ANSWERS BY W. H. LITTLEJOHN.
341.—SABBATH DAYS WHICH ARE SHADOWS.
D. N. M.: 1. It is true that the word “days” in Col. 2: 16 is a supplied word. This fact, nevertheless, in no way affects the perpetuity of the Sabbath, as the word translated “Sabbath” in the original is in the plural. Leaving out the word “days,” the passage would instruct us not to allow any one to judge us respecting the Sabbaths which are a shadow cast by Christ the body. Now the weekly Sabbath never was a shadow of Christ or anything else connected with the plan of the atonement, as it came into being before man fell. The Sabbaths to which the apostle alludes in Col. 2: 14–16 were the ceremonial Sabbaths of the Mosaic law. You will find them mentioned in Lev. 23. They were celebrated once each year, and perished at the cross because there the type met its antitype; whereas Isaiah represents the weekly Sabbath as existing even in the new earth. Isa. 66: 23.
2. On the morality of the Sabbath commandment, see the article entitled, “The Temple in Heaven,” in REVIEW of May 19, 1885.
342.—CALL NO MAN FATHER.
S. O. J.: 1. Matt. 23: 9 was not designed to teach that we should not call him “father” who sustains that relation to us in this world. The Scriptures themselves frequently apply that title to those who are parents. It was the design of Christ simply to forbid the application to men of learning or piety, epithets too reverential in their character. When we speak of a natural parent as a father, it is understood that we mean merely that he sustains the relation of parent to us. When we give to a man the title of “Father” because of some intellectual or spiritual superiority which he is supposed to possess over other men, we do him a reverence which approaches worship. Perhaps the text in question would condemn the use of the modern D. D.
2. The coming spoken of in Matt. 10: 23, probably refers to a journey through the cities of Judea that Christ intended to make about the time that the disciples were making a similar journey. He did not design to remain as long in any city as they did, and therefore they were instructed not to tarry in any town that would not receive them, but to pass on to some other place; for even though they should act upon this principle they would not get through all the cities of the land before Christ should complete his circuit of the same.
343.—GRADUATED PUNISHMENT.
A. Y.: Punishment is not always equivalent to suffering. It is sometimes tantamount to loss, or deprivation. To illustrate: There are certain kinds of poisons which, if administered in the proper quantities, will cause the death of the one to whom they are given without inflicting upon him the least pain. Not only so, but his sensations while passing away may be of the most pleasing character. Suppose, now, the State were to enact that a certain class of offenders, say murderers, should be compelled to take this kind of poison in sufficient quantities to destroy life; would it not be true that the men perishing in this way would be punished for their crimes? If so, punishment does not necessarily involve pain, as in the cases referred to there would be no pain, but simply the loss or deprivation of life. Again, the State might decree that the criminals of a particular order should suffer a mixed punishment, being tortured for a time and then put to death in the painless manner indicated above.
The same principles hold substantially in regard to the punishment that God has prescribed for incorrigible sinners. They are to suffer eternal death, or everlasting punishment. Death results in the loss of life, and is therefore a punishment in itself. Eternal death is equivalent to eternal punishment because it inflicts a loss that is eternal. The infliction of the penalty of death, to begin with, necessarily involves the destruction of life. God has decreed that those who are subjected to the second death shall not perish instantly, but be brought to that condition as the result of the pangs which they will endure in the lake of fire. This arrangement renders it possible for him to graduate the punishment which each will undergo, by making his suffering in the lake of fire long or short, according as the offenses committed were light or aggravated. Luke 12: 46–48; Rev. 20: 4–10.
Take, for example, two individuals, one of whom has been a pirate upon the high seas and murdered men by scores, while the other has taken the life of but one man. Now suppose that the Lord should compel the first of these to endure the torments of the lake of fire for many weeks before becoming extinct, and the latter to suffer the same torments for a few days only before forever ceasing to be. It would then be true that the punishment of these men would be everlasting punishment, and that it had been graduated according to their deserts; for while both are to enter the state of death, and remain there eternally, the punishment which each experiences before entering that condition is so regulated that he who was the most criminal in character endures enough more pain than the other one did, to compensate for the difference in moral character. You will see from this, therefore, that God, by making the penalty of sin cover both the act of dying the second death and remaining in the condition of death forever, is able to adjust punishment to every particular case. This he could not have done, however, had the penalty been, as some claim that it is, simply the loss of life; for had it been such, the most hardened transgressor and the offender in the slightest degree would have met with equal loss and endured no suffering whatever.
344.—THE SEED CALLED IN ISAAC.
M. M.: I do not discover any want of harmony in Gen. 21: 12, 13. Both Isaac and Ishmael were the seed of Abraham. Sarah wished to have Ishmael and his mother cast out in order to prevent the former from becoming heir with Isaac. The Lord counseled Abraham to take the advice of Sarah, saying that in Isaac the seed of Abraham should be called; but that Ishmael should be made a great nation because he also was Abraham’s seed. The point is this: Ishmael was to be made a great nation because he was the son of Abraham by a bondwoman; but his posterity were not to become the heirs of the promises made to Abraham personally, since these were to be reserved to the descendants of Isaac, who was the son of Abraham by Sarah; that is, the descendants of Isaac were to constitute the nation through which the Messiah should be developed, who should possess the promised land, etc., etc. The seed of Ishmael were not by this means excluded from the benefits of the plan of salvation; but they were simply debarred from enjoying the honor of being made the special instruments in perfecting that plan.