AdventAI

HOW TO ARGUE WITH A PERSON.

By Dudley Marvin Canright

From Review and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 24., June 16, 1885

Perhaps nothing requires greater tact and patience in the Christian course, than to argue with a person successfully. Almost any one can argue and dispute and contend and drive a person off; but to argue with them so as to win them, is another thing. Well did Jesus counsel us to be as wise as serpents, and harmless as doves. Our object in arguing with people should always be either to win them, or to win those who are listening. Sometimes we might argue with a bitter opposer. If we must argue with such a one, it is generally for the benefit of those who are listening. In such a case, we can treat him with more severity than we can a candid person; but even then, mildness and Christian courtesy are the best.

If we wish to win a person in conversation, we must, in the first place, keep perfectly calm, cool, and self-possessed. Whatever he may say, the moment you lose your temper, you have lost your vantage ground. In the second place, it is very necessary to listen to what he has to say, without trying to talk all the time yourself. If he does not have a chance to state his arguments fully, he will never be satisfied. If he is silenced, he will feel in his heart that he has not had a fair chance, and you will fail in convincing him. In the third place, it is not wise to talk in such a manner as to make him feel that he does not know much, or, at least, that his knowledge is much inferior to yours. If you do, he will think that it is simply your superior knowledge that has gained it, and not the justice of your argument; or he will feel that he knows so little that his own judgment is not worth much in the matter, and hence he will have no confidence in his own convictions. But encourage him to think that he does know something, and that he can state his point plainly; then, when he sees a point, he will have some confidence in his own understanding of it.

Another thing it is always important to notice, and that is: do not be ready to snatch up every little statement that a person may make. Let everything go but the main point at issue. If he should make a statement that is entirely wrong, and which you could easily show to be false, let it go, unless it has a direct bearing on the question at hand. Suppose you are talking with a man about the Sabbath, and he makes some remark concerning the immortality of the soul; pay no attention to it; let him have it that way. Stick right to your point; if you are turned aside on that question, you will soon be off the subject entirely; besides, it is not well to endeavor to convince a man of too much at once. You should be well satisfied to settle one thing at a time.

Admit all you possibly can of his argument, and if you can truthfully say that he has taught you something that you did not know, be sure to say it.p. 379 This will please him, give him confidence in your candor, and draw him toward you. Above all, impress him with the thought that you are arguing only for the truth and for his good, and not simply to carry your point. “Wise as serpents and harmless as doves” is an excellent rule to study carefully in personal argument. D. M. CANRIGHT.