We had appointed last evening to answer any questions that might be asked on the subjects we had presented. Our tent was full, and the first-day Adventists were on hand as usual. We took most of the evening for the especial purpose of answering questions. Of course they were largely on the law. This gave us a chance to explain the main passages which are usually relied upon for the abolition of the law. Among other questions which one of their prominent brethren asked, was one about the stoning penalty of the law. He said, “Is a law in force without a penalty?” We answered, “Certainly not.” (Here he thought he had made a point.) “Was not the penalty of the ten commandments stoning to death?” We answered that stoning to death was simply the penalty of the civil law, but it had nothing to do with the real penalty of the moral law, which was the second death. This has been the penalty from the days of Adam, and it yet remains unchanged. This of course really answered his objection, and he could say nothing against it.
He then referred to the tenth commandment, “Thou shalt not covet.” It struck me in a moment that there was no stoning penalty attached to this precept; there could not be. Its violation can only be in the spirit and in the heart, and hence there would be no possible way of taking hold of it outwardly. At any rate there was no penalty ever attached to its violation so far as the natural law was concerned. Evidently, then, God himself will inflict its penalty at the day of Judgment, and not before that time. So we asked him to tell us what was the penalty for the violation of this commandment. Of course he had to own up squarely that he could not tell. Then according to his own theory, here was a law that God gave that never had any penalty! All the “no-law” people claim that the whole ten commandments were only a law given to the Jews as a nation. They think that the stoning penalty is the grand proof of this position; but here is one commandment which in a moment demolishes that whole theory. I confess that I had never before noticed this strong point. I most heartily thank him for putting me on the right track. Our brethren will do well to note this fact, and use it to refute such objections.
Worcester, Mass. D. M. CANRIGHT.