AdventAI

THE TEMPLE IN HEAVEN.

By W. H. Littlejohn

From Review and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 24., June 16, 1885

MR. WESTMINSTER'S THEORY OF THE CHANGE OF THE SABBATH WEIGHED IN THE BALANCES AND FOUND WANTING. MR. NOLAW, DISGUSTED WITH THE LOGIC OF HIS ASSOCIATES, IS ABOUT READY TO SURRENDER.

BY ELD. W. H. LITTLEJOHN.

Mr. Biblist.—At this time I am to examine that portion of Mr. Westminster's theory which bears upon the practice of the early Church. He stated it in these words: “After Christ's ascension, the Church, instructed by the apostles, made the first day of the week the regular occasion for public worship.” You perceive, gentlemen, that there are two prominent points in the words I have quoted. The first is, that the apostolic Church made the first day of the week the regular day for public worship; the second is, that they were instructed to do so by the apostles. I will examine them separately, taking up the latter one first. To begin with, I propound this question: How do you know, Mr. Westminster, that the early Church were instructed by the apostles to make the first day of the week the regular occasion for public worship? Did you learn that fact from the Bible?

Mr. Westminster.—No, sir; I cannot say that the Bible supports my claim by direct statements.

Mr. B.—Then now, as hitherto, you base your doctrine upon a mere inference?

Mr. W.—Yes, sir, upon an inference merely.

Mr. B.—Suppose now that it should happen to prove true that the early Church did observe the first day of the week as holy on their own motion and without any instruction from the Lord Jesus Christ or his apostles on that point; would their example be obligatory upon us?

Mr. W.—I should hardly be willing to say that it would.

Mr. B.—Well, you are sound there. Right here is one great difference between Catholicism and Protestantism. The former claims that the decisions of the Church, as such, are binding, while the latter insists that they are not obligatory unless made in harmony with the expressed will of God. In John 12:48, we have these words: “He that rejecteth Me, and receiveth not my words, hath One that judgeth him; the word that I have spoken, the same shall judge him in the last day.” From this language, it appears that the words of Christ are to be the criterion of judgment in the last day. Do you agree with that?

Mr. W.—Certainly, sir.

Mr. B.—Very good. Now I have another question to ask: The words of Christ which are to judge us, are they those only that are recorded in the Bible, or do they comprehend also words of his that were never recorded?

Mr. W.—The words that are in the Bible, I suppose. It would be unreasonable to judge us by words of Christ that we know nothing about.

Mr. B.—True; but did you not say just now that we have nowhere in the Bible a declaration to the effect that we should keep Sunday holy?

Mr. W.—Well, yes, sir; I believe I did. But then you know that we infer from the example of the Church that he commanded the Sunday to be kept holy.

Mr. B.—After all, then, the Catholics are right, are they?

Mr. W.—What do you mean?

Mr. B.—I mean that if your doctrine be true, that the keeping of Sunday is to be enforced by the example of the Church in the absence of any expressed command of Christ, then Catholics are correct when they argue that we are to follow the Church even where they have no warrant for their action in the written word.

Mr. W.—I should not want to consent to that. There is a difference, you know, between the decisions of the Church of to-day and those of the Church in apostolic times.

Mr. B.—The principle involved in following one or the other is the same. The apostolic Church, as a church, were not inspired. It is nowhere said that they were to be our exemplars. It is one thing to obey the command of the inspired apostles; another—an entirely different thing, to take the example of the Church as an expression of the divine will.

Thus far I have opposed your theory simply on the ground of its doctrinal unsoundness. I wish now to refute its accuracy from the stand-point of historic facts. I deny emphatically that there is anything in the New Testament record which will warrant the statement that the Church of the first century made the first day of the week a regular day of worship.

Mr. W.—Then, sir, I will prove to you that there is.

Mr. B.—Very good; let us have the testimony.

Mr. W.—You will admit, of course, that the apostles were holding a religious meeting when Christ appeared in their midst on the day of his resurrection?

Mr. B.—No, sir, I shall not admit any such thing. Proceed, however, to give the other instances on which you claim that meetings of the kind in question occurred.

Mr. W.—In 1 Cor. 16:1, 2 we have incontestable proof that the Corinthian church made the first day of the week a stated day for worship. I will read the passage: “Now concerning the collection for the saints, as I have given order to the churches of Galatia, even so do ye. Upon the first day of the week let every one of you lay by him in store, as God hath prospered him, that there be no gatherings when I come.” The next text which I shall quote is found in Acts 20:7. Here it is: “And upon the first day of the week, when the disciples came together to break bread, Paul preached unto them, ready to depart on the morrow; and continued his speech until midnight.” From what I have just read, it appears that the church of Troas, as well as that of Corinth, was in the habit of meeting for worship on the first day of the week. Let me see; I believe that those are all the instances of meetings which are recorded in the New Testament as having taken place on the first day of the week.

Mr. B.—Then you rest your case upon them?

Mr. W.—Yes, sir.

Mr. B.—I will take them up in the order in which they have been cited. I told you positively that I would not agree to the proposition that the account in John 20:19 proved that the apostles met for worship on the day of Christ's resurrection. I will now prove that it does not. There are a thousand and one purposes for which men congregate together besides that of worship. It does not follow, therefore, because men are found assembled that they have met for devotional exercises. You will consequently give me your reasons for supposing that the meeting spoken of in John 20:19 was necessarily of a religious character.

Mr. W.—Well, I take it for granted that such was the case, as it would have been very natural for them to assemble at that time to return thanks for the resurrection of Christ.

Mr. B.—Very natural to suppose that they assembled to give thanks for the resurrection of Christ? A strange conclusion that, indeed! Instead of being a very natural one, the very reverse is true of it. All the circumstances of the case forbid its acceptance by one who has given the subject much thought. They would be hypocrites of the first order who would assemble to express their gratitude to God for an event which they did not believe had ever taken place. Such, nevertheless, was the very thing that the apostles did, if your version of the meeting in the upper chamber at Jerusalem be correct. Let me read you a passage upon this point from Mark 16:9–14:—“Now when Jesus was risen early the first day of the week, he appeared first to Mary Magdalene, out of whom he had cast seven devils. And she went and told them that had been with him, as they mourned and wept. And they, when they had heard that he was alive, and had been seen of her, believed not. After that he appeared in another form unto two of them, as they walked, and went into the country. And they went and told it unto the residue; neither believed they them. Afterward he appeared unto the eleven as they sat at meat, and upbraided them with their unbelief and hardness of heart, because they believed not them which had seen him after he was risen.”

That was rather singular treatment of the apostles by Christ, if they were congregated to give thanks for his resurrection. Was Christ ignorant of the purpose that had brought them together, or did he administer a rebuke when commendation was the thing which all the circumstances of the case demanded? Did he “upbraid” them for not having believed those who had seen him after his resurrection, when the facts were that they had believed them and had convened to give formal expression to their faith in their reports by offering a tribute of praise to God for the good news of the resurrection? You must be very careful, gentlemen, that you do not rear the structure of your Sunday sanctity dogma upon a foundation that rests upon the supposed ignorance or injustice of the risen Lord, whose exit from the tomb you appear to be so anxious to commemorate. Christ before his death could read the hearts of men at will. It would therefore be singular in the extreme if he were incapable of doing so after he came forth from the grave. Before the crucifixion, he delighted in approval rather than censure. It would be unaccountable if, after his victory over death, his nature should be so far changed for the worse that he would take pleasure in bruising where healing was called for; in reprimanding where approval was in order. The simple fact is, that the apostles stubbornly refused to believe that Christ had risen from the grave until the personal presence of the Lord himself in their midst, when they were gathered together in the chamber at Jerusalem, rendered further doubting impossible. No other view of the subject can be harmonized with the rebuke that Christ administered to them at that time. Admit that, however, and the argument for Sunday sanctity, which rests upon the conception that they were gathered there to honor the day of the resurrection, is converted into a baseless fantasy.

Mr. Dipper.—As you seem to have a genius for tearing down, I should like to see you try your hand at construction for a moment. Tell us, if you please, for what purpose the disciples were assembled if it were not for the one in question.

Mr. B.—That I will do with the greatest pleasure; although it would not prove your theory to be correct even if I were incapable of doing so. A man might insist that the dark spot on the moon was actually a dog gnawing a bone; should he do so, it might be very easy to overturn his theory, while it would be very difficult to furnish another explanation that would be entirely satisfactory. But to come to the point: I understand that the disciples were gathered together in the upper room at Jerusalem, for the express purpose of partaking of a common meal, when the Lord appeared in their midst.

Mr. Shouter.—Well, well; that's the last idea that I ever heard advanced on that subject!

Mr. D.—I think as much, Brother Shouter.

Mr. Surplice.—Neighbor Biblist has an ugly habit of calling upon us for Bible proof for our positions; so I propose that he give us a little for this new-fangled notion of his.

Mr. W.—Yes, yes, Friend Biblist; suppose you give us a little Bible on that point.

Mr. B.—Certainly, gentlemen, your request is not unreasonable, and so I will try to gratify your wishes. In the first place, I will prove that the apostles had a common home at Jerusalem at the time in question. To do this, I will read John 20:10, 11:—“Then the disciples went away again unto their own home. But Mary stood without at the sepulcher weeping; and as she wept, she stoopedp. 371 down, and looked into the sepulcher.” The statements of this text are so lucid that I need not dilate upon them. They establish the proposition that Peter and John had a home at Jerusalem and that they repaired to it on the morning of the resurrection day. I turn now to Acts 1:13 to prove that the home of Peter and John was shared by the other apostles. The text relates to an event that took place in connection with the ascension of Christ. I read: “And when they were come in, they went up into an upper room, where abode both Peter, and James, and John, and Andrew, Philip, and Thomas, Bartholomew, and Matthew, James the son of Alpheus, and Simon Zelotes, and Judas the brother of James.” The transaction narrated in these verses took place in the city of Jerusalem. It will not be disputed that the “upper room” of Acts 1:13 is the same as the “home” of John 20:10. Thus it is demonstrated that all the apostles resided together.

But it has already been shown that on the day on which Christ came forth from the grave, Peter and John were located at their usual home in the morning. As therefore it will hardly be claimed that they would have undertaken to change their quarters during the excitement which followed the discovery that Christ was missing from the tomb, it is fairly presumable that when we find them in the evening of the resurrection day hiding away behind the barred doors of a certain apartment, that this apartment was the same as the one which they occupied in the morning, and which they shared with the other apostles. Confirmation of this view is found in the circumstance that when Christ appeared to the eleven on the day of his resurrection, he not only found them in their room behind barred doors, but he also found them actually engaged in partaking of their evening meal.

Mr. W.—How do you know that he did? I would like to see your authority for that.

Mr. B.—It would hardly seem necessary to read the Scriptures to prove a fact as clearly stated as the one in question; but I will do so, inasmuch as you doubt its existence. Here it is in Mark 16:12–14. I believe that I have read it to you once before this evening: “After that he appeared in another form unto two of them, as they walked, and went into the country. And they went and told it unto the residue; neither believed they them. Afterward he appeared unto the eleven as they sat at meat, and upbraided them with their unbelief and hardness of heart, because they believed not them which had seen him after he was risen.”

Mr. W.—Pardon me, sir, pardon me; I do not recollect ever to have noticed that point before.

Mr. B.—In Luke 24:36–42, which is the parallel to the passage that I have just read, we learn that when Christ appeared to the apostles they were terrified, supposing that he was a spirit; and that he, in order to allay their fears, asked for meat, and ate before them some fish and honey-comb, which had been given to him in response to his request. There, then, we have an additional proof that the apostles, at the time that the Saviour appeared to them collectively, were engaged in a common meal. But the natural place for men to assemble at supper time is their own home. Hence, in the absence of all proof to the contrary, it must be decided that on the evening of the day of Christ's resurrection, the disciples were in their own quarters quietly partaking of a frugal repast, instead of being engaged in a religious meeting to honor the resurrection of One whom they did not believe had risen from the dead.

Mr. Nolaw.—You might as well give in, gentlemen. Mr. Biblist has the argument on this point.

Mr. Shouter.—What! you going to turn Sabbath-keeper?

Mr. N.—I do not know as I shall; but I hope that I may never be so far governed by prejudice as to be incapable of appreciating sound logic. Mr. Biblist has clearly shown that you are wrong in claiming that the record in John 20:19 proves that the apostles met for public worship on the evening of the day of Christ's resurrection. He has demonstrated from the Bible that, at the time in question, they were in their own private rooms eating an ordinary meal, and that they did not even believe that Christ had risen from the dead. To insist, after such a showing, that your version of the text is correct, is absurd. It looks very much as if the wish were father to the thought. To tell the truth, I have to blush for you, gentlemen, when I see you resorting to such subterfuges. You thought I was worsted in the no-law argument, and perhaps you are right. The more I think of it, the more dissatisfied I am with the showing I made; but I certainly never committed so egregious a blunder as that of insisting that a band of terror-stricken disciples, hiding away in their own chamber from the Jewish mob, and doubting whether or not Christ had risen from the dead, could fairly be taken to represent the apostolic Church assembled in the order of providence, to become our exemplars in the matter of Sunday-keeping.

Mr. B.—It affords me great pleasure to learn from Mr. Nolaw's own lips that he is about ready to surrender that most dangerous of all doctrines,—that the law of God which the apostles said was “holy, just, and good” has been repealed. If he gets fully righted up on the law point, he will, I think, have but little trouble on the Sabbath question.

At our next interview I will consider the remaining two texts that Mr. Westminster has brought forward in support of his theory.

Battle Creek, Mich.