AdventAI

CONDITIONAL IMMORTALITY IN EUROPE.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 24., June 16, 1885

From a letter by J. H. Pettingell, published in the Bible Banner of May 28, 1885, we take the following interesting items showing how the Bible doctrine of immortality through Christ alone, is spreading in Europe:—

“I learn from private letters, as well as from periodicals and reports of Conferences, which I am constantly receiving from friends in Europe, that the doctrine of life only in Christ is gaining in favor and force, especially among the clergy and learned professors, both in England and on the Continent. A few months since, I received from Dr. Petavel of Geneva, a copy of a private letter from the learned Professor Jonker of Holland, in which he declares his full belief in this doctrine.

“At a meeting of the Synod of the Reformed Church of France held last October at Montpellier, composed of more than fifty pastors, besides many able laymen, Mr. Babut—who is described by M. de Pressense, the distinguished senator of France, as the ‘leader of evangelical Protestantism in the Southern departments’—read an argument in opposition to the traditional doctrine of inherent immortality, which was assented to by M. Bonnet of Frankfort, the well-known evangelical commentator, and supported by M. Sabatier, the Christian Science professor of Montpellier, and which was well received by the whole assembly. A copy of this address has been sent to me in the Revue Theologique, but I have no time to translate it for the Banner, and besides, it would be too long for the columns of this paper.

“Only last December, Prof. Bonney, one of the most distinguished men of science, and a preacher of orthodox Christianity, took decided ground in his Hulsean lecture, in favor of the doctrine of eternal life only in Christ. Professor Drummond in his recent very popular work, entitled ‘Natural Law in the Spiritual World,’ has demonstrated that natural immortality of man is a scientific as well as a Scriptural impossibility; and that there cannot be any immortality excepting by union with the Deity in a new, holy, and spiritual life. I might go on to mention the names of many men, eminent for scientific and theological learning in England and on the Continent, who have come to the support of this doctrine.

“The Homiletic Monthly of England has for the past several months been publishing a series of papers by some of the leading theological scholars of the country, on this question, in what is called a symposium. Rev. Edward White closes the series in a very able, and as I think, unanswerable argument, on ‘the foundation of the belief in the immortality of man,’ showing that the popular doctrine has no foundation either in Scripture, or reason, or sound philosophy.”