbath, the manna that fell on the sixth day; whereas, that which fell on other days corrupted before the following day. 3. He made the fall of the manna to cease altogether on the seventh day.

Now, gentlemen, I shall be ready, as attorneys would say, to rest my case after having placed my argument in the form of a brief syllogism. It is this: 1. When the fourth commandment was first uttered by Jehovah, it enforced the observance of the seventh or last day of the week. 2. The same commandment which then obligated man to observe the seventh-day Sabbath is still binding upon the race. 3. Therefore as it is obvious that the same law cannot properly be construed to mean one thing at one time and another thing at another time, it must be true that the observance of the seventh-day Sabbath is still binding upon the human family.

Mr. Westminster.—Your syllogism in one particular is defective. You reason upon the hypothesis that the fourth commandment is the same to-day that it was when it was first given; whereas it was changed by Christ so as to make it enforce the first-day instead of the seventh-day Sabbath.

Mr. B.—If you are right in what you say, of course my syllogism is unsound. Before surrendering it, however, I must be assured that your statement is correct. You will be so kind therefore as to take the Bible and prove your assertion by reading to us a positive Thus saith the Lord for the change that you claim has taken place.

Mr. W.—Well, I do not know, sir, that I can find a passage that states in so many words that Christ changed the Sabbath; but I am nevertheless sure that he did so.

Mr. B.—You admit, then, that there is no explicit statement in the Scriptures to the effect that Christ changed the Sabbath?

Mr. W.—Well, yes, sir. I suppose I shall be compelled to do so.

Mr. B.—Very good. Now I will make another request, since you cannot find in the Scriptures a declaration to the effect that Christ changed the Sabbath: Will you oblige by furnishing us with a verbatim copy of the fourth commandment as it stands since Christ changed it with a view to making it enforce the first-day Sabbath. It is not impossible that the phraseology of the changed law will not bear the construction that you placed upon it.

Mr. W.—Why, I don’t suppose that Christ changed the wording of the fourth commandment in any way.

Mr. B.—Then you admit, sir, that the fourth commandment reads just the same as it always did—

Mr. W.—Yes, sir.

Mr. B.—And that it is still binding?

Mr. W.—Yes, sir.

Mr. B.—Well, this is a strange state of things surely! Christ changed the Sabbath, and never told anybody about it nor changed the Sabbath law!

Mr. Dipper.—Perhaps he told the apostles.

Mr. B.—Ah, yes; but a perhaps will not answer the purpose in such a case as this. There is too much at stake. This question of the change of the Sabbath is a vital one. If the old Sabbath is still binding, its desecration would prove fatal to those who set it at naught. If a new Sabbath has taken the place of the old one by the express command of Christ, it is of infinite importance that all should know that such is the case. How, then, could the fact of the change be communicated to succeeding generations, except through the medium of the record of the New Testament. Are we as Protestants going to admit at last that papists are right in taking the position that there are essential doctrines of Christianity the authority for which can be found alone in tradition? If so, let us make a clean breast of it and confess that Rome has been right and we have been wrong in the bitter and prolonged contest which we have been waging against her. If we yield on the point of tradition, we must yield on every point. I ask again, therefore, in the name of Protestantism,—nay, I demand, that you shall furnish me with the chapter and the verse which teaches that Christ changed the Sabbath before you call upon me to believe that he ever did so. This suggestion of Mr. Dipper’s that Christ told the apostles that he had changed the Sabbath, is not only entirely gratuitous, but it is also preposterous in the extreme. Let me read you a passage bearing on this point. You will find it in John 14: 26: “But the Comforter, which is the Holy Ghost, whom the Father will send in my name, he shall teach you all things, and bring all things to your remembrance, whatsoever I have said unto you.” Did the Saviour fulfil these words? If he did, then the Holy Spirit, after the death of Christ, brought to the remembrance of the apostles the fact that Christ had told them that he had changed the Sabbath, provided that such were the case; but if the Spirit did so, was it not for the express purpose that the apostles might place the fact concerning the change on record for our benefit? How then shall we explain their neglect to do so? Admit that the Holy Spirit revived before the minds of the writers of the New Testament the facts concerning the change of the Sabbath, and that they failed to transmit them to us, and you impeach both them and God; them, for not writing what the Holy Spirit told them to write; God, for permitting their blunder to render the gospels defective in that they do not declare the whole duty of the Church and the world. The simple fact is, gentlemen, that if your theory is correct, matters are badly bungled all around. According to it Christ changed the Sabbath and failed to cause that important fact to appear anywhere in the inspired writings; while God, though conscious that Christ had substituted the first-day in the place of the seventh-day Sabbath nevertheless failed to repeal the fourth commandment which enforces the latter on penalty of death, thus subjecting man to the necessity of keeping two Sabbaths in each week; the first in order to meet the demands of the decalogue; the second for the purpose of obeying the command of Christ.

Mr. Nolaw.—There, gentlemen, didn’t I tell you that you would get into trouble if you should admit that the fourth commandment was still binding?

Mr. D.—If I am any judge, we have come out as well as you did with your no-law theory.

Mr. B.—Be calm, gentlemen, be calm. Facts have very hard knuckles; but if they knock us down the best thing that we can do is to accept the situation and lie quiet. I see by the clock that it is now time for us to adjourn. When we come together again we will resume our discussion where we leave it at this time.