AdventAI

THE TEMPLE IN HEAVEN.

By W. H. Littlejohn

From Review and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 22., June 2, 1885

THE REDEMPTION THEORY VENTILATED; REVERENDS SURPLICE, SHOUTER, DIPPER, AND NOLAW AT LOGGERHEADS; MR. BIBLIST REMAINS QUIET WHILE THEY DEMOLISH EACH OTHER'S PROPOSITIONS.

BY ELD. W. H. LITTLEJOHN.

Mr. Biblist.—All seem to be present on time to-night, gentlemen, so I conclude that all are interested in our investigation of the Sabbath question. When we were together the last time, we were examining the New Testament authority for the change of the day by Christ. I had taken the position that the fourth commandment is still binding, and by its very terms enforces the hallowing of the seventh day of the week. In response to my demand for an explicit Scripture statement for the substitution of Sunday in the place of the ancient rest day of the Lord, it was admitted that no such statement could be found.

Mr. Shouter.—Pardon me, sir, if I interrupt you by saying that we do not need a positive Scripture declaration authorizing the observance of Sunday instead of the Jewish Sabbath. We know that the work of redemption was a greater work than that of creation, and so we celebrate the day of Christ's resurrection,—the one on which our redemption was finished,—instead of the one on which the creation of the world was finished.

Mr. B.—Has the Lord anywhere told us that the work of redemption was greater than that of creation?

Mr. S.—No, sir; but we know some things of ourselves.

Mr. B.—Very good, we will not debate the comparative merits of redemption and creation. I will admit, for the sake of the argument, that you are right on that point. I will even go farther than that, and grant that if you see fit to do so, it is your privilege to hallow the first day of the week in honor of the resurrection of Christ and a finished redemption. Having done so, I inquire how your voluntary celebration of the Sunday releases you from the duty of observing the creation Sabbath also. It is not material to the issue whether or not redemption is greater than creation; the simple fact is this: God thought that his rest, after the completion of creation, was worthy of commemoration; and so he instituted the Sabbath to secure that end. He has never informed you or me or any one else that he has changed his mind on that point, or that he has repealed the law by which he sought to perpetuate the memory of his creative power, as manifested in that series of grand and wonderful acts by which he brought the world into being. So long as this is true, we cannot, without a direct insult to the wisdom and sovereignty of the most high God, set aside one of his most positive commands, because, forsooth, we happen to take the notion into our heads that there is some event more worthy of being celebrated by a day of rest than the one which God has thought deserving of such treatment. Institute, if you please, so many fast days and feast days and rest days as those that adorn the calendar of the Romish church, only be careful that you do not, like them, claim the power to command them under sin, and to change the decrees of the Creator of all things. If you reallyp. 339 must have one or half a dozen more sabbaths than God has ever given to you, see to it that you do not claim his authority for their institution, or that you do not neglect the only Sabbath that God has ever commanded.

Now that I have made it clear that, after admitting all you ask in reference to the dignity of the work of redemption as compared with that of creation, you are still held by the explicit and unalterable statute of Jehovah to rest on the seventh day, even though you should take it into your heads to make a Sabbath of your own out of the first day of the week, you will permit me to suggest that there are objections to your theory not yet touched upon. Let me enumerate several. In the first place, the work of redemption is not yet completed, and therefore it would be premature to commemorate its perfection by the institution of a memorial day. Redemption will not be completed until the work of atonement is ended, our sins blotted out, and our physical, as well as our moral, natures rescued from the consequences of sin. By reading the ninth and tenth verses of the fifth chapter of Revelation, you will learn that the grand redemption song of the saints will not be sung until the hosts of the redeemed of all ages are gathered into the city of God. In the second place, if redemption is to be commemorated at all by the appointment of a day of rest, it is by no means settled that the day of the resurrection is the one that should be designated for that purpose. If you have never looked the matter up, you will be astonished to find how many allusions there are in the Scriptures to the blood of Christ as the means of our redemption.

If you please, Maud, hand me from the bookcase there, a copy of the complete Scripture Concordance. Yes, thank you; that is it. I will read you some of the catch lines under the word “blood”: “We have redemption through his blood. Col. 1:14; Eph. 1:7. Thou hast redeemed us to God by thy blood. Rev. 5:9. Made them white in the blood of the Lamb. Rev. 7:14. They overcame him by the blood of the Lamb. Rev. 12:11. Church he hath purchased with his blood. Acts 20:28. A propitiation through faith in his blood. Rom. 3:25. Much more being now justified by his blood. Rom. 5:9. That he might sanctify the people with his blood. Heb. 13:12. And washed us from our sins in his blood. Rev. 1:5.” You have followed me as I have read these lines, and you see that they all point to the shed blood of Christ as the center of the Christian's hope. Without the shedding of Christ's blood there could have been no redemption. That once shed, everything else connected with the salvation of believers was assured.

Mr. S.—Does not Paul say (1 Cor. 15:14), “If Christ be not raised, then is our preaching vain, and your faith is also vain”?

Mr. B.—Yes, sir.

Mr. S.—Does not that prove, after all, that it is the resurrection to which we are indebted for our salvation?

Mr. B.—Not by any means, in the primary sense of the word. It is true that we could not be saved if Christ had not risen from the dead; but it is also true that had he never been crucified, he never could have risen from the dead; furthermore, the moment he was put to death it was just as certain that he would rise again as it was that he had died. When he expired on the cross, his part of the plan of redemption was so fully completed that its failure in any particular was an impossibility. At that point, the question was forever settled that he had overcome the world, the flesh, and the Devil. From that moment, it was rendered certain that his triumph was inevitable. Never again was he to be tempted or exposed to suffering or failure. His last words were: “It is finished;” and so it was. The resurrection was important, nay, indispensable; but it was at the crucifixion, after all, that the question was settled that Christ had safely passed the ordeal to which he had been subjected. Indeed, it was because he was faithful even unto death that he was able to take up his life again.

If you will read 1 Cor. 15:14 carefully, you will perceive that Paul is not discussing the relative importance of the crucifixion and the resurrection. There were some who denied the resurrection altogether, and in order to silence them, he reasoned that if the plan of salvation had failed in one particular, the apostles had proved themselves false witnesses; and, that, as a consequence, the hope of the Corinthians would be vain. The same thing would have been true of any other point, great or small, in God's plan. Or, to speak more correctly, if the apostles had been shown to be false witnesses, or if the plan of salvation that they represented had failed in a single respect, that would have proved that neither their mission nor the gospel system was of God; and, as a consequence, that all hopes built upon it were vain.

I might offer another reason why the day of the crucifixion rather than that of the resurrection should be distinguished by a memorial. It is this: It was on the day of his passion that Christ endured more than in all the rest of his ministry besides. Then it was that he bore the sins of the whole world. There is nothing in the history of the universe that is to be compared with Gethsemane and Calvary. There the God-man suffered untold agony and the humiliating death of the cross. In the resurrection, on the contrary, there was nothing endured, nothing sacrificed. It was a blessing instead of a curse; life instead of death; the regaining instead of the laying down of power; something that both the Father and the Son desired above everything else, instead of something against which every feeling of their natures revolted.

Mr. S.—Then you would not think the resurrection worthy of any sort of commemoration?

Mr. B.—Did I say so?

Mr. S.—No, sir; but I inferred that such was the case.

Mr. B.—Your inference, then, was wrong. What I urged was this: if we are to have a man-made institution for the honoring of but one day connected with the life and work of Christ in perfecting the plan of redemption, let it celebrate the day of the crucifixion, rather than that of the resurrection.

Mr. Surplice.—Brother Shouter will pardon me if I make a suggestion right here, which I think will help him out a little. There is no need of celebrating the crucifixion by appointing a day of rest for that purpose; for Christ instituted the Lord's supper to do that very thing.

Mr. S.—Thank you, Mr. Surplice, for that thought. It is a capital one. The crucifixion has its memorial, and of course the resurrection ought to have one likewise.

Mr. B.—Your idea seems to be this, gentlemen: Christ has appointed a memorial for the crucifixion, and therefore it does not need another one; he has not appointed one for the resurrection, therefore we ought to institute one.

Mr. S.—That, sir, is exactly what we mean.

Mr. B.—Then you hold that no event needs more than one memorial.

Mr. S.—Certainly, sir.

Mr. Dipper.—I perceive, gentlemen, that you are getting yourselves into a bad tangle. By admitting that no institution needs more than one memorial, you have virtually surrendered the whole question.

Mr. S.—How is that, sir. I don't see your point.

Mr. D.—You would if you were a Baptist.

Mr. Nolaw.—Yes, sir; or if you were a Disciple. You gentlemen thought I made a bad fist of my no-law argument; but I certainly never committed such a blunder as you have now.

Mr. S.—I don't know what you mean.

Mr. D.—Let me explain. Baptism commemorates the resurrection of Christ, just as certainly as the Lord's supper commemorates his death. You see, therefore, that if you admit that an event requires but one memorial, you thereby strike down Sunday observance; since it is unnecessary to set apart a day each week for the celebration of the resurrection if Christ has appointed baptism for that purpose.

Mr. Surplice.—You immersionists always run everything into the baptism question. I would like to have you show me some Scripture authority for your doctrine that baptism is a memorial of the Lord's resurrection.

Mr. D.—That is not at all difficult to do. Miss Maud, hand me the Bible, there, if you please. I will turn to the sixth chapter of Romans. Here is what I want in verses 3, 4, 5:—

“Know ye not, that so many of us as were baptized into Jesus Christ were baptized into his death? Therefore we are buried with him by baptism into death; that like as Christ was raised up from the dead by the glory of the Father, even so we also should walk in newness of life. For if we have been planted together in the likeness of his death, we shall be also in the likeness of his resurrection.”

If these verses are not conclusive, I will turn to others of like character.

Mr. Shouter.—Perhaps we shall have to admit that baptism is a memorial of the resurrection; but I can't see why it was necessary for you, gentlemen, to come to Mr. Biblist's assistance.

Mr. D.—We simply came to the rescue of the truth. Had I not made the point that I did make, furthermore, Mr. Biblist would have done it himself.

Mr. B.—Well, gentlemen, I am much obliged to Mr. Nolaw and Mr. Dipper for saying what they have said. It has secured to me a moment's rest, and they have done a better job perhaps than I could have done had I attempted to cover the same ground. I think that I must say right here, however, that Mr. Shouter is to be censured somewhat for the spirit in which he retorted on Mr. Dipper and Mr. Nolaw. I trust that in discussing these important questions, we shall not allow anything like a partisan feeling to enter our counsels.

It is now time to bring our deliberations to a close. Perhaps you, gentlemen, have nothing more to say upon this subject.

Mr. Westminster.—I have a view I would like to present to-morrow evening. I am not ready for it to-night. I would like to look up some authorities before broaching it.

Mr. B.—Very good. We will make your view the special order for our next session.

Battle Creek, Mich.