AdventAI

SWINE EATING FROM A SCRIPTURAL STAND-POINT.

By G. G. Rupert

From Review and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 23., June 9, 1885

BY ELD. G. G. RUPERT.

It is hard to break off habits, especially those of appetite. But it is strange that people will try to sustain practices by the Scriptures that in common conversation they will admit to be unhealthful and unchristian. For thus will people talk in reference to the use of swine’s flesh. Science and experience, say they, may be against the usage of eating swine; but they will try to sustain the practice by the Bible, even as the drunkard says the Bible teaches the use of intoxicating drinks. If these things be so, then the Bible is a dangerous book, and we should discard it. I, for one, do not believe the Bible teaches the practice of hurtful appetites, and will endeavor to examine a few of the strong texts relied upon for the use of swine.

1 Tim. 4:4: “For every creature of God is good and nothing to be refused if it be received with thanksgiving.” How much does “every creature” embrace? Mark 16:15: “Go ye into all the world, and preach the gospel to every creature.” Does this mean that we shall preach to all the animal kingdom,—horses, cattle, alligators, swine, etc.? No; it must be in a limited sense, and depends on the thing spoken of, which is people. So the text quoted by Timothy, to take it as some would have it, would embrace men; then the cannibal would be justified. We can see that it must only cover such things as are elsewhere allowed, which another text, recorded in Rom. 14:5, 4, makes still plainer: “One man esteemeth one day above another. Another esteemeth every day alike.” Some have taken this text to do away with any Sabbath, just as some are using the other to uphold the use of swine. But every commentary of note will testify that it has a limited sense. So it is used in Ex. 16:21. It there tells us that they gathered manna every morning; and verse 27 shows that they went out on the Sabbath, and there was none. Hence, in the phrases “every creature” and “every morning,” only the things and time God had formerly instructed us in are referred to. To illustrate: My brother wishes me to help him on the farm next week. I reply, “I can help you every day next week.” Would he understand that I would help him on the Sabbath?—No.

Let us now examine another text. Christ says (Mark 7:15): “There is nothing from without a man that, entering into him, can defile him; but the things which come out of him, those are they that defile the man.” The argument in this text rests on the word “nothing.” How many times I have heard men quote this text when tobacco, pork, whisky, etc., were spoken against. Let us see if there is anything that could defile the body? Daniel would not defile himself with the king’s meat. Dan. 1:8. “Whether therefore ye eat or drink, or whatsoever ye do, do all to the glory of God.” 1 Cor. 10:31. “For ye are bought with a price; therefore glorify God in your body and in your spirit, which are God’s.” 1 Cor. 6:20. We are to glorify God in our bodies as well as our minds. How can we do this? The apostle informs us of one way, in 2 Cor. 7:1: “Having therefore these promises, dearly beloved, let us cleanse ourselves from all filthiness of the flesh and spirit, perfecting holiness in the fear of God.” Now, if our bodies are not cleansed, what condition are we in?—Unholy, as the last text teaches.

Let us look at one more text, which will show decisively that using anything unclean will defile the body. 1 Cor. 3:16, 17: “Know ye not that ye are the temple of God, and that the Spirit of God dwelleth in you? If any man defile the temple of God, him shall God destroy; for the temple of God is holy, which temple ye are.”

We have now established two points beyond dispute: 1. There are things that can be eaten that defile the body. 2. In order to acquire perfect holiness, laws of diet must be observed. These points also establish the fact that when our Lord said that nothing going into the mouth can defile the man, the word had its limit, even as the expression every creature, which we examined at the outset.

When certain statements are made in the Scriptures that seem to be contradictory, why not give to the Bible the same chance we give to man? namely, let it be its own interpreter. Do this, and we have no trouble. “Well,” says one, “did not the Lord tell Peter to eat all manner of ‘four-footed beasts and creeping things’?” If this be so, Peter would have experienced quite a change in his diet; for he answered that nothing common or unclean had ever entered his mouth. We need not argue at any length concerning this scripture. If the reader will turn and read the tenth chapter of Acts, he will readily see that Peter held that the Gentiles were unclean and would not be saved; and the Lord takes this method of showing him that the way was now open for them to come in. We have no fears of seekers for truth stumbling over the vision given to Peter if they will turn and read the chapter in full.

There is still another text to explain in this connection, found in 1 Cor. 10:25, 27: “Whatsoever is sold in the shambles, that eat, asking no question for conscience’ sake.” “If any of them that believe not bid you to a feast, and ye be disposed to go, whatsoever is set before you, eat, asking no question for conscience’ sake.”

I once had my chart of ten commandments hanging up, preaching from it; and after I had finished, a Baptist minister arose, and said we could not keep that law. I said to him, Cannot you keep the eighth commandment? “Yes.” (He was obliged to say so to this commandment at least.) Cannot you keep the seventh? “Yes.” And he soon saw that such a position would not answer in a public audience. So it is with the above text. I asked an opposer of health reform, who made use of the text under consideration, if he would carry it out if bidden to dine with the Indian on dog flesh? with some of the Southern people on alligator? or even with his neighbors on certain occasions? His answer was, No. So we say, No!

By reading the connection, we learn that the apostle is here speaking of meat that had been sacrificed to idols. Some had the idea that it was thus made unclean. This scripture teaches that it did not affect the meat in any way; but if it would cause a brother to offend, the command was, not to eat of it. 1 Cor. 8:13. Now, if the apostle was willing to lay aside the use of good meat in order not to offend his brother, we should surely be willing to leave off the use of that which God has forbidden us to eat. As sure as the explanation of the above texts is correct, the New Testament does not tell us that we can eat the flesh of swine. Let us now see what the Old Testament teaches about the matter.

Some conclude that swine was forbidden only to the Jews. But we read in Gen. 7:2 of clean and unclean beasts. By this we learn that the law of unclean and clean beasts did not originate with Moses any more than did the ceremonial law, or the moral law of God. All are referred to in Genesis as being in existence, but afterwards given to Moses, and recorded by him. In Lev. 11 and Deut. 14, the use of swine is plainly forbidden, it being unclean. The Jews have largely obeyed God in this respect, and have been greatly benefited by it in health and intellect, as all will admit. In Isa. 66, there is a prophecy which applies to this dispensation. In verse 3 we learn that those who continued to sacrifice as a type of the crucifixion to come, were as much of an abomination to the Lord as if they had offered swine’s blood. As sure as that verse applies to this dispensation, so sure the swine is an abomination in this dispensation, in the same sense that it was an abomination in the Old Testament.

Now read verses 15–17, which need no comment to show when they apply. You there see those that eat it are classed with those who eat various abominable things, such as the heathen do, and that they will be consumed when the Lord comes.

There is also the parable of the “Prodigal Son.” As he left his father’s house he went to the lowest calling, that of feeding swine. This parable shows how the Saviour still regarded these things. And there is the case of the devils’ desiring to enter the swine, when they were drowned. It seems Satan is their friend, at least. Now, why people that have light on these things will insist on eating such flesh is more than I can tell. A certain denomination in Georgia, where I have been, gave a feast, for which twelve hogs were slain. Such feasts might do to serve Baal, but not God.

Look at the animal, as it wanders from place to place devouring every unclean thing. See it wallow in filth. See many of the children that eat it breaking out with scrofula. Inquire of any reliable school-teacher whether children that live largely on pork are active to learn their lessons. Ask your physicians why dyspeptics are not allowed to use it. Why are persons exposed to contagious diseases not allowed to eat it? Examine these points and many more; and then on the end of it all tell me the Bible justifies its use! For shame! to accuse the Bible of such instruction. It is unhealthful. (Bible.) It is unclean, or filthy. (Bible.) It is an abomination. (Bible.) It defiles our bodies, injures our minds, benumbs our spirituality, offends our brethren, and displeases God. May the Lord help our brethren professing present truth, to lay it aside now never to use it again.