THE PENTECOST AND ITS RELATION TO THE SABBATH QUESTION; PROOF THAT IT FELL ON SATURDAY INSTEAD OF SUNDAY: THE SEVENTH PART OF TIME THEORY EXAMINED FROM THREE STAND-POINTS.
BY ELD. W. H. LITTLEJOHN.
Mr. Biblist.—In calling you to order to-night, gentlemen, I have not forgotten that we are here for the special purpose of listening to Mr. Surplice’s theory of the change of the Sabbath.
Mr. Westminster.—Before Mr. Surplice brings out his peculiar view of the subject under discussion, I wish to say that in presenting the texts which record meetings of the early Church, I omitted entirely the one which mentions a meeting on the day of Pentecost. The account of it is found in the second chapter of Acts, which it is unnecessary for me to read to you; since its contents are well understood by all present. The meeting was the most remarkable one that ever took place, and the outpouring of the Spirit which occurred in connection with it was evidently designed to signalize the day of Christ’s resurrection.
Mr. B.—How do you know that such was the case? Can you show any Bible that will support your view?
Mr. W.—I do not know that I can; but that is nothing here or there; it is enough that the meeting took place on the first day of the week. That fact warrants the inference that I have drawn.
Mr. B.—It seems that you gentlemen will never tire of “inferences.” The experience of the last few evenings ought, it seems to me, to have shaken your confidence in this method of reaching the truth in matters of doctrine; but it does not appear to have done so. Instead of reasoning that in the matter of the change of the Sabbath, God has done as he has in other matters by telling us just what his desires and purposes are, you conclude that in this most important affair he has left us to guess out his design as best we may. However, I will not stop to discuss the absurdity of your theory upon this point, but will proceed to show that your inferences are far-fetched and utterly unreliable. If it had been the intention of the Lord to honor in an especial manner the first day of the week by the outpouring of the Spirit on the day of Pentecost, he would have made that day conspicuous in the record, to say the least. This he did not do. The first day of the week is not so much as mentioned in the connection; whereas Pentecost is everywhere made prominent. The account, instead of beginning with the words, “When the first day of the week had fully come,” or, “When the resurrection day was fully come,” opens in this way: “When the day of Pentecost was fully come.” It was the feast of Pentecost and not any day of the week in particular that was made conspicuous. If your line of reasoning is correct, therefore, it would be more natural to conclude that it was the feast of Pentecost that the Lord wished to honor and perpetuate, than that he desired to teach the sanctity of the first day of the week. But we all know that Pentecost has been abolished.
Maud.—On what day of the week, father, did Pentecost fall?
Mr. B.—Sometimes on one, and sometimes on another. Like our Christmas, it was an annual institution.
Mr. W.—At the time in question we know that it fell on the first day of the week.
Mr. B.—How do you know that?
Mr. W.—All scholars admit that such was the case.
Mr. B.—There you are very much mistaken. Some of the ripest scholars that the Church has ever produced have held that the Pentecostal feast about which we are talking fell on the Sabbath, or seventh day of the week. Maud, hand me my scrap-book, if you please. Here is what Prof. Hackett says on that point: “It is generally supposed that this Pentecost signalized by the outpouring of the Spirit, fell on the Jewish Sabbath, or Saturday.”—Com. on Original Text.
You will observe that according to Prof. Hackett, the prevailing opinion among the learned is, that Pentecost at the time which we are considering transpired on Saturday instead of Sunday. I have here extracts from Jennings, Olshausen, Dean Alford, and others, all favoring the view that it was on Saturday, not Sunday, that the Pentecost fell that was signalized by the outpouring of the Holy Spirit. What will you do with these facts, Mr. Westminster? If the Pentecost in question did fall on Saturday instead of Sunday, then candor demands that you should decide that it was the seventh and not the first day of the week that the Lord intended to render illustrious. On the other hand, if you shall insist that Pentecost fell on Sunday in the year that Christ died, then you must admit either that it has no connection with Sunday sanctity, or else that God blundered in neglecting to furnish the friends of Sunday with satisfactory proof that it was the day on which the Holy Spirit fell in such great measure. In a case like this, uncertainty is as fatal as positive disproof could be.
Mr. Dipper.—I must confess, as a Baptist, that I do not exactly like this hypothetical argument, Mr. Westminster, about Pentecost. It sounds too much like the reasoning by which our Pedo-baptist friends establish infant baptism.
Mr. Nolaw.—You are right there, Mr. Dipper; but the same objection holds against every argument that you gentlemen have thus far brought in favor of Sunday. It has been inferential from beginning to end.
Mr. B.—We are forgetting the special order for the evening. I propose now that we listen to Mr. Surplice’s favorite theory.
Mr. N.—I am surprised to hear that Mr. Surplice has a favorite theory! I believe that he has, like the rest, thus far supported every view favoring Sunday sanctity which has been advanced. It has seemed to me a little singular that he could do so, inasmuch as they have differed very widely; but let us hear what he has to say to-night.
Mr. Surplice.—Well, I offer it as my opinion that the fourth commandment simply requires the observance of one day in each seven, leaving it to the individual to decide which it shall be. This view, you see, removes all the difficulties of the situation. Christ and the disciples kept Saturday, as they had a right to do; while we modern Christians keep Sunday, as is our privilege, thus honoring the rest day of the Creator and the resurrection of Christ at the same time.
Mr. N.—I think that Goodyear ought to have that theory expressed to him immediately. It has in it rubber enough for a whole stock of rubber goods. Think of it for a moment. It will stretch far enough one way to cover all the seventh-day men, and far enough the other way to cover all the first-day men, and still have elasticity enough left to be spread over the odds and ends of creation who might see fit to keep any of the other days of the week!
Mr. B.—Now that we have fully recovered from the merriment provoked by Mr. Nolaw’s illustration, I will examine the doctrinal features of Mr. Surplice’s view. There is in it nothing new. Within the last few years it has become a sort of “forlorn hope” to many who have been hard pressed when endeavoring to bolster up the Sunday institution. Mr. Surplice commends it very highly because it enables one to celebrate the creation and the resurrection on the same day. But if that can be done, where was the need of the change of the day at all? If the creation rest of Jehovah can be celebrated on Sunday, then the resurrection can be celebrated on Saturday; thus avoiding the confusion that would necessarily result from a change of Sabbaths. As we sometimes say, It is just as broad as it is long. It was a foolish thing, therefore, that they did back there—nobody knows just where—when they transferred the seventh-day Sabbath to the first day of the week in order to commemorate the resurrection of Christ; for, according to Mr. Surplice’s view, it was only necessary to say that they intended to honor both the resurrection and the creation on Saturday, and all would have been perfectly satisfactory to the Lord. So much for the inconsistency of the change on the grounds claimed.
Now let us try this seventh-part-of-time theory,—as it is sometimes called,—by the standard of the Sabbath law. The fourth commandment was written in Hebrew. For this reason, and because of the fact that the Sabbath was given directly to them on Mount Sinai by Jehovah, the Jews might be supposed to understand the spirit of that commandment better than any other people in the world. For fifteen hundred years they lived under it. During the most of this time, the prophets of the Lord were among them to instruct in duty and doctrine. In all those years there is not a single instance in which one of them ever ventured to celebrate the Sabbath on any other than the last day of the week. Again and again they were slaughtered by their enemies, who, knowing that they would not fight on the Sabbath day, took that occasion to attack them. Had they believed in the seventh-part-of-time theory, they might have saved their lives and property by fighting on the Sabbath day, when attacked, and devoting some other day to rest and worship. This they never did. There is not a single act in all the history of their nation which would go to show that they ever dreamed for a moment that the Sabbath was movable at will. Leaving the opinions of the Jews, I have still higher authority to present. God certainly knew the import of his own law. If he had intended to give men the privilege of keeping any day of the week that they pleased, he never would have prevented them from doing so by his providence. But what are the facts? For forty years he led them in the wilderness, during the whole of which time he rendered it impossible for them to hallow any but the last day of the week.
Mr. Surplice.—Pray tell us how he did so?
Mr. B.—How he did so? Why, by directing that no manna except that which fell on the sixth day should be kept over till the next day. He also forbade the people to gather any manna on the Sabbath day itself. You see, therefore, that if the Hebrews, during the forty years that they were in the wilderness, had undertaken to celebrate either Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, or Friday as the Sabbath day, they would have been compelled to do so while they and their families were destitute of food. But, as suggested above, it is absurd to reason that God would have subjected the people to such a necessity when attempting to observe any of the first six days of the week as the Sabbath, provided it was his original design to permit them to select for themselves the day of the week which they would hallow.
One more thought on this point, and I will pass. The fourth commandment is very explicit regarding the day of the Sabbath. In the first place, it informs us that the Sabbath which we are to keep is that of the Lord our God. It then proceeds to identify that day as the one on which God rested at the creation, and which he blessed and hallowed at the same time. When, therefore, we shall find the Sabbath of the Lord and the one which we are to observe, it will have these three characteristics. Let us apply this test to the various days of the week: Did God ever rest on, bless, or hallow the first day of the week? The answer must be in the negative. It was on that day that he commenced to make the world. He never blessed, he never hallowed it. So, too, with the second, third, fourth, fifth, and sixth days of the week. He never rested on, he never blessed, he never hallowed, any one of them. If, therefore, we should consecrate any one of these to rest and worship, we should not hallow the day which the commandment requires us to hallow.
Passing to the last day of the week, we find the case entirely different. Moses tells us distinctly in Gen. 2:2, 3 that God rested upon it, blessed it, sanctified or hallowed it during creation week.p. 403 These are his words: “And on the seventh day God ended his work which he had made; and he rested on the seventh day from all his work which he had made. And God blessed the seventh day, and sanctified it; because that in it he had rested from all his work which God created and made.” The facts are now before you. The seventh day of the week is the one the observance of which the fourth commandment enforces, because it is the one upon which God rested, and which he blessed and hallowed. Neither of the first six days of the week can be kept so as to meet the requirements of the Sabbath law, because that law enforces the observance of a particular day upon which certain events transpired that never took place on any one of those days. A man may on his own motion consecrate Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, or Friday; but that will not satisfy the demands of the decalogue, which says that we must hallow the Sabbath of the Lord, identifying it as the day of God’s rest at the creation of the world, and the one which he blessed and hallowed at that time. Thus much for the seventh-part-of-time theory.
I have shown you that the Hebrews in whose language the Sabbath law was written, and to whom the Sabbath itself was given on Mount Sinai, never surmised that any day of the week save the last one could ever be regarded as the Sabbath. Furthermore, I have proved that if the seventh-part-of-time theory be sound, then God stultified himself by first giving to the Hebrews the privilege of selecting each for himself the day of the week that he would hallow as the Sabbath, and then preventing them for forty years from enjoying the franchise deliberately granted. Lastly, I have made it manifest that the Sabbath which the decalogue obligates us to keep, is a particular, definite day of the week, of which certain things are true that are not true of any other day in the weekly cycle.
You now have an opportunity to offer objections to my line of argument should you see fit to do so. As no one is inclined to take issue with me in the positions advanced upon the seventh-part-of-time theory, I will simply suggest, in conclusion, that a strong argument might be made against it from the stand-point of practicability. It is safe to conclude that every law emanating from Jehovah will be exactly adapted to the needs of those for whom it is made. A moment’s reflection will satisfy any man of penetration that a Sabbath movable at the caprice of every individual, as compared with one which is to be kept by all on a definite day of the week, would be very objectionable. Where all rest upon one and the same day, there is perfect concord.
Where some worship on one day and some on another, there must necessarily be friction and discord. In order to maintain public worship, the people of a given community must consecrate the same hours to that purpose. Divide them up into little squads, some meeting on one day of the week, and others on other days of the week, and the various divisions would be too weak to support a minister and meet the necessary expense of public worship. Let your business men, your legislators, and the judges and officers of your courts celebrate different Sabbaths, and the perplexities and hindrances which would necessarily spring out of such a state of things, would be both innumerable and insupportable. God, who knows the beginning from the end, understood these facts very well; and it is therefore preposterous to suppose that he would have given a variable Sabbath to the race, when a fixed and definite one would have conduced so much more to the advancement of both their social and their spiritual interests. It is now time to bring this interview to a close. I am satisfied from long familiarity with the Sabbath controversy, that you have now presented nearly every theory of Sunday sanctity that would offer you any hope of success in the argument. Nevertheless, I will give you an opportunity to-morrow night to advance others if you have them.