AdventAI

THE TEMPLE IN HEAVEN.

By W. H. Littlejohn

From Review and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 23., June 9, 1885

MR. WESTMINSTER STATES HIS VIEW OF THE SABBATH. HE IS GREATLY EMBARRASSED AT FINDING THAT HIS LOGIC WOULD COMPEL HIM TO RECOGNIZE THREE CHRISTIAN SABBATHS INSTEAD OF BUT ONE.

BY ELD. W. H. LITTLEJOHN.

Mr. Biblist.—I believe that I am relieved from the responsibility of leading out to-night. If I mistake not, it was arranged that Mr. Westminster should present for our consideration his theory relating to the change of the Sabbath.

Mr. Westminster.—I will proceed to my task without delay. I find upon reflection that I can state my conception of the matter in a very few words. It is this: We have in the example of Christ and the apostles ample authority for changing the Sabbath from the seventh to the first day of the week. It is demonstrable from the accounts in the New Testament that it was the custom of both Christ and the apostles to hallow the day of the resurrection. Christ met with them often on that day, evidently with the design of proving to them that it was holy time. After his ascension, the church, instructed by the apostles, made the first day of the week the regular occasion for public worship.

Mr. B.—As no one else ventures to make a remark, I think I will ask a few questions of Mr. Westminster. The first one is this: Is it said anywhere in the Scriptures that Christ and the apostles intended that their example should be construed to favor Sunday sanctity?

Mr. W.—I believe that there is no statement to that effect, sir.

Mr. B.—Then your whole theory rests upon an inference, does it not? and that inference is drawn, not from the words, but from the acts of Christ and the apostles?

Mr. W.—Yes, sir.

Mr. B.—Do you think that it is safe, as a rule, to base important doctrines upon mere inferences?

Mr. W.—Well, we are not in the habit of doing that; but in this case the inference is so manifestly correct that it is perfectly safe to deviate from the general rule.

Mr. B.—Well, let us see: I think you stated that Christ met with the disciples often on the first day of the week. Did you not?

Mr. W.—Yes, sir.

Mr. B.—Did Christ meet with them after his ascension?

Mr. W.—No, sir; not in person.

Mr. B.—How many days intervened between the resurrection and the ascension?

Mr. W.—Forty.

Mr. B.—In forty days there would ordinarily be five first days. In the case in question there were six, since the forty commenced with a first day. Now if the Lord had met with the disciples on every first day between his resurrection and ascension, that would not justify your declaration that he met with them often. The facts are, however, that it is impossible to prove that he ever met with them but once on Sunday after his resurrection; i.e., on the very day that he came forth from the grave.

Mr. Shouter.—Nonsense, Mr. Biblist; every one of the evangelists declare that Christ met with his disciples on the first day of the week.

Mr. B.—You do not catch the point, Mr. Shouter; I did not say that the meeting of Christ with the apostles was mentioned but once in the Gospels. I stated that it could not be proved that Christ met with them on more than one first day. It is true that every one of the evangelists speaks of that meeting; but that circumstance does not alter the fact that the meeting referred to by one and all of them was the same meeting.

Mr. W.—You admit that Christ met with his apostles on the day of his resurrection?

Mr. B.—Yes, sir.

Mr. W.—I think I can prove to you that Christ met with his disciples just one week after his meeting with them on the day of his resurrection. I read John 20:26: “And after eight days again his disciples were within, and Thomas with them; then came Jesus, the doors being shut, and stood in the midst, and said, Peace be unto you.”

Mr. B.—Remember, now, what I said was, that it could not be proved that Christ met with his disciples more than once on Sunday after his resurrection. To prove a thing is to establish it by incontestable evidence. If Mr. W. has done this in his attempt to show that the meeting spoken of in John 20:26 occurred on the first day of the week, then he has proved that the expression “after eight days” covers just one week. But it is difficult for a common mind to see how eight days can be crowded into a week which has but seven days. One would naturally infer that the meeting in question was one week and one day subsequent to the one from which the eight days are counted. This he will be the more likely to do if he will read 1 Chron. 9:25. Perhaps I had better turn to it. Here it is: “And their brethren, which were in their villages, were to come after seven days from time to time with them.” You will find by reading the context, that the persons alluded to were the divisions of the Levites who had charge of the temple. The verse quoted shows that these divisions remained on duty seven days alternately.

If you will read 2 Kings 11:4–9, you will ascertain that one company came in and another went out from the temple every Sabbath day. It seems, consequently, that according to Old Testament usage, the expression, “after seven days” covered the time that elapsed between two consecutive Sabbaths, or just seven days. Applying the same rule of measurement to the time mentioned in John 20:26, we find that the second meeting of Christ with the apostles, as already stated, probably took place one week and one day subsequent to the first; since, if in Bible times the words “after seven days” meant precisely one week, the expression, “after eight days,” would seem to mark off a period longer than that by one day. Admit this to be the case, and it follows that the second meeting of Christ with the apostles occurred on Monday instead of Sunday evening. The simple fact is, however, as it seems to me, there is so much uncertainty respecting the signification of such expressions as those under consideration, that it is impossible to decide at all times just what they mean. In Matt. 17:1, for example, we read: “And after six days Jesus taketh Peter, James and John his brother, and bringeth them up into an high mountain apart.” These six days are counted from the time at which a certain conversation was held between Christ and others.

In Luke 9:28 the inspired penman, when referring to the same event spoken of in Matt. 17:1, says that it occurred “about an eight days” after the very conversation from which Matthew computes his time. Thus it appears from the New Testament record, that “after six days” is tantamount, or nearly so, to eight days thereafter. But this being true, it is, to say the least, very far from being certain that the meeting of John 20:26 wasp. 355 held on the first day of the week. If it were not, then, Mr. Westminster, you have as the basis of your statement that it was the “custom” of Christ to meet with the disciples, after his resurrection, on the first day of the week, the isolated fact that he actually met with them on one first day between his crucifixion and his ascension. Now if I understand the signification of the term “custom,” it relates to a continued practice. If, therefore, it can be truthfully said that by meeting with the disciples on one first day, the Saviour did that which would justify the declaration that it was his custom to meet thus with his disciples after his resurrection, then I know nothing about the signification of language. Furthermore, if it is fairly inferable from the circumstance that Christ met with his disciples on one first day out of the six which fell between his death and his final departure to heaven, that he meant to teach by his example that it was holy time, then I do not understand the first principles of logic.

Mr. W.—You forget that I insist, sir, that he met with them upon two first days.

Mr. B.—No, sir; I do not forget that you insist upon that, neither do I forget that you cannot prove that he did meet with them on more than one first day. Nevertheless, were I to concede that the Lord did meet with his disciples on two first days, as you claim, it would not alter the result. If Christ had desired to throw the weight of his example in favor of Sunday sanctity, he would have met with his disciples on every one, instead of only two of the six first days that intervened between his death and his final separation from his followers. His failure to do so is proof that he had no such design as is attributed to him. Again, if he had intended, by meeting with his disciples on the first day of the week, to teach that it was holy time, then he would have been very careful not to meet with them on any other day of the week, lest they should conclude that it also should be regarded as a Sabbath.

Mr. W.—Are you sure that he did meet with the disciples on any other day of the week than Sunday?

Mr. B.—Sure of it? Why, I am just as sure of it as I am that inspiration is trustworthy. In Acts 1:1–9 we have the account of our Lord’s ascension. At that time there were a large number of disciples present. Our Lord discoursed to them for a time, and then passed upward out of their sight. As he did so, however, he lifted up his hands and blessed them. In the 21st chapter of John we read of a visit which the Master made to the apostles at the Sea of Tiberias.

Mr. W.—How do you know, sir, but that both of these meetings transpired on the first day of the week?

Mr. B.—Well, that is a fair question, and I will endeavor to answer it candidly. How many days were there between the resurrection of Christ and his ascension?

Mr. W.—Just forty, sir, according to the 1st chapter of Acts, which you have already quoted.

Mr. B.—Correct. Now will some one tell me on what day of the week the fortieth day after Christ’s resurrection would fall?

Mr. Surplice.—It fell on Thursday, of course, sir. We Episcopalians are posted on that subject. You know that we annually celebrate ascension day.

Maud.—Yes, father, Mr. Surplice is right. I have just figured it out on this paper, as you see: Forty days are five weeks and five days. Five weeks from, and including the Sunday on which Christ arose, would have terminated with a Saturday. Five days more would have reached to, and included Thursday.

Mr. B.—Well done, Maud. I wish you were as good in theology as you are in figures. Thursday, then, was the day on which Christ met with his disciples on one of the two instances which I have cited. I am perfectly willing that Mr. Westminster should insist, if he likes, that the last of the two took place on Sunday. If he does so, however, I do not see how he can ever indorse the modern theory that Sunday fishing is reprehensible.

Mr. W.—I don’t see your point, sir.

Mr. Nolaw.—Don’t see it? I should think any one might see that. Why, if it was Sunday on which Christ met with his disciples at the Sea of Tiberias, then it cannot be wrong to fish on Sunday; since, at the time in question, Peter, John, and others were fishing, and the Lord approved their conduct by telling them where to cast their nets, and by working a miracle to secure for them a large haul.

Mr. W.—W-e-l-l, we shall have to admit that Mr. Biblist is right in stating that Christ met with the disciples, after his resurrection, on two week days.

Mr. B.—I thank you for that concession. In making it you virtually yield all the other points at issue.

Mr. W.—How is that?

Mr. B.—How is that? It would seem that a gentlemen of your capacity should have no need to ask such a question. You rest your whole argument for Sunday sanctity, so far as Christ is concerned, not upon his words, but upon his example in meeting with his disciples on two first days. I have proved that he met with his disciples on Thursday, and on a certain fishing day, both of which days you now admit to have been secular in their character. Now, therefore, in order to be consistent with yourself, you must acknowledge either that the simple circumstance that Christ met with his disciples on a certain day does not prove that he meant to signalize it as a Sabbath, or else you must adopt the conclusion that we have three Sabbaths, all of which were made in this manner; viz., the resurrection day, or Sunday; the day of the ascension, or Thursday; and an unknown day, or the one on which the disciples went fishing.

Mr. N.—You will believe by and by what I told you in the beginning, gentlemen.

Mr. Shouter.—What was it that you told us in the beginning? I have no recollection of anything that you said, except some very foolish remarks which you made to the effect that God instituted a law containing ten commandments, and then abolished all ten of the commandments in order to get rid of one of them. I don’t think we shall ever believe that.

Mr. B.—To-night I have disposed of the example of Christ himself, so far as it relates to that feature of it which, it is claimed, favors Sunday sanctity. I was about to say that I would leave the matter there for the present; but I think that I must add a word respecting the example of Christ on the other side of this question. The only first day that Mr. Westminster has really been able to point out as one on which the Lord met with his disciples, was the one on which he arose from the dead. At the close of that day he joined them in an upper room in Jerusalem, as Mr. Westminster says, in order to teach them by his example that the day on which they were convened was holy time.

Now, if Mr. Westminster is right in this, of course the Lord would not have allowed himself to do anything that would have been inconsistent with such a purpose. But what are the facts? Several hours before the night meeting in question,—as you will find by reading the 24th chapter of Luke,—two of the very same disciples whom the Lord had met in the Jerusalem chamber, were on the highway from that city to Emmaus, a little town distant from Jerusalem about seven and a half miles. As they were walking, and talking about the mystery concerning the resurrection of Christ, the latter, disguised as a wayfaring man, joined them on the road and accompanied them clear to Emmaus. That place reached, he made as though he would have gone farther; but they constrained him to tarry with them. This he at last consented to do, and revealed himself to them in the breaking of bread at supper time. Immediately the two disciples returned to Jerusalem to communicate the facts to their brethren. In all, therefore, they traveled fifteen miles that day. On one-half of the journey, or thereabout, they were accompanied by the risen Lord. What a splendid opportunity for the latter to inform them that the day on which they were traveling was holy time! Not a word of this kind, however, fell from his lips. Furthermore, had he told them so, his words and his deeds would not have been in accord. Not only did he travel with them to Emmaus, but when he reached that place he made as though it was his intention to go further.

Now I have this question to ask of Mr. Westminster: Did Christ, in assuming the garb of a wayfaring man and traveling in the company of the two disciples for several miles, without rebuking them for their desecration of the first so-called Christian Sabbath, throw his example in favor of that institution or against it?

Mr. W.—W-e—w-e—w-e-l-l, sir, I never looked at the matter in that light before. I should want to reflect for a time before answering your question.

Mr. B.—It is of no use, gentlemen; you might as well give up first, as last, your theory that the example of Christ favors first-day sanctity. That which proves too much, proves nothing at all. If the simple fact that Christ met with the disciples on the first day of the week converted it into holy time, then a similar act on his part would produce a similar effect on any other day; but, as we have seen, if this be true, then we have three Christian Sabbaths instead of one. Again, if Christ in meeting with his disciples on the first day of the week intended to lay the foundation for Sunday observance, he would have been very careful that his conduct, during the whole of the day on which that meeting occurred, should be in harmony with such a design; whereas, the fact is that he made the day in question one of common travel.

To-morrow evening we will look up the record of the early church in the matter of Sunday-keeping.

Battle Creek, Mich.