From the very beginning of the Sabbath cause, as represented by S. D. Adventists, it has been its fortune to encounter the opposition of a few men who have seemed to be actuated by especial bitterness against it. These men have exerted every effort to tear down the work, and arrest its progress. All manner of sophistry has been brought into play. Scarcely a misrepresentation has been left untried. They have watched assiduously to hedge up the way where it was likely to make advancement. They have grown frantic over its successes, and have apparently been able to be happy only when they imagined they were doing something effectual to prevent its prosperity. Yet despite all their efforts, and regardless of the chagrin which they have been unable to conceal, the work has gone steadily forward.
In the early part of 1862, nearly a quarter of a century ago, A. N. Seymour published eleven questions,—weak, illogical, indecisive questions,—on the subject of the Sabbath. These, through a marvelous display of tautology, he afterward expanded to fifty, gave them the pompous title of “unanswerable arguments” and republished them to the world. In May, 1862, J. M. Aldrich answered these so-called arguments through the Review, patiently wading through the entire list, and exposing one by one their utter nothingness. These articles were immediately issued in pamphlet form, and in the course of the following two or three years the entire edition of some 1500 or 2000 copies was sold. What little stir had ever been raised by the “questions” had then subsided, the “unanswerable arguments,” all answered, sunk into oblivion; and there they have rested in their native imbecility till the present year.
In January last Mr. Seymour again came forward in the World’s Crisis, with the same old exploded eleven questions, piously exhorting that paper to put forth its best efforts to destroy seventh-day influence. And now we understand he sets up the surprising claim that these questions have never been answered nor even noticed by any observer of the seventh day. How shall we account for so astounding an assertion? We can do it only on one ground. Some three years since, Mr. S. was thrown from a cutter and quite seriously injured; and we have been inclined to account for his course in this matter on the charitable ground that that injury upon the head had entirely destroyed his memory of previous events.
We had not deemed the matter worthy of any attention, till two or three correspondents, unaware probably of its past history, wrote to inquire about it, and hence we notice it. It is not our design, however, to enter into any argument on the matter of the questions. Bro. Kimball, of Vermont, pays sufficient attention to them in another column; yet, in passing, we cannot forbear calling the attention of the reader to the utter foolishness of the effort, as illustrated in the following. The questions are all after this sort: “Where is there one command of God to keep holy the seventh-day Sabbath, prior to the time of Moses?” “Where is there one command of God to any of the Gentile nations?” etc. “Where does the Comforter, or Spirit of truth, command” so and so? “Where does Paul teach” so and so? Thus the questions drive on, every one beginning with the word, “Where.” Now mark, in the conclusion, a profundity of wisdom which is enough to make the seven sages of Greece turn somersaults in their coffins. He says: “I hereby offer a reward of fifty dollars to any seventh-day-Sabbath-keeper who will, with God’s word in their hands attach a ‘thus saith the Lord,’ to the affirmative of the above questions.”
We imagine it will require something in no wise inferior to certain styles of no-law and no-Sabbath logic to tell us what is the “affirmative” and what the negative, of such questions as he proposes. Take, for instance, the first one: “Where is there one command of God to keep holy the seventh-day Sabbath prior to the time of Moses?” What is the affirmative of this question? Suppose one should say, “I affirm” on this question, and another should say, “I deny.” What does he affirm or deny? One affirms that “where is there one command,” etc., and the other denies that “where is there one command,” etc. Wonderfully intelligent, isn’t it? Yet one must attach a “thus saith the Lord” to the “affirmative” of the questions to secure the wonderful reward of fifty dollars! A very prudent offer, indeed.
But it is another part of the subject which we set out to notice. Mr. S. says: “These questions have led eight ministers, to my knowledge, out of the seventh-day Sabbath, and scores of private members, and kept hundreds out of the seventh-day delusion.”
This reminds us of the little boy who, just as an eclipse was coming on, discharged a six-inch popgun at the moon, and waited to see the result. The eclipse increased, and the moon disappeared. “There!” said he, “don’t you see I have knocked the moon clear out of sight?” What could be more conclusive? He discharged his popgun, and the moon went out of sight! What could have caused it if not his popgun! So Mr. S. having discharged his questions, is just conceited enough to imagine that they are the supreme cause of all further religious agitation in the world; and when he hears of a person giving up the Sabbath, he says in great glee, “There! don’t you see what my questions are doing?” We affirm that not a solitary minister has given up the Sabbath on account of those questions. If he has, it only shows that he has dwarfed his mental caliber to that degree of diminution as to make him of no use to this cause or any other.
Mr. S. set out to “destroy seventh-day influence.” To this end he and his co-laborers have exerted themselves. How gladly would they have annihilated it. But what has been its history since they began their warfare upon it? When the wonderful “questions” appeared in 1862, which were forever to sweep away this seventh-day delusion, we had no Conference organizations. May 20, 1863, the General Conference was organized. We then had one office of publication and one paper, besides the youth’s paper. We had no educational institutions, no tract societies, and no missions. Our list of publications was limited, our laborers few, and funds insignificant. What the membership then was we have no means of knowing. It was not till 1867, four years after the General Conference was organized, that a statistical summary was given. The figures then stood thus: Ministers 28, licentiates 10, churches 160, membership 4,320, funds $18,661. These figures would have been considerably less in 1862. Right there was just the time to stop this cause, if it was ever going to be stopped; and there Mr. S. ruthlessly hurled his eleven deadly questions against it in all its weakness.
But somehow there wasn’t any wonderful shock produced. The seventh-day doctrine kept spreading, and the work enlarging. The same year, notwithstanding the “questions,” State Conferences were organized in New York and Minnesota, and a second office building was erected. In 1863, Conferences were organized in Ohio and Vermont, and in 1864 in Iowa. In 1866 the publication of the Health Reformer, now Good Health, was commenced, and the Health Institute was founded. In 1867 the Maine Conference was organized. In 1868 camp-meetings were introduced, and a mission opened on the Pacific Coast. In 1871 Conferences in New England, Illinois, and Wisconsin were organized; and the first State tract and missionary society was established in New England. Between that and 1874, State T. and M. societies were organized in New York, Michigan, Vermont, Illinois, Minnesota, and Maine, and a State Conference in California. In 1874 the Educational Society was organized; and Eld. Andrews opened the mission in Switzerland, and Conferences were organized in Nebraska and Indiana, and a T. and M. society in the latter State. In 1875 the Pacific Publishing Association was incorporated, and Kansas Conference organized. In 1876 the publication of the French paper at Bâle was begun, a General T. and M. Society, and Kentucky and Missouri Conferences organized. In 1877 the Scandinavian mission was opened by Eld. Matteson, and in 1878 the English mission, by Eld. Loughborough.
But we need not further follow the unfoldings of this work. Suffice it to say that we now have twenty-eight Conferences, five missions, one hundred and seventy-six ministers, one hundred and forty-five licentiates, seven hundred and five churches, 18,702 members, and yearly funds of $105,543.41. We have offices of publication in Oakland and Healdsburg, Cal., South Lancaster, Mass., Great Grimsby, England, Bâle, Switzerland, and Christiana, Norway, Periodicals and books are issued besides the English, in French, German, Danish, Swedish, Italian, and Roumanian. The central office has grown to be the most comprehensively equipped office of any in the State of Michigan; eight power presses are constantly turning out seventh-day literature, and for the year ending Nov. 1, 1884, 57,367,851 pages of books, tracts, and pamphlets were printed.
Meanwhile where have been these “unanswerable arguments,” these safeguards against seventh-day delusion, these all-potent weapons against its progress?—Slumbering for nearly a quarter of a century in ignominious obscurity. We give the foregoing statistics simply to show that the seventh-day work has not been very materially retarded by them. We have now more ministers in the State of Michigan alone than there were in all the field when Mr. S. first published his “questions,” and three times as many licentiates in this one State, as could be found in all the States together at that time. The “questions” do not seem to work very satisfactorily in preventing people from receiving the seventh-day views. And the reason is obvious. Rarely will people investigate these subjects, unless they are people of sufficient intelligence to be able to detect at once that which is sophistical and shallow.