THE TEMPLE IN HEAVEN

3%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 19, 1885

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 20.

Read the full edition

THE TEMPLE IN HEAVEN.

THE CONSEQUENCES OF THE NO-LAW THEORY DISCUSSED AT LARGE; THE FOURTH COMMANDMENT SHOWN TO BE BOTH MORAL AND POSITIVE; THE TESTIMONY OF CHRIST INTRODUCED.
BY ELD. W. H. LITTLEJOHN.
Mr. Biblist.—You will recollect, gentlemen, that when we separated last evening I was in the act of showing that if Mr. Nolaw’s theory that the ten commandments as a code were abolished, and yet that nine of them are still made obligatory upon the race through the medium of moral law, the change was unfortunate, and the situation deplorable. In doing this I had called attention to the advantages offered by written over those presented by unwritten laws, making reference to the fact, that unless statutes are carefully written out, uncertainty is liable to arise respecting what is, or what is not, required of the individual, thus exposing him to the possibility of being punished for doing what he really thought he ought to do, or neglecting to do that which he was not aware had been required at his hands. The correctness of the position which I was seeking to maintain is so obvious that there can be no doubt respecting it. If it be not demonstrable, then the boasted superiority of modern civilization over barbarism in the matter of its carefully prepared statutes for the instruction and protection of the citizen, is a myth; and it were better, while preserving our judges and our prisons, to abolish our legislatures, and dispense with our written codes as something which, though very expensive, is utterly superfluous.
You see the bearing, gentlemen, of the point which I made upon the view advocated by Mr. Nolaw. God never makes a retrograde movement. Having come down to this world for the special purpose of giving to its inhabitants a written law embodying a concise yet comprehensive statement of that which they were forbidden to do or required to perform, he would never commit the blunder of withdrawing that law so long as it continued to express his will concerning them.
Mr. Nolaw.—You forget, sir, that I claim that in the particular of the Sabbath, the ten commandments do not express the will of God respecting us.
Mr. B.—Then your position is that God repealed the ten commandments in order to get rid of the fourth one in the series.
Mr. N.—Well, yes, that seems to be the only one that we do not need.
Mr. B.—A singular proceeding, indeed, would that be on the part of God. It reminds me of an incident in the experience of one of our ministers who was answering from the desk the very objection under consideration. It so happened that he had recently injured one of his fingers. At the time in question it was inclosed in a cot. He lifted his hand and addressed to the people these words:— “Suppose that I were to go to a physician, and ask him to remove by a surgical operation this wounded finger of mine, and he should insist that it was necessary to amputate all the others on both hands along with it, in order to get rid of that one, what would you say of the sanity of such a man?”
You can imagine the effect of the illustration upon the people to whom it was presented. Nothing more was necessary to satisfy them that in case God had discovered that one of the commandments of the decalogue had ceased to meet the requirements of the race, while the others were exactly adapted to their needs, he would have abolished that one, leaving the others still in force. You will perceive also that in doing so he would not only follow the dictates of reason, but also that his action would accord with that of human legislators under like circumstances.
Now that I have demonstrated the absurdity of Mr. Nolaw’s method of getting the fourth commandment out of the way, I wish to show that his reasons for desiring to do so are not satisfactory. He discriminates against that commandment on the ground that it is not moral in its nature, and therefore differs from the other commandments.
Maud.—I wish you would tell me, father, what you mean by a moral commandment.
Mr. B.—We speak, Maud, of laws as being of two kinds, positive and moral. A positive law depends for its existence upon express enactment; that is, it continues to be binding only so long as it is enforced by the positive command, either written or oral, of the law maker. A moral law, on the contrary, continues in force even where there is no positive statute for it to rest upon. It is founded on the nature and relations of things; and its existence can be discerned through an exercise of the human reason. Murder, for example, must be wrong, because it is destructive of life contrary to the interest of the individual and of society.
Returning now to the point under consideration when Maud propounded her question, I proceed to inquire whether the Sabbath commandment belongs to the category of moral or that of positive laws. I think that we shall find upon investigation that it partakes in part of the nature of both of these kinds of law. It is positive because there is nothing in it which would enable us to decide that the seventh, to the exclusion of every other, day of the week, should be made a Sabbath. It is moral because it is demonstrable from the very constitution of things, that man needs just such a Sabbath as the fourth commandment provides and enforces. Rest, for example, on one day in seven is absolutely necessary to the highest physical development of both man and beast. Actual experiment, made over and over again, has settled this point beyond dispute. Both men and animals will accomplish more work during the year when working but six days out of seven, than they will when working every day in the week. Incessant labor sooner or later ends in the destruction of life; whereas, when interrupted by the weekly Sabbath, it preserves vigor, and prolongs existence. The French tried the experiment of devoting every tenth instead of every seventh day to rest. Other nations have for a time substituted other cycles; but nearly all of them have returned to the practice of resting on each seventh day as being best adapted to the needs of the race.
Passing from the physical to the spiritual side of man’s nature, again we find that a hebdomadal or weekly Sabbath exactly meets the demands of his being. Were we to work every day in the week, little or no progress could be made in religious things. The rush of business and the fatigue, intellectual and physical, which result therefrom, are most unfavorable to spiritual growth. The man who labors each day from the rising to the setting of the sun, returns at night to his home weary and so late that he would find little time or inclination for self-examination, prayer, reading, or worship of a public nature. Indeed, it is almost certain that were the weekly Sabbath to be abolished, the nations would relapse into barbarism. Without the preaching of the word, conversions would necessarily be very few in number. “How, then,” says the apostle in Rom. 10:14, “shall they call on Him in whom they have not believed? and how shall they believe in him of whom they have not heard? and how shall they hear without a preacher?” Take away the rest day, and you have removed an institution which, more than all others combined, favors the proclamation of the truth.
Without a definite Sabbath which all can observe at one and the same time, ministers of the gospel could not be supported in their work, and churches could not be erected for the public proclamation of the word. In order to meet the expense incident to the support of the ministry, it is not only necessary that men should rest one day in seven, but it is also required that this should be done uniformly on the same day. Where all rest at the same time in a community of moderate size, one preacher of the word can minister to all, thus making the cost of his support comparatively light to each. On the other hand, should men celebrate the Sabbath on different days of the week, the expense of maintaining public worship on the days thus hallowed would become insupportable. Again, the interests of business demand that all men should rest on the same day. Were this not to be done, inconvenience and confusion must result. Thus it appears that in the particular of definiteness, the commandment Sabbath is exactly adapted to both the spiritual and social interests of society.
There is one point more that remains to be considered. I refer to the commemorative nature of the Sabbath. Reason and observation have taught men the value of memorials. They not only serve the purpose of transmitting to posterity the knowledge of great events and deeds, but they also inspire in the hearts of all a disposition to emulate the virtues of those whose achievements are celebrated. Nothing, for example, is better calculated to perpetuate among Americans the love of liberty and veneration for the authors of our national existence, than the commemoration of each returning fourth of July. But if it be true that great advantages accrue from the proper observance of memorial days which serve to bring to mind the origin of institutions which when compared with the creation of the world become insignificant, then how important it must be that the creation itself should be properly commemorated. Had this been done in all ages and by all peoples, atheism would never have cast its dark shadow upon our earth. The knowledge of a personal God would have been transmitted to each succeeding generation as it could not have been done in any other way.
Thus I have shown that the Sabbath law, as found in the fourth commandment, is moral in every particular save one. The physical rest that it provides, the opportunities which it affords for prayer, self-examination, public worship, and the preaching of the word, as well as its commemoration of the fact that God created the world, exactly meet the demands of our fallen race. As it regards the circumstance that the Sabbath law is positive so far as it relates to the hallowing of the definite day, I remark that this in no wise furnishes an argument that would favor the repeal of the law. Indeed, the very opposite is true. The commandment being moral in every respect but one, it follows that its abolition would be a positive calamity. But inasmuch as reason and nature, though pointing out the necessity of a weekly Sabbath, do not indicate the particular day on which it should fall, it becomes indispensable that God should supplement the moral law of the Sabbath by a statute stating explicitly the day which all should observe. The fourth commandment is just such a statute. It would therefore be the very height of folly for God to repeal it; since in doing so he would render the moral feature of the Sabbath law practically inoperative and void.
Having said all that is necessary on this subject from the logical stand-point, it is now time to view it from that of the Scriptures. Do they or do they not teach that the law of God is abolished. It is not necessary that my argument on this point should be extended to any great length, since Christendom generally are agreed that they do not. I read from Ps. 40:7, 8: “Then said I, Lo, I come; in the volume of the book it is writ- ten of me, I delight to do thy will, O my God; yea, thy law is within my heart.” These words relate to Christ. They contain a prophetic declaration which shadows forth very distinctly the object and character of the mission of Jesus. Fortunately the relation which, when he should come, he would sustain to the law of the Father, is clearly defined. Let me read the last verse again: “I delight to do thy will, O my God; yea, thy law is within my heart.” Strange language this for the prophet to put in the mouth of one who, according to Mr. Nolaw’s theory, was to make a clean sweep of the only law that God ever in person proclaimed in the assembly of his people. When the Psalmist represents the Saviour as saying that he had come to do the will of God, he renders it certain that it was not his purpose to set at naught any of the statutes of the Father; but when he attributes to him the additional words, “thy law is within my heart,” he shows the nature of the obedience which our blessed Lord would yield to the commandments of Him by whom he was sent. The heart is the grand center of the affectional nature. When we say a thing is within our hearts, we mean that we love it ardently. But if the Saviour had loved the law of God ardently, as the Psalmist said he would, it is certain that he never would have sought its abolition.
I read from John 15:10: “If ye keep my commandments, ye shall abide in my love, even as I have kept my Father’s commandments and abide in his love.” In this verse we have the fulfillment of that which the Psalmist predicted. He prophesied that Christ would do the will of his Father; or, in other words, that he would keep the commandments of the latter, just as the Saviour, in John 15:10, claims that he did do. Here, then, we have the example of Christ on the side of obedience to the law of God. Such an example, in the absence of evidence to the contrary, furnishes a presumption that its author would never favor the repeal of a code which he himself obeyed all his life-time. This presumption is rendered almost equal to demonstration when the fact is noted that in the text now being considered, the Saviour represents that it was obedience to the commandments of the Father which secured to him an abiding place in the love of the latter.
I pass now to Matt. 5:17–19: “Think not that I am come to destroy the law or the prophets; I am not come to destroy, but to fulfill. For verily I say unto you, Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law till all be fulfilled. Whosoever therefore shall break one of these least commandments, and shall teach men so, he shall be called the least in the kingdom of heaven; but whosoever shall do and teach them, the same shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven.” What I have just read is taken from the first sermon that our Lord ever preached. It contains a clear and decisive statement of the relation which he intended to sustain to the law of God.
Mr. N.—Yes, sir, and it proves, just as I have stated, that the law is abolished.
Mr. B.—How so?
Mr. N.—Why, if Christ fulfilled the law, that is the end of it.
Mr. B.—Strange logic yours! I never knew before that the repeal of a law followed as a necessary consequence of its being fulfilled. James says (chap. 2:8), “If ye fulfill the royal law according to the scripture, Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself, ye do well.” The word “if” implies that it is possible for individuals to fulfill the “royal law” in question; i. e., the ten commandments. If, therefore, Mr. Nolaw’s doctrine be correct, it follows that in case one should happen to do so, the law which he fulfilled would be repealed as a consequence. Thus by a single act of obedience on the part of the creature, the law of the Creator would be abolished. But such a thing cannot be true. James used the word “fulfilled” as it is generally employed in the Scriptures, in the sense of accomplish or obey.
Mr. N.—The case is not a parallel one. I was talking about Christ, not about men. What I claim is that Christ fulfilled the law for me and all others, and therefore we have nothing more to do with it.
Mr. B.—Let us see. Could Christ fulfill the law for a man who was never under obligation to keep the law which he (Christ) fulfilled?
Mr. N.—Why, I suppose not.
Mr. B.—Well, you certainly could not have been under obligation to keep the law of God before you were born. Hence if Christ’s fulfillment of the law released you from the necessity of obeying it, it must be that such a release became operative after you had reached mature years. But as you could not be released from a law which had no existence, and if it be true that you were set free from the law of God during your natural lifetime, then it cannot be a fact that Christ abolished the law in his day. This is one of the absurdities of your position. Another is, that according to it Christ died, not only that he might liberate his followers from the necessity of obeying the ten commandments, but also that he might set the hosts of wicked men free from the obligation to keep a law which in the Scriptures is declared to be “holy, just, and good.”
But to return to the question whether the fulfilling of a law results in its abolition. As you object to the illustration that I brought from James 2:8, on the ground that it relates to men and not to Christ, I will furnish you one which refers to the latter solely. Here it is in Matt. 3:15: “And Jesus answering said unto him, Suffer it to be so now; for thus it becometh us to fulfill all righteousness. Then he suffered him.” John was baptizing in the Jordan. Christ came to John and requested him to administer the ordinance to him. John declined to do so. Christ persisted in his request, arguing that it was becoming in him as well as us to fulfill all righteousness. Now you will not deny, will you, that Christ did fulfill all righteousness?
Mr. N.—Why do you ask me such a question as that?
Mr. B.—Why do I ask it? Because I know that you would be compelled to answer it in the affirmative; and that if you did so, you would be forced to abandon your view that the fulfillment of the law by Christ necessarily resulted in its repeal; or else you would be forced to admit that his fulfillment of all righteousness abolished the same,—an absurdity so palpable that no man in his senses would be guilty of indorsing it.
In closing our talk for this evening, I will bring from our Saviour’s own words as given in Matt. 5:17–19, the most irrefragable testimony that it was not his design by fulfilling the law to do it away. What he says in that connection in regard to the kingdom of heaven, relates either to the Christian dispensation or to heaven itself. It is immaterial which position you take, the result will be the same; for that which is honored in heaven will be honored in the Christian church, and vice versa. Now for the testimony in question. In verse 17 the Lord declares that he had not come to destroy the law but to fulfill it. In verse 18 he states that so long as the earth stands, one jot or one tittle should in no wise pass from the law till all be fulfilled. In verse 19, he shows what are the legitimate consequences of the doctrines set forth in verses 17, 18. He says: “Whosoever, therefore [i. e., for the preceding reasons], shall break one of these least commandments, and shall teach men so, he shall be called the least in the kingdom of heaven; but whosoever shall do and teach them, the same shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven.” His premise is this: I fulfill the law; his conclusion this: every man, therefore, who has a place in my kingdom must both do and teach the law of God as I have done.
Mr. Thoughtful.—Will you oblige me, sir, by restating your position as just given?
Mr. B.—Certainly. In Matt. 5:17 Christ declares that he has come to fulfill the law, not to destroy it. In verse 18, as proof that it was not his mission to destroy the law, he affirms that the latter will stand complete in every jot and tittle till the earth shall pass away, or till all things be fulfilled. Notwithstanding the statements of Christ in verses 17, 18 to the effect that it was not his purpose to destroy the law, it is claimed by Mr. Nolaw and his friends that by fulfilling he did really destroy it; for when a law is abolished, it is destroyed. By way of proving beyond all dispute that the fulfillment of the law by Christ spoken of in verse 17, could not have resulted in its repeal, I called attention to verse 19, where the Saviour affirms that as a consequence of the doctrines set forth by him in verses 17, 18, he who should break the commandments of God, and teach men to do so, should be called least in either the kingdom of heaven or the gospel dispensation,—a thing that could not be true unless the law was of binding force in that kingdom or that dispensation. I might still further fortify this interpretation by citing verse 20, where the Lord continues the discussion of the subject. In it he says: “For I say unto you, That except your righteousness shall exceed the righteousness of the scribes and Pharisees, ye shall in no case enter into the kingdom of heaven.” The word “for” at the commencement of this verse, connects it with the preceding one, and shows that its teachings were designed to confirm those of that one. The term “righteousness,” as used in verse 20, beyond all controversy is that which would result from keeping the commandments mentioned in verse 19.
Thus we have the declaration of Christ to the effect that unless a man shall keep the commandments better than did the scribes and Pharisees, he cannot enter the kingdom of heaven. But if a man is required to keep the commandments better than did the scribes and Pharisees, it follows that he is under obligation to keep them in a manner superior to that in which they kept them. If, however, the commandments were abolished, he would not be compelled to keep them at all, and there would therefore be no force in the declaration of Christ, that a man’s righteousness must exceed that of the scribes and Pharisees before he could enter the kingdom of heaven. In closing let me warn Mr. Nolan that in the light of Matt. 5 it is a very serious thing to break the commandments of God, and to teach men to break them, as he is doing.
Battle Creek, Mich.