SHALL WE KEEP SATURDAY OR SUNDAY?

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 2, 1885

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 22.

Read the full edition

“SHALL WE KEEP SATURDAY OR SUNDAY?”

Following the usual runway of Sunday arguments, Mr. R. asks us next to consider 1 Cor. 16:1, 2: “Now concerning the collection for the saints, as I have given order to the churches of Galatia, even so do ye. Upon the first day of the week let every one of you lay by him in store, as God hath prospered him, that there be no gatherings when I come.” We too would ask the reader to consider it, but not so superficially as it has to be considered to make anything out of it for Sunday-keeping. Mark what tremendous leaps our friends have to make to reach the conclusion they desire. Paul directs the disciples to “lay by them in store.” This means, we are told, to put into the contribution box; therefore it was to be done at a public gathering; therefore they met on the first day of the week; therefore that day was their regular meeting day; therefore they kept that day as the Sabbath; therefore they had ceased to observe the seventh day; therefore that day had been abolished; therefore the first day had been put in its place; and therefore we ought to keep it. To be sure, there is not the least intimation anywhere in the record sustaining any such conclusions, nor any law for Sunday sacredness; but that seems to make no difference; Sunday arguments are sublimely independent of all evidence. Such a theological circus do they go through to find Sunday in the text. But the whole scheme is knocked squarely in the head when we consider that the expression “to lay by him” means in the Greek, “to lay by himself at home,” and not in the public congregation at all. It was a private not a public matter, not involving any assembling of the people. And moreover the duty enjoined, looking over their secular affairs to see how God had prospered them, was not such work as would be allowable on sacred time. This text, therefore, so far from proving Sunday to be the Sabbath, shows most conclusively that the apostle regarded it as secular time.
Next in order, of course, comes Rev. 1:10: “I was in the Spirit on the Lord’s day.” This text need not detain us; for every claim based upon it in behalf of Sunday is groundless assumption from beginning to end. We agree that no reference is made to the gospel dispensation as such, nor to the future day of judgment, the “day of the Lord.” The only question lies between the days called Saturday and Sunday, the seventh day and the first day of the week. And it is a marvel how there can be any question here. There never would have been had not men had a desperate case to make out. The fact that the term “Lord’s day” is used is positive proof that the Lord claims some day as his. But whether it is a day of the year, a day of the month, or a day of the week, we have no means of knowing unless God has revealed it unto us; and if it is a weekly day, we cannot tell what day of the week it is, unless he has made it known. No man has any right, aside from a revelation from God, to undertake to decide this question. But if God has given us a revelation on the point, let us have the testimony, and that will settle the question at once and forever.
Now the Lord has plainly pointed out one day as his. It belongs to a cycle of time which God established when he reserved this day unto himself, and by the very act of thus reserving it; namely, the week: and it is the seventh or last day of that weekly cycle. That day God reserved to himself, or to uses connected with his worship, from the very beginning; for he sanctified it. Gen. 2:2, 3. With a voice from heaven which made the earth tremble and the hearts of all the people quake, he declared that that day was the Sabbath—not of the antediluvians, nor of Jews, nor of Gentiles—but “of the Lord thy God.” Ex. 20:8–11. This day he calls “my holy day,” declares that his honor is involved in our keeping it, and assures all who will keep it, Gentiles as well as Jews (for the promise is to the sons of the stranger who join themselves, not to the Jews, but to the Lord) that they should be fed with the heritage of Jacob, or become heirs of the Abrahamic promises which are to be fulfilled in Christ. Isa. 56:1–7; 58:13, 14; Rom. 4:13; Gal. 3:29. If you object that this is found in the Old Testament we will come to the New; and there we find Jesus publicly proclaiming himself the “Lord of the Sabbath.” Matt. 12:8; Mark 2:28. This was the seventh day, not the first—Saturday not Sunday. And while the Lord has so expressly claimed this day as his, he has never claimed any other day whatever. Yet with all this evidence before them, men spurn this day, trample it under their feet, and stoutly declare that another day is the Lord’s day, respecting which not one word from the lips of the Lord has been left on record. Reader, dare you meet at last the Lord of the Sabbath and the Judge of all, occupying such a position and following such a practice as this? It cannot be successfully disputed that the seventh day is the Lord’s day of Rev. 1:10. The Lord erected this into a special and sacred day, called it his own, and gave it to man for sacred uses only. It is the only day ever exalted thus. It is the day Christ observed all through his ministry while giving instruction and setting an example for Christians, the day the apostles recognized and observed, and which, as late as A. D. 96, when the Revelation was given, again received the seal of the Lord as his day. It is his still; and blessed is he—so says the Lord—who layeth hold on it, turneth away his foot from it, and ceaseth to pollute it. Isa. 56:2; 58:13. Find a passage which reads that the Son of man is Lord of the first day of the week, and we will yield the controversy and acknowledge that to be the Lord’s day. And ought there not to be such a passage if it is the Lord’s day? Every candid man will admit that there should be; and if it could be found it would settle the question. But we have just this declaration concerning the seventh day from the lips of Christ himself; yet men will pay no attention to it. The course of the defenders of Sunday would be ludicrous, if it did not betray a lack of integrity and candor which is truly painful. When we find the express declaration that Christ is Lord of the Sabbath, that means, they say, that he had power to abolish it, and therefore did abolish it, and we should discard it. But when they find a passage which they imagine implies that Christ is Lord of the first day of the week, lo, presto! that means that he established it, clothed it with divine honor, and we should keep it holy!
Having now, as they suppose, produced a positive argument for Sunday, but which we have found to be wholly false and unscriptural, their next effort is to try to break down the ancient Sabbath and take it out of the way. There is only one way in which any show of argument can be made for this, and hence it is the course uniformly pursued; and that is to confound the moral law of God, with the ceremonial law of the Jews, and then take those passages which speak of the doing away of the latter, and apply them to the former. They do this simply to get rid of the Sabbath. But if they succeed in their argument they do more than this; for they destroy the whole law. It is only on this ground that such passages as Rom. 14:5, and Col. 2:16, can be brought in; for these passages refer simply to the ceremonial law of the Jews. Rom. 14 speaks of the meats and ceremonies that belong to the Jewish ritual, and the “every day” refers to their feast days; and Col. 2:16 refers only to those sabbaths which were a shadow of things to come. Why will men overlook so plain a limitation. There were seven of these ceremonial sabbaths connected with the Jewish feasts. But there was nothing typical about the weekly Sabbath. It originated before a type could exist, as it was made before man fell; it was the Sabbath of the Lord, not a feast of the Jews; it was a memorial of creation, not a type of Christ. Col. 2:16 has no reference to it whatever.
But further, why cannot men see that such arguments as they build on Romans and Colossians against the seventh-day Sabbath, are just exactly as strong against the Sunday. If their reasoning is correct, there is now no Sabbath at all. But this they do not themselves believe. No apology can be made for a religious teacher who is so poorly informed as not to know, or so uncandid as not to admit, that there are two laws, the moral and ceremonial, as distinct from each other as summer and winter, daylight and darkness; that the moral law is in its very nature immutable and perpetual, even as God himself is possessed of these attributes; for it is but the expression of his will; that it is summarily contained in the decalogue, and that the Sabbath is an integral and indivisible part thereof. On the other hand the ceremonial law originated because of man’s sin, and is in its nature mutable and temporary, pointing forward to Christ, and giving place after his first advent, to the institutions of the gospel. Christ nailed to the cross only the ceremonial and typical laws and institutions which pointed to himself. He could not have abolished a single moral principle without being the enemy of both God and man. The Devil would be very glad to abolish all moral precepts; and too many, even professed ministers of the gospel, are trying with might and main to aid him in his nefarious work. But Christ says, “Think not that I have come to destroy the law or the prophets.” Do not attribute to me so unholy a work as this; for every jot and tittle of the law shall remain till heaven and earth pass away, and all things be fulfilled. This certainly was not the law which he nailed to the cross, called “the handwriting of ordinances which was against us,” and “the law of commandments contained in ordinances” (Col. 2:14; Eph. 2:15), but that law which we do not make void by faith in Christ. Rom. 3:31. Call heat cold, straight crooked, white black, round square, or a bottle of ink a cup of milk, but don’t for the sake of common sense and Scripture mix up the moral and ceremonial laws.
An effort must now be made to account for the frequent references to the Sabbath in the New Testament, and the frequent occasions on which the apostles are said to have observed it. And this our Sunday friends endeavor to do in the most summary manner by saying that Paul and others preached on the Sabbath simply because they could then secure a congregation of Jews to preach to. How do they know this? The apostles have nowhere said so. But on the other hand, if the seventh day had continued to be the Sabbath, as we affirm, would they not have met on that day for worship just as the New Testament records that they did?—Yes, they would. What right, then, has any one, without any instruction to that effect, to assign any other reason?—None whatever.
But the practice of the apostles utterly refutes the Sunday claim. The great apostle Paul was converted as early as A. D. 35 for the express purpose of carrying the gospel to the Gentiles. Acts 9. Afterward we read of his preaching in Antioch, Iconium, Thessalonica, Corinth, and Rome. Were there none but Jews in all these cities? Was not his mission to the Gentiles here? But on what day did he preach in these places? As early as A. D. 45 they said expressly, “Lo, we turn to the Gentiles.” Acts 13:46. Luke takes occasion to make an express record of a meeting held by Paul and Barnabas in Antioch. And he says: “And when the Jews were gone out of the synagogue, the Gentiles besought that those words might be preached to them the next Sabbath.” Oh! then the Gentiles worshiped in the synagogue as well as the Jews; and it was not for the purpose of reaching the Jews alone that the apostles sought that place. But here the Gentiles themselves called for a meeting for their especial benefit. Here was Paul’s golden opportunity to introduce the so-called Christian Sabbath, if he had any such, to the Gentiles. But when was that meeting held?—On the next Sabbath. In view of such a record, it is folly to claim that the apostles regarded the first day as the Sabbath, and held meetings on the seventh day simply to reach the Jews. Would it not be a most marvelous thing, if the apostles were everywhere holding meetings for the Gentiles on the first day of the week, and only incidentally among the Jews on the seventh day, that Luke records only the meetings held on the seventh day, putting in scores of them, but mentioning only one meeting held on Sunday, and that on such a part of the day that the remainder was so used as to show conclusively that it was held as secular and not sacred time?
Christ taught his disciples to pray that their flight from Jerusalem should not be necessary on the Sabbath. This we are told was because the gates of Jerusalem would be closed and the Jews would hinder them. But whoever will read the history of the siege and fall of Jerusalem will see that the Jews were so infatuated that they opened the gates and pursued their enemies even on the Sabbath. There would have been no hindrance from them. It was simply that they might not be obliged to travel on that sacred day.
Difference in time east and west is urged as proof that we cannot keep the seventh day. It is marvelous that any Sunday-keeper should use such an argument. Wherever the first day can be kept, the seventh can also be kept.
But perhaps the most astounding argument of all is that Christ during the forty days after his resurrection told the disciples all about the Sunday Sabbath; but they forgot to write anything about it! And who says this?—A Protestant Doctor of Divinity. Alas, for Protestantism! What error might we not thus bring in? Didn’t Christ instruct them then also in favor of infant sprinkling, purgatory, image worship, sacred relics, and holy pilgrimages? Thus we might bring in every abomination of the Catholic church. Can a Protestant resort to such a method of reasoning and not blush for his cause?