BY I. E. KIMBALL.
The World’s Crisis published A. N. Seymour’s twelve propositions on the Sabbath, through the desire of a Vermont man, who wishes to use them to quiet the consciences of those having enough respect for God’s word to be troubled over the subject. They are not worth noticing, yet some may have been deceived by them, the negative style of the phraseology being peculiarly suited to bring about such a result.
First, the calling for a command before the days of Moses is only the pretext of an argument—a sham entirely. I may ask for the command against killing, stealing, lying, cheating, or any other sin, before that time, and no one can produce it. It is true there were “sinners exceedingly” in the days when Abraham was sharing the richest blessings, and receiving the wonderful promise of heirship to the world, “because,” as the Lord testified, “Abraham obeyed my voice, and kept my charge, my commandments, my statutes, and my laws.” Indeed, their excessive sinning brought unmingled wrath from the Almighty; but according to modern reasoning, they were innocent victims; for God’s voice had not spoken, his charge had not been given, and his commandments, statutes, and laws placed no strictures upon them. Any one who desires to know the truth of the matter, can easily find a command in the second chapter of Genesis.
Secondly, he appeals for a command to any Gentile nation, without stopping to consider that there was never a command or a promise given to a Gentile nation in the world. Rom. 9: 4–8; Eph. 2: 11, 12. As all the promises of eternal blessing were made “through the righteousness of faith,” and are embraced through obedience, thus placing the commandments and promises hand in hand, he who accepts the one, must take the other also. God practices no more lenity with Gentile than with Jew. His requirements of the “children” are the same. If any one wants to build on the foundation of the apostles and prophets, and thus be fed with the heritage of Jacob, they will find one of the prerequisites in Isa. 58: 13, 14.
Thirdly, he asks for a command this side of the crucifixion, as though the Lord should reiterate his commandments. The one “law giver” (James 4: 12) is the arbiter of the New Testament also. It was given the apostles “fully to preach the word of God” (Col. 1: 25), and this they did most decidedly. Does not the apostle teach that the holy Scriptures (referring to the Old Testament entirely) are given for “doctrine,” etc., “that the man of God may be perfect, thoroughly furnished unto all good works”? That, coupled with faith in Christ, they are able to make us “wise unto salvation”? But to profit by their teaching and doctrine, Sabbath principles must necessarily take hold upon us. And, again, does not the apostle inform us that he gave “no new commandment,” but “the word which we have heard from the beginning”? 1 John 2: 7. “And now I beseech thee, . . . not as though I wrote a new commandment unto thee, but that which we have had from the beginning . . . that we walk after his [the Father’s] commandments.” 2 John 5, 6.
Who can say that exhortations like this are to the exclusion of the Sabbath commandment? And when they tell us that this is the only way to show our love to God (1 John 5: 3), and that he is a liar who says he knows him and will not do it (chap. 2: 4, 5), it certainly seems that no stronger arguments could be urged for the keeping of not one only, but all of them. And when they signify further that God’s law is established by faith in Christ (Rom. 3: 31), and is made for everything that is contrary to sound doctrine (1 Tim. 1: 9), is not this sufficient for the most incredulous? What! heed the Scriptures? heed the commandments? love manifested only in keeping them, and he a liar who professes to but does not do it? and yet say there is not a commandment for Sabbath-keeping? Established by faith in Christ! and is not the Sabbath commandment established as much as the rest? Condemning everything contrary to sound doctrine, does not the no-Sabbath doctrine look a little unsound?
But the fourth inquiry implicates its author in unallowable ignorance. He asks, “Where does the Holy Ghost, or Spirit of truth given to lead into all truth, ‘command’ seventh-day Sabbath-keeping?” If he will sometime read 2 Pet. 1: 21, he will find that in “old time” the same Spirit of truth moved the prophets to speak as they did. Would it not be better to learn what Isaiah, Jeremiah, and Ezekiel have said about the Sabbath, than to be asking such “foolish and unlearned questions”?
The fifth and sixth are identical in substance. They require texts showing that God’s law, given to gauge a man’s relations to God and his fellow-men, therefore standing fast forever, means the ten commandments, no more, no less. The facts that God came down upon Mt. Sinai, gave his testimony with a voice that shook the earth (Heb. 12: 26), and when delivering it to Moses in the Mount proclaimed it (Ex. 24: 12) “the law and commandments which I have written, that thou mayest teach them” (the Hebrew article ha makes it very definite, the law),—all this has no significance to him.
In teaching according to the instruction, Moses deduces therefrom the one great principle of love: “Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy might” (Deut. 5: 6), and “thy neighbor as thyself.” Lev. 19: 18. We may either contract or greatly expand in our explanation of the principles of fundamental law. This we find in the constitution and subsidiary laws of the State; but all superstructive teaching must rest upon the base. And so we find that all the teachings of Moses and the prophets are natural deductions from God’s law. Yet Mr. Seymour seems not to comprehend the distinctive pre-eminence of the law over the other instructions. When God calls those ten precepts “the law,” is it not then the law? What right have we to add or deduct?
The seventh mistake is in the conclusion that because certain offerings, typical of our Saviour, were said to be holy, therefore the sacrificial law was holy. I read of the law of a carnal commandment” that was “disannulled for the weakness and unprofitableness thereof;” but that law was never yet called holy or spiritual.
The eighth error is a heterogeneous admixture of the two laws, calling for a statement that the one abolished is now binding. We have not the least intention, desire, or ability to present such proof.
It is certainly strange that a person cannot discriminate between a law by which we have a knowledge of sin, and a typical law pointing us to the remedy for it. One was urged by the prophets with the greatest decision and force, while at the same breath they condemned the other and showed God’s abhorrence of its practice when they persisted in willful transgression of the first. When stubbornly disobedient, it was worse than useless to apply the figurative remedy. Isa. 1: 10–12, etc.; Jer. 7: 22, 23; Ps. 40: 6, 8. The law “added because of transgression,” and the same called, “the law of commandments contained in ordinances,” which formed the partition wall between Jew and Gentile,—this law so “weak and unprofitable,” serving only in figure, we are happy to acknowledge is abolished; but the Gentiles are built into that “spiritual house” exactly as were the apostles and prophets who form its foundations, not by useless offerings but by obedience. Eph. 2: 11–22.
The ninth is embraced and answered in the third. However, if he wants a “jot or tittle of testimony” to show violation of the fourth commandment to be a sin in the gospel dispensation, it can be found in Matt. 5: 18, 19; James 2: 10, 11.
The tenth is a challenge for proof that the Sabbath is the seal of God. Has God a seal?—Yes. Rev. 7: 3. And what is it for?—To make known the true God. And the Sabbath was given for this very purpose. Ex. 31: 13–17; Eze. 20: 10, 11, 19, 20. The words “sign” and “seal” are exactly synonymous. See root meaning of seal in Webster’s Dictionary, also Rom. 4: 11.
Number eleven asks for Paul’s teaching of Sabbath-keeping. Example speaks as loud as words, even with him. The book of Acts shows Paul to have kept over eighty Sabbaths at least; and part of this time he wrought on the other days, with a Jew, at tent-making. Acts 13: 14, 44; 16: 13; 18: 4, 11. The Jews, so vehement in every conceivable accusation, would have noted and condemned Sabbath-breaking in him or the early church, had they had the opportunity. Paul witnessed to “none other things than those which the prophets and Moses did say should come,” and moreover testifies, “I have committed nothing against the people or customs of our fathers.” The prophets had not taught the abolition of the Sabbath, neither did Paul once conceive of the thing. His example, and words that only they who do the law can be justified, and that all must finally be judged by it (Rom. 2: 12, 13, 16), are sufficient, indeed invincible, testimony for Sabbath-keeping.
The twelfth gives a final flourish by a request for any testimony that imposes Sabbath-keeping upon the followers of Christ throughout the entire dispensation of grace! As though Christ was not the chief corner-stone of the temple, whose foundations are the apostles and prophets, and which commenced to be built in Eden; or that there was any other measure of justification than through him! Acts 4: 12; 13: 39. As though the dispensation of grace did not extend even to the expulsion of Adam from Eden!
Brattleboro, Vt.