(Concluded.)
The sentiment expressed in the words,— “Thou, O Christ, art all I want, More than all in thee I find,” was but the outburst of a soul supremely satisfied with the fatness of God’s house,—a soul that had been slaking its thirst in the rivers of pleasure in God’s presence, where there is fulness of joy, and at his right hand, where there are pleasures forevermore. Sad as it may appear, yet, judging from the present order of things, Jesus and the gospel are no longer equal to the demand of a human soul. In order to keep the people from the theater and the opera, our churches must be made semi-theater and semi-opera.
The expedients that have been resorted to by some of the churches in this city the past few years, present a sad spectacle indeed. To convince you that I am not guessing at these things, I call your attention to a few of the many announcements that have appeared in the public prints the last three or four years: “Simon and Ruth” at “Jolly Nine” social to-night at —— Church.” This notice occurs five times in one issue of a daily paper. “Go and hear the ‘Champion Snorer’ at —— Church to-night.” “Mum Supper” at —— Church to-night.” “Fancy Tables” at —— Church to-night.” “Hot Dinner” at —— Church to-night.” “Blue T” at —— Church to-night.” “Pink T” at —— Church to-night.” “Bowe Pie Social” at —— Church to-night.” “Ball to-night at —— Church.” “If you want to laugh, go to —— Church Thursday evening and hear —— in the famous bag-pipe recitations.” “Thanksgiving by Presidential authority, and don’t you forget it. The members of the —— Church will have a big concert, and a social after the concert. Look out for particulars.” “The Peak Sisters, on their way from Jersey, will stop over at —— Church, and give an entertainment to-night.” (The Peak Sisters turned out to be some ladies from Columbus.) “If you want to laugh, hear the —— singers at —— Church to-night. They will put you in good humor for Christmas.”
The Ohio State Journal, in reporting one of these entertainments, among other things said: “The tambourine drill was given by small boys and graceful girls. It consisted of uniform maneuvers in marching and beating tambourines to the music of a piano.” I was informed by several friends who were present at the tambourine drill, that the maneuvers referred to were regulated by a “waltz” played on the piano.
These are only a few of the scores of notices of a similar import that have appeared in the local columns of our daily papers from time to time. I have frequently heard irreligious young men ask their friends if they were going to the show at —— church to-night. It must be borne in mind, also, that in many instances the principal actors in these entertainments also furnished music for saloons and beer gardens and dances.
I have heard Methodists speak sneeringly of the “ridiculous” methods of the Salvation Army, who at the same time were very enthusiastic in their support of the things of which I have spoken. I know of nothing that the Salvation Army has done in this country or in England, that is one half so ridiculous and improper as these shows in the churches. I have no desire to be censorious, or sit in judgment on others, where matters of fair difference of opinion are in question; but in the name of Christian consistency, in the name of all that is Christ-like, I ask, Can these kinds of entertainments be productive of spiritual or even moral good?
Can the exalted objects of the Church be attained or advanced by such methods? How can the influence of pious parents, who look anxiously to the future of their children, be supported by such doings?
I remember reading of a young man sent to prison for forgery. The heart-broken parents begged their pastor to visit him, in the hope that the light and liberty of the gospel might reach him in his gloomy cell. The minister greeted him kindly. The young man scarcely replied, but gazed with a sort of defiance upon him. The minister began giving his mother’s tender message, with the interest all the church felt in his welfare. The prisoner at last broke out, “Do you know you are the one that did it?” “What have I done?” eagerly inquired the minister. “I began the business,” replied the youth, “in your Sunday-school. Don’t you remember the Sunday-school fair, where they first set up raffling, and hid a gold ring in a cake? Just for twenty-five cents, too, I got a whole box of little books. I was pleased with my luck, and went in afterward for chances. Sometimes I gained and sometimes I lost. Money I must have for lotteries. I was half mad with excitement, so I used other folks’ names, and here I am. Don’t let the church come blubbering around me. They may thank themselves! Their raffling was what did it! It ruined me!”
And yet the Church will persist in advertising “religious raffles” and “benevolent grabs,” all for the benefit of the poor heathen. There was a time when a “raffle” was patronized only by the worst characters. But now it seems like many other vices; it has been “Christianized,” and little children are initiated into the mysteries of games of chance, and taught the beneficence of gambling for the poor. Sanctified gambling-schools will soon be in vogue.
It would be a great deal more sensible and consistent to deal with such things according to law, than to indict the lowest dens of vice in the city; for “religious raffles” and “benevolent grabs” are sugar-coated and heaven-liveried, and hence all the more alluring and deceptive. Children would flee from such sinks of iniquity as from a viper, when they would consider “religious raffles” perfectly harmless, because given in, by and for, the Church.
When asked why such outlandish proceedings are tolerated in the Church, poor human nature agonizes for an excuse by saying, “Something must be done to interest the young;” or, “The young people must have amusement;” or, “We must do something to raise some money;” or, “We must do something to get better acquainted.” Can it be possible that there is no longer any Christian social companionship? Can it be that the warm, sympathetic “tie that binds our hearts in Christian love” has been chilled or snapped asunder by the icy touch of the world? Have the glorious themes of the Bible that thrilled the hearts of Paul, and Chalmers, and Hall, and Wesley, and Whitfield, lost their power? Have the songs of redemption lost their captivating and enlivening influence? Must the standard be lowered, a compromise effected, and an alliance formed between the Church and the world, in order to interest and save the children? Must the children of Christians dress like harlots and rogues, dance, read novels, and sing comic songs, evoking indecent jests, in order to get them into the Church and keep them when in? This whole thing has proved to be another trick of the enemy, and has utterly failed to accomplish the end the Church had in view (though I doubt not Satan considers it a grand success).
The sad sight of prayer-meetings and class-meetings poorly attended,—the young people conspicuous by their absence, or dumb if present,—young people’s prayer-meetings almost entirely neglected, special gatherings for religious work ignored, while at the same time the young people’s socials, fairs, concerts, pink and blue teas, hot dinners, mum suppers, broom brigades, tambourine drills, bazaars, and the like, are crowded, and hum with activity and enthusiasm, is an illustration, too painfully frequent, of the folly of substituting anything for the gospel, which is declared to be “the power of God unto salvation.”
After these flippant festivities are over, and a handful gather in the prayer-meeting, more from a sense of duty than delight, it is not a matter of surprise that they sing— “Look how we grovel here below, Fond of these earthly toys; Our souls, how heavily they go, To reach eternal joys. “In vain we tune our formal songs, In vain we strive to rise; Hosannas languish on our tongues, And our devotion dies.” To sing anything else would be hypocritical.
I assert, without any hesitation or fear of successful contradiction, after careful observation, that these questionable methods to draw young people to the Church have utterly and universally failed. Christ said, “I, if I be lifted up, will draw all men unto me.” And it is an indisputable fact that when He who is declared to be “the fairest among ten thousand,” and “the one altogether lovely,” “the bright and the morning star,” is lifted up in all his glory and beauty before the people, he proves to be the mighty, irresistible magnet, to draw, and save, and keep.
The methods resorted to to draw young people are as futile to hold them. No careful observer can help detecting their demoralizing influence upon the young convert. As long as he finds his sweetest satisfaction and richest enjoyment in serving the Master, he grows in grace and has no desire for the world’s poisonous delights. The King’s banquet makes the husks of the world seem tasteless. But the moment he begins to “fulfill the lusts of the flesh,” he ceases to “walk after the Spirit.” As soon as he endeavors to effect a compromise, the world gets the whole. As long as he is single-eyed, he is full of light and life and liberty. Double-mindedness results speedily in instability.
These amusements are prolific sources of lightness and frivolousness among the young of the Church, and have a constant tendency to draw away the mind from the stern realities of life. They are certain to vitiate spiritual life, and rob the Christian of power. Rev. Charles Wesley, while preaching at Tresmere, in England, and warning the people against what are usually called “harmless diversions,” declared “that by them he had been kept dead to God, asleep in the arms ofp. 547 Satan, and secure in a state of damnation for the space of eighteen years.” Mr. Meriten, another clergyman present, cried aloud, “and I for twenty-five years.” “And I,” exclaimed Mr. Thompson, another minister, “for thirty-five.” “And I,” exclaimed Mr. Bennett, the pastor of the church, “for above seventy years.”
It has been vehemently urged that these entertainments are good places to get acquainted. My observation and experience has been, that the so-called sociables are the most unsociable meetings held in the Church. I have attended about ten or twelve of them, but cannot recall more than that number of acquaintances made in all. If one is fortunate enough to have some friends, he can manage to have something to say and have somebody to say it to, and perhaps pass the evening pleasantly. The sociability is confined almost entirely to previous acquaintances.
On the other hand, I have found the prayer-meetings and class-meetings, the Sabbath-school and the preaching service the best places to get acquainted. Acquaintances made there are always more valuable and lasting, for the reason that they are renewed again and again. Then, too, the associations and interchange of experiences peculiar to these meetings, are admirably adapted to bring us into sympathetic and helpful relations to each other. When the Christian has his heart all aglow with love for the Master and men, he seldom waits for a formal introduction.
Another argument offered in defense of these “harmless diversions” is, that they are necessary to meet the current or incidental expenses. The policy of some seems to be, as an official member expressed it, “anything to get the money.” Rev. Mr. Luckock, who was a member of the Ohio Legislature three or four winters ago, told me that a lottery was held in connection with an entertainment given one evening in the church near his home. During the exercises one man claimed that injustice had been done him, and began to create quite a disturbance. For a while it looked as though a mob had taken possession of the church. A member ran toward the door to call for police protection, when he was seized by one of the mob, who exclaimed, “Let them fight, let them fight, it’s for the benefit of the church!”
Many people who are enthusiastic in their support of these “innocent amusements,” look upon them as being perfectly legitimate on the theory that “the end justifies the means.” In this matter of money-making they have proved as complete failures as in the other things alluded to. I am of the opinion that for every dollar they put into the treasury, they take out five. It is impossible to conceive of anything so utterly destructive of the spirit of benevolence and free-will offering (the only offering acceptable to God, according to the Bible), as these modern methods of money-making. By means of them the people have been led to expect an equivalent for everything they give. The only way to open a man’s pocket-book nowadays is to fill his stomach. When God’s work is to be supported, men must be bribed and coaxed to duty with a dish of ice-cream, or a piece of cake, or a stick of candy. It is equivalent to saying, “Lord, I’ll take half of this money and have a good time with it, and you may have the rest.”
The idea that for every cent contributed to the Church there must be received a consideration in ice-cream, oysters, cake, or bazaar articles, as a return for money given, is unscriptural and impious. God requires free-will offerings of his people, not selfish expenditures, looking to the largest returns of carnal pleasure or profit as an inducement thereto. If men will not give to the Lord, “hoping for nothing again,” in the spirit of cheerful benevolence, we are warranted in saying he does not want them to give at all. See Luke 6: 35; 2 Cor. 9: 7; Matt. 10: 8.
The Sunday School Times grows quite satirical in speaking of this subject. It says, “And now, brethren, let us get up a supper and eat ourselves rich. Buy your food; then give it to the church; then buy it back again; then eat it up; and your church debt is paid.” Instead of trusting in God for support, the assistance of the world is solicited. Our fathers paid their own bills, and did not ask Satan to pay for the weapons which they used in warfare against him. What would be thought of a wife, when a faithful husband promised to supply all her needs, if she should distrust him by asking help from his enemies; or, to obtain it, should open her house to the entertainment of sensual pleasure-seekers? Is not this precisely the course that is being pursued by the Church, the bride of Christ, in these entertainments? It is not surprising that a jealous God has said of such characters, “Ye adulterers and adulteresses, know ye not that the friendship of the world is enmity with God? Whosoever therefore will be a friend of the world is the enemy of God.” And again, “Woe to them that go down to Egypt for help; that stay on horses, and trust in chariots, because they are many; and in horsemen because they are very strong; but they look not unto the Holy One of Israel, neither seek the Lord.”
The world loves its own; and the churches which depend on the world for support, of course are obliged to please the world, conform to it, and consequently be governed by it. John Wesley’s words of warning are peculiarly applicable at this time. He said, “Beware how you invite rich men into your churches, until you are sure they are Christians. Beware how you manage your churches in such a way that rich men will become a necessity to you. If your church buildings are so luxurious that you need an enormous income, wealthy men will be a necessity to you, and they will rule you, and then you must soon bid farewell to Methodist discipline, and perhaps to Methodist doctrine.”
These modern methods of Church amusements and money-making paralyze and render powerless the soul-saving efforts and influence of the Church. The fun-loving people of the Church, those who are deeply interested in “getting up something to draw and hold our young people,” have no relish for the spiritual work of the Church. They are merely baptized worldlings, and are dead weights. Professing godliness and practicing worldliness, they are making more infidels than all the enemies outside the Church.
Some of these churches often express surprise that they do not have revivals. It would be a far greater surprise if they did have. Mr. Moody gives it as his observation, that such churches are never visited with revivals. They attribute the cause to “lack of funds;” “people are too busy;” “our pastor is not a revivalist;” “too many other things going on;” or, as was expressed to me the other day, “The church edifice is unsafe and unhealthful” (speaking of a building that had been taxed to its utmost capacity by the pleasure-seeking people). Whereas their own sins are blocking up the way of souls and the in-coming tide of salvation, and causing the awful apathy in Zion.
These things absorb so much of the time and energy of these “respectable” Laodicean churches, that they seldom think of the salvation of souls. To say that the Church cannot be sustained without these schemes to beguile the world into its support, is to libel as well as to confess the failure of Christianity. The inevitable effect of such a confession is to lower Christianity in the estimation of the very persons whom it seeks to save. An infidel once said, “I think your God must be in great need of money, by the tricks the churches practice to get it for him.” This is a gross perversion of the facts in the case.
While it is a fact that world-conformed, popular, time-serving, and pleasure-seeking churches have never been able to exist without the assistance of the world, Christianity has always been self-supporting, and, in the entire absence of these damnable devices, has planted the banner of the cross on the ruins of Satan’s strongest holds, and won the most triumphant victories.
It has been said, “A locomotive with the steam up not only goes without help, but it draws the train.” Such has been Christianity’s mighty march of conquest over all opposing forces through the centuries of the past. Where there have been real piety and pentecostal power and fire, it has not been necessary to resort to these sacrilegious snares. When the gospel has been preached and practiced in its simplicity, fullness, and purity, there has been no need of calling in flirts and fops to play and snicker over dolls and tomfooleries. History records that in the days of Tiberius it was considered a crime to carry a ring stamped with the image of Augustus into any mean or sordid place, where it might be polluted. How much may we who bear the name of Christian learn even from a heathen! If the Church would heed the admonition of the apostle, and “come out from among them and be separate,” and would “keep its robes unspotted from the world,” then its beauty and motive would charm the world, and the voice from all souls would be, “Say, have you seen my Beloved?”
The limits of this paper will not permit the discussion of another point of grave importance in this connection; viz., the desecration of the temple of God, which has been set apart for holy purposes.