SHALL WE KEEP SATURDAY OR SUNDAY?

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 26, 1885

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 21.

Read the full edition

“SHALL WE KEEP SATURDAY OR SUNDAY?”

In further considering this subject, let it be noted that the observance of the first day of the week has never been appointed as a memorial of the resurrection of Christ. The idea that we must keep Sunday to commemorate the resurrection of Christ is cunningly instilled into the minds of men; but it is wholly without foundation—a mere human invention. For the New Testament plainly points out the memorials of Christ’s death and resurrection. To commemorate his death, the Lord’s supper is appointed (1 Cor. 11 : 23-26); and to commemorate his resurrection, we have the ordinance of baptism. Rom. 6 : 4, 5. Now mark, God does not give two memorials for the same event. There would be no need of it. And therefore the idea so insidiously brought in, without a word of instruction to that effect in the Scriptures, that we must keep Sunday in memory of Christ’s resurrection, and that if we do not do this we deny Christ, is simply a handful of tares which the enemy has sown among the wheat. Be not deceived.
But again, there is no consistency in this Sunday memorial. What is there in the event of Christ’s resurrection to indicate that it should be commemorated every week?—Nothing. With the Sabbath the case is far different. When that was instituted, a period of just seven days was covered. Six of them were devoted to labor, and one to rest. And these events, as has already been shown, created the cycle of the week, permanently setting apart its last day to rest from labor, and sacred uses. But Christ did not work just six days, and then rise on the next day. Why then should we work six days, and then spend one day in rest every week, to commemorate that event? It is all folly. The fourth of July, 1776, on which the declaration of American Independence was made, was Thursday. Why do not the American people, then, celebrate Thursday of every week to commemorate that event?—Because there was nothing in it to indicate a weekly celebration. The sixteenth day of the first Jewish month, on which Christ arose, was Sunday. But there was nothing in this case any more than in the other to indicate a weekly celebration. Then why should we keep Sunday of every week for this purpose? There is no occasion for it whatever.
We are next asked to consider on what day the apostolic churches assembled for worship. Let the reader ever bear in mind that it does not matter how much honor the disciples paid to Sunday, nor how often they devoted it to meetings. That does not release us from the original Sabbath unless that law has been repealed; and this matter must not be left to inference or guess-work. But we are told that some doctrines rest largely on deductions and inferences, as the doctrine of the resurrection which Christ deduced from the writings of Moses to refute the Sadducees. Matt. 22 : 31, 32. In reply to which we ask if any man can suppose there is any parallel between an argument for a doctrine, and a law to regulate our duty to God? Does God leave his laws to inferences, and compel men to find out their duty as best they can?—No; he gives his requirements in plain, direct, and unmistakable language; and that man assumes a fearful responsibility who charges God with acting otherwise.
Under the head of apostolic practice, much stress is laid upon Acts 20 : 7. The reader is familiar with the narrative. Paul came to Troas, and tarried with the disciples seven days. The time having at length arrived for him to depart, the disciples came together to hold a parting meeting and break bread. Paul preached all night, and at the break of day, on some day of the week, he departed on his long journey to Jerusalem. Meanwhile Paul’s companions, among whom were Luke and other eminent disciples, did not remain to this parting meeting, but while Paul was preaching, were themselves on their journey, sailing the ship around the promontory from Troas to Assos, with the intention of there meeting Paul, who after his meeting was to go across the base of the promontory, a shorter distance, on foot, and join the disciples there by the time they could bring the ship around; which he did.
Our first-day friends who try to use this text to sustain Sunday-keeping find that they have an elephant on their hands, which, before they get through with him, steps his whole weight on their argument, and crushes it into the ground. Does the text say that they met to keep the Sabbath?—No. Does it say that this was their ordinary time of meeting?—No; in the Greek there is simply a noun and its participle—“the disciples having come together.” It was not a regular but a special meeting held in view of Paul’s immediate departure. Do we anywhere read that the breaking of bread on any day by the disciples, made a Sabbath of it?—Nowhere. Then what is there in all this to build a new Sabbath upon? Let us see. The disciples came together to break bread on the first day of the week. Now for the conclusions: Therefore that was their regular time for meeting; therefore they regarded that as the Sabbath; therefore a new Sabbath had been introduced among them; therefore the old Sabbath had been given up; therefore the law was abolished; therefore we ought to reject the old and adopt the new; notwithstanding there isn’t a syllable of Scripture anywhere for any one of these conclusions. Reader, are you willing to rest your practice in so important a matter as the keeping of one of the commandments of God upon such a foundation?
But the text contains within itself positive proof that neither Paul nor his companions regarded the day as sacred time; for it records acts on their part which show this. The text speaks only of an evening meeting; for when they assembled, there were “many lights” in the place where they were gathered together. It is absurd to say, as some do, that this meeting commenced on Sunday morning, and that Paul preached in one continuous discourse all through the day and the whole of the following night till Monday morning.
It becomes, then, quite an important question, though by no means exhaustive on the text, to determine what evening it was upon which this meeting was held. Bible days, as every reader of ordinary intelligence understands, commence with the evening, or at the setting of the sun. The first day of the week begins, according to this manner of reckoning, not at midnight on Saturday, but at the setting of the sun on Saturday, some six hours sooner. The only meeting which could be held on the first day of the week, at which lights would be required, would therefore be, according to this computation, in the evening following the setting of the sun on Saturday night. Having preached all that night, the next day-break, at which time Paul departed, would be Sunday morning; and so in the day-time of Sunday, beginning at that early hour, he journeyed on foot twenty miles from Troas to Assos. We can imagine with what righteous indignation he would denounce those who try to use his example on this occasion to overthrow the Bible Sabbath, and bolster up a usurper in its place; for every step he took, trampled into the dust, and every swing of his Syrian staff as he sturdily marched forward to Assos, smote into fragments any Sunday institution which men attempt to found upon his example.
It becomes necessary at once for Sunday-keepers to so manipulate this passage as to give it a different complexion; and this they strenuously endeavor to do. So Mr. Rauschenbusch lustily cries out that this is a “brand-new” interpretation. Not at all, we answer. All Biblical critics recognize the Jewish method of computing the day from sunset to sunset; and Messrs. Conybeare and Howson, in their popular work on the “Life and Epistles of Paul,” expressly affirm that Paul commenced his journey from Troas to Assos on Sunday morning. But Mr. R. says, No; for, Luke wrote, he contends, according to Roman reckoning, which begins the day at midnight. The reasons he gives for this are, that Troas was a Roman colony, that Julius Cæsar invented the Roman calendar, which was then used throughout the Roman empire, and that the Romans compelled all their subjects to adopt their method of reckoning time. The reply to all which is (1.) that the Julian calendar had nothing to do with the commencement of the day, but only with the reckoning of months and years. (2.) The Romans did not compel their colonists to adopt their beginning of the day in their own private or social transactions. In all transactions with the government and legal matters, they would of course insist upon this. But they could carry it no further. It could be no different from what it is in our country to-day. The law recognizes the division between the days at midnight, and legal transactions conform thereto. At the same time here are hundreds of thousands of Jews, who still reckon the day in everything that pertains to their worship according to their ancient method; and here are also some thirty or forty thousand Christians observing the seventh day as the Sabbath, beginning and ending the day according to the Bible reckoning, and so reckoning whenever they write concerning it; and the law does not interfere. So it was in the Roman empire in the days of Paul. (3.) Although Troas was under Roman jurisdiction, Troas was settled by the Greeks, not by the Romans; and the Greeks reckoned the day from sunset to sunset, just the same as the Jews. See Smith’s Bible Dictionary. So we may be sure that the inhabitants of Troas, independently of Paul and his company, were commencing the day at the setting of the sun.
To say then, that, under these circumstances, Luke, a Jewish, not a Roman writer, making by inspiration a record to compose a part of the New Testament Scriptures, describing the movements of a company from Judea, brought up in the ancient customs of that country, would depart from all precedent, and adopt the Roman reckoning of the day instead of the Biblical, is most unreasonable.
But even if this could be sustained, and Roman reckoning be taken here instead of the Biblical, nothing would be gained for the Sunday after all; for then the meeting would be thrown forward into what is now Sunday evening, and the breaking of bread, after midnight, would be on Monday. But, as already shown, while Paul tarried behind to hold his meeting, Luke and the rest of the company went aboard the ship and commenced their journey; for so the record (Acts 20 : 13) states: “And we [Luke and his company] went before to ship and sailed unto Assos.” Therefore, even on this ground, Luke and others sailed off Sunday evening; and if Paul kept the Sunday there, these persons, with the concurrence and arrangement of the great apostle, certainly broke it; which would be just as bad for Sunday. There is no conceivable hope for the institution from Acts 20. The apostles regarded it as a secular day, and that only.