SHALL WE KEEP SATURDAY OR SUNDAY?

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 9, 1885

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 23.

Read the full edition

“SHALL WE KEEP SATURDAY OR SUNDAY?”

(Concluded.)
No Sunday advocate has learned his lesson thoroughly who does not endeavor to bind off his argument with the usual series of historical forgeries. Mr. R. is no exception to the rule, and hence he presents what he gravely asks us to believe is evidence that the early Christians from the days of the apostles onward, kept the first day of the week as the Sabbath, in place of the then discarded seventh day.
The first witness he brings forward is one which most people who have any regard for their intellectual reputation, are content to pass by; namely, an unknown Jew who fraudulently appropriated the name of “Barnabas,” to give credit to an otherwise contemptible production. The so-called “Epistle of Barnabas,” claims to be contemporary with the epistles of the New Testament, and to have been written by that Barnabas who was the companion of Paul; or rather this is what is claimed for it by Sunday advocates; and these facts must be established to make the testimony of any value whatever. But scholars now generally admit that the writing is spurious. Even Mr. R. admits that the title is wrong; that is, that it was not written by Barnabas, and yet strange to say, quotes it just the same in behalf of Sunday-keeping. Mosheim speaks of the author of that epistle as some Jew of “mean abilities and superstitious attachment to Jewish fables.” The epistle is also utterly condemned by Neander, Prof. Stuart, Dr. Killen, of Ireland, Prof. Hackett, Mr. Milner, Kitto, Sir Wm. Domville, of England, and Eusebius, the earliest of church historians in the fourth century. Its testimony is therefore of no value.
The Epistle of Ignatius to the Magnesians is next quoted, speaking of Christians as “no longer observing the Sabbath, but keeping the Lord’s day in which our life is sprung up by him.” This is just the kind of testimony that is needed, as it not only speaks of introducing the new institution but of discarding the old, which is just as essential. But, alas for our friends! the testimony is not genuine. Modern research has ascertained that the real Ignatius never wrote an epistle to the Magnesians. Dr. Killen says that in the sixteenth century fifteen letters were brought out, purporting to be the writings of Ignatius, the pastor of Antioch. Scholars forthwith pronounced eight of them to be forgeries. In the seventeenth century the remaining seven were subjected to further scrutiny, and four of the seven were discarded, leaving but three genuine; and the epistle to the Magnesians is not one of these. That epistle is therefore spurious. But strange to say, in the genuine copies of this spurious epistle, if we may so speak, the words which are quoted about discarding the Sabbath and keeping the Lord’s day, are not to be found. They have been interpolated by some subsequent imitator of the original forger. (See Kitto’s Encyclopedia.)
As was to be expected, the new manuscript which purports to have been lately discovered in Asia Minor, called “The Teaching of the Apostles,” is brought forward with much assurance on the Sunday question because it contains an expression which is translated “Lord’s day.” But in the original the word “day” is not to be found. It has to be inserted, just as in the epistle of Ignatius, to make it say anything for the Lord’s day. But even if it were there what would it prove?—Nothing; for it does not say which day of the week it was; and we have already shown that in John’s day the term referred to the Sabbath, the seventh day of the week; and if this writing is as early as it claims to be, it would be the same here. But it seems to be yet quite a question whether this document is genuine or not. Although Mr. R. hastens to quote it in behalf of his Sunday, we venture to say he would be very quiet about it on the subject of baptism. And the editor of the leading organ of the denomination to which Mr. R. belongs (Der Sendbote, Sept. 17, 1884), thus speaks of it:—
“The authenticity of this writing is, however, strongly questioned by German and English scholars. Nobody has as yet seen the original. And those who in the cloister tried to get sight of the original manuscript, were first deceived by the monks, and then met with a refusal. Whereas all other old manuscripts which the archives of the cloister contained, were at their disposal, the said manuscript was obstinately refused to them. Why so, if it really existed? More and more the conviction is making its way that this writing which has created so much excitement, and which, as many thought, would finish the Baptists, is nothing else but a counterfeit. As mentioned already, it is a fact that no one has seen the original manuscript as yet, and that heretofore every one has merely supposed the authenticity of the copy.”
The testimony of Pliny is next referred to, that Christians were accustomed to meet on a stated day before it was light, etc. But does he say which day it was?—No. If Christians were still observing the seventh day, as we must suppose that they were without any evidence to the contrary, would not the gatherings be reasonably explained on that ground?—Certainly. Now it is a well-known principle of logic that when a matter can be explained according to existing and established facts, resort should not be had to that which is new and before unheard of to explain it. We claim that Pliny’s stated day was the Sabbath; for we have evidence that Christians were at that time observing the Sabbath, but none whatever that they were observing Sunday. And Mosheim, although himself disposed to make the most of it he can for Sunday, nevertheless quotes the testimony of B. Just. Hen. Boehmer that we are to understand that this day was the same as the Jewish Sabbath. But Mr. R. is so sure this was Sunday and that this was the custom of Christians, that he even places Paul’s meeting at Troas (Acts 20:7), before light on Sunday, and has it continue through the entire day, and all the night following. Reader, is your credulity equal to the task of believing this?
The testimony of Justin Martyr is next introduced. This Mr. R. is willing to take as “a very explicit account regarding the Sunday-keeping of early Christians.” And what is it? Justin does not call Sunday the Lord’s day, does not say that they kept it as a Sabbath, does not say that the ancient Sabbath was discarded, but that on the day called Sunday they assembled to hear the memoirs of the apostles read. And doubtless they had at that early day begun to elevate the Sunday as a voluntary festival in the church. And that is all there is of it.
Then the testimony of Tertullian, A. D. 200, is referred to. And in him, we have the first writer who applies the term “Lord’s day” to Sunday. (See Kitto.) He, however, speaks of refraining from labor only enough to attend service, and says, according to Dr. Peter Heylyn, that they devoted the day “partly unto mirth and recreation, not to devotion altogether.”
Irenæus is quoted as saying that on the Lord’s day Christians keep the Sabbath. But nothing of this kind can be found in the writings of Irenæus, nor any fragment of them, nor in any quotation from him by other authors. This testimony is a modern acquisition.
Mr. R. now passes down to the Council of Nicæa, A. D. 325, an age so far down in the stream of apostasy that what we find there or subsequently can have but very little weight in determining our duty aside from the New Testament. He might have referred also to the story about “Dominicum servasti,” and the testimony of Theophilus, and Dionysius, and Melito; but on the ground that three frauds are better than seven, these may well be omitted.
The Council of Nicæa was called and presided over by Constantine. Two years before this, in A. D. 323, he had professed conversion to Christianity. And two years before that, in A. D. 321, he had made his famous Sunday law. We are sometimes accused of saying that Constantine introduced Sunday. We do not say so. The facts are these: Constantine made his Sunday law while yet a pagan, and made it in behalf of Sunday as a heathen festival; for Sunday was the chief day in the heathen world. The North British Review calls it, “The wild solar holiday of all pagan times.” Up to this time, as already noticed, the Sunday festival had been growing up in the Christian Church. Two years afterward occurred Constantine’s professed conversion. Then Sylvester, bishop of Rome, whose name now stands in the line of popes, conceived the idea of giving this Sunday festival a tremendous lift by the law of the empire. Hence he took Constantine’s pagan law, and made it enforce Sunday as a Christian institution.
Now you have the real basis of the Sunday institution in the Christian church. What will you call its parentage?—Paganism was its father, and Roman Catholicism its mother. But it has no Scripture in its support, and no indorsement in the practice of any inspired person. Neander pronounces it simply a festival in the Church. Alas! that misguided Protestants should have undertaken to defend a Romish festival which makes void one of God’s commandments, as a Christian institution.
Remember that for ages the Romish Church held all Christendom under its sway. It has deluded men into the belief and practice of many and grievous errors. Most of the denominations of the present day have arisen by breaking away from some of the errors and superstitions of that apostate church and that age of darkness. But some old Romish errors are still prevalent among them. Among these are sprinkling for baptism, and the Sunday-Sabbath in place of the Sabbath of the Lord. And the Reformation will not be complete till Sunday-keeping, with all other errors, is discarded.
The Lord will have a people at his coming who are worshiping him not in spirit only, but also in truth; whose belief will be in accordance with his holy word, and whose lives will be according to the pattern set us by our Lord. History shows that all through the gospel age there have been witnesses to the truth of the Sabbath of the Bible, and now a special work of reform on this very point is going forward, to prepare a people in this generation for his coming. Do you wish to be among the number? Then accept the truth as it shall be made known to you from the word of God, on the true Protestant ground that the Bible and the Bible alone is our rule of faith. The truth received into the heart, and obeyed in the life, will sanctify and make you free; and the Lord will save you in the coming day.