“Their witness agreed not together.” Mark 14:56. These words, written concerning the trial of our Saviour, have frequently come to my mind as I have listened to various opposers to God’s holy Sabbath. The best, the purest, the truest friend to man that ever trod the earth, had come to save the fallen race. Those he came to redeem were seeking to condemn and crucify him. Many witnesses testified against him; some said one thing and some another, but the witnesses did not agree.
The Sabbath is now being restored to the world, and, like its Lord, it is opposed by the religious teachers of the day; and it may as truthfully be said of the opponents of this reform, Their witnesses do not agree.
During my experience in this work, I have seen many illustrations of this fact. One will perhaps take one position, and another will oppose it and attack the Sabbath from an entirely different standpoint. Both are declared wrong by a third as he presents a long theory by which he proposes to demolish the old Sabbath and forever settle the perplexing Sabbath question. I think I have never yet found two opponents to the Sabbath who were perfectly agreed on all points of the subject. Indeed, while Eld. Grant was trying to prove that the Sabbath was abolished, before him sat another minister who had recently preached from the same desk that the Sabbath was changed to the first day of the week by the inspired apostles. Another contends that the commandments are all binding, but it matters not which day we keep if we only keep the seventh part of time. When I asked Eld. Grant to affirm that the first day of the week was the Sabbath by divine authority, he said he would not, for he did not believe it. He has also said, “It is a fact that there is but one weekly Sabbath mentioned in the Bible.” This he claims is now abolished. I suggested that these gentlemen hold a discussion between themselves before calling upon me to argue with a man who held views upon the subject contrary to their own.
If the Sabbath of the fourth commandment is abolished, as Eld. Grant claims, then we are without a Sabbath in this dispensation. This I am not willing to admit. I came to defend an institution which is among the richest blessings that Heaven has bestowed upon man—a blessing which has been handed down to us from the garden of Eden.
“Think how the abstraction of the Sabbath would hopelessly enslave the laboring classes. Think of labor going on in one monotonous and eternal cycle, limbs forever on the rack, fingers forever straining, the brow forever sweating, the feet forever plodding, the brain forever throbbing, the shoulders forever drooping, the loins forever aching, and the restless mind forever scheming!
“Think of the beauty it would efface, the merry-heartedness it would extinguish, the giant strength it would tame, the projects it would wreck, the groans it would extort, the lives it would immolate, and the cheerless graves it would prematurely dig! See them toiling and moiling, sweating and fretting, grinding and hewing, weaving and spinning, strewing and gathering, mowing and reaping, razing and building, digging and planting, striving and struggling, in the granary and the barn, in the factory and the mill, in the warehouse and the shop, on the mountain and in the ditch, on the roadside and in the wood, in the city and in the country, on the sea and on the shore, in the day of brightness and the day of gloom. What a picture would this world present if we had no Sabbath!” This institution, our Saviour tells us, was made for man. I will now examine the arguments brought forward to prove that God has taken this blessing away:—
“God was very strict about the Sabbath, and whoever broke it was to be put to death. That penalty has been taken away. We can now go out and work on the seventh day and not be stoned; therefore, the Sabbath must be abolished.” “To say that the law is in force after the penalty has been removed would be to talk nonsense.”
This no doubt may appear to some like a sound argument. Let us apply the rule to see how it will work. Turn to Deut. 17:2–5. We here learn that if any man or woman “hath gone and served other gods, and worshiped them, either the sun, or moon, or any of the host of heaven,” that man or that woman shall be taken unto the gates, and the people shall “stone them with stones, till they die.” Is that penalty now in force? Go over to California and there you will see men worshiping the Chinese gods, and still enjoying life and liberty. Is it therefore right to worship false gods? Yes, it is, according to Eld. Grant’s argument. Then why send missionaries to convert the heathen?
Take another of the moral precepts: “Thou shalt not take the name of the Lord thy God in vain.” Now read Lev. 24:16: “He that blasphemeth the name of the Lord, he shall surely be put to death, and all the congregation shall certainly stone him; as well the stranger, as he that is born in the land, when he blasphemeth the name of the Lord, shall be put to death.” Eld. Grant says he can go out and work on the seventh day and not get stoned to death. I heard a young man, the other day, utter most terribly profane oaths; but nobody stoned him to death for it. If this argument is good to uphold Sabbath-breaking, it will uphold profanity just the same. Shall we teach our boys that they can swear and blaspheme the name of God as much as they please, and it is all right, because the stoning system is done away? Here is a text in Lev. 20:10 that will make his position look rather dark; but it will show you just what this theory would lead to: “The man that committeth adultery with another man’s wife, even he that committeth adultery with his neighbor’s wife, the adulterer and the adulteress shall surely be put to death.”
Does the gospel enforce this penalty? Hear what Christ says in John 8:3–11: “The scribes and Pharisees brought unto him a woman taken in adultery; and when they had set her in the midst, they say unto him, Master, this woman was taken in adultery, in the very act. Now Moses in the law commanded us, that such should be stoned; but what sayest thou?” Then after Jesus had brought a test that showed that they all had sinned, he said to the woman, “Neither do I condemn thee; go and sin no more.” They ask if the penalty shall be enforced; but Christ bids her go free and sin no more, thus showing that the penalty is not to be enforced by the gospel. But does that make it right? How will such reasoning sound when applied to this commandment? Here are Mr. Grant’s own words, as printed in his book: “To say that a law is in force after the penalty has been removed, would be to talk nonsense!” Christ’s mission to this world was not to administer condemnation and death. “For God sent not his Son into the world to condemn the world; but that the world through him might be saved.” John 3:17. Christ pleads with men to turn from their sins. He offers pardon and mercy to the vilest sinner. Oh! shall we be so ungrateful for his long-suffering and forbearance as to claim the liberty to transgress the law of God because we are not immediately stoned to death for it?
His next argument was upon the manner of keeping the Sabbath:—
“Those who kept the Sabbath were required to offer two lambs every Sabbath day. Num. 28:9. If the lambs were not offered, the Sabbath was not kept. If we offer sacrifices now, we deny Christ; hence, no one can keep the Sabbath without denying Christ.”
If I understand this position correctly, each individual who observed the Sabbath properly was anciently required to offer two lambs as a manner of keeping the Sabbath. Here is a brother who tried to keep last Sabbath. Did he offer two lambs as a sacrifice? No. Then he did not keep the Sabbath. Here is another brother. Did he563offer two lambs last Sabbath? He says he did not. Then he also broke the Sabbath, according to Eld. Grant’s argument. Have I stated your objection correctly, Bro. Grant? He answers, “Yes.” Then, according to his teaching, every individual was required to offer one hundred and four lambs per year, in order to keep the Sabbath. Rather a heavy tax that would be. Bro. R. says he has only seven sheep on his farm; surely his Sabbath-keeping would not last long at that rate. But that is not the worst of it. The same law in the same chapter of Numbers says, “Ye shall offer unto the Lord two lambs of the first year without spot, day by day, for a continual burnt-offering.” Read the 28th and 29th chapters of Numbers, and you will find that if these were individual offerings, then every person was required to offer over one thousand sheep, and one hundred head of cattle, besides large quantities of flour, oil, etc., every year. All can see the absurdity of this position. It would be utterly impossible. These were not individual offerings, but the language refers to the work of the priests at the sanctuary (Heb. 5:1; 8:3, 4), and is no part of the Sabbatic institution. As the people could keep the Sabbath at their homes, which may have been hundreds of miles from the sanctuary where the priests offered the two lambs for the sins of the whole nation, so we can keep the Sabbath now, while Christ, our high priest (Heb. 8:1–3), offers his blood in the heavenly sanctuary.
The absurdity of this argument is further shown by the following facts: first, the Sabbath was instituted in Eden before sin entered our world, when no sin-offering was needed; secondly, the children of Israel had kept the Sabbath thirty-nine years in the wilderness before Moses received command for the offering of the two extra lambs on the Sabbath (compare Num. 22:1; 27:12, 13; 28:9; 36:13); thirdly, the sin-offering was done away when the great sacrifice was made on the cross, but the Sabbath was kept “according to the commandment” after the crucifixion. Luke 23:56.
The remaining and principal part of his discourse was in regard to the word “forever,” to show that it does not always mean eternity, but may refer to a limited period of time. I was a little surprised that he held the audience so long, to prove a point on which we are perfectly agreed; indeed, I have often used the same scripture to prove the same point—that “forever” may in some cases be limited. But after proving one thing conclusively, he skillfully assumed that he had proved something else. He read the scriptures which say that the passover, the sacrifices, the blowing of trumpets, etc., were to continue forever; then said he, “Forever does not mean any longer than through their generations;” and as the Sabbath was to continue forever (Ex. 31:17), he concluded that the Sabbath ended with the Jewish dispensation. Now let us see if “forever” always ends with the Jewish age. Dan. 2:44: “In the days of these kings shall the God of heaven set up a kingdom, which shall never be destroyed; . . . it shall stand forever.” Dan. 12:3: “They that be wise shall shine as the brightness of the firmament; and they that turn many to righteousness, as the stars forever and ever.” Luke 1:33: “And he [Christ] shall reign over the house of Jacob forever; and of his kingdom there shall be no end.” That “forever” in these scriptures means eternity, no one will question. To say that “forever” means only through the old dispensation, would be to limit the kingdom of God and the reign of Christ to that age of the world, and would cut off our hopes of eternal life.
I have now examined every argument which he has thus far brought to bear against the Sabbath. The first, if it is sound, would license idolatry, blasphemy, adultery, and many other sins. The second is of no force, as the offering of lambs was no part of the Sabbatic institution. The Sabbath was kept before the lambs were offered, and it was observed by the disciples of Christ after the sacrifices were done away. The third proves nothing, since “forever” sometimes means a limited period of time, and it sometimes signifies eternity. Surely the Sabbath will stand if it has no more formidable obstacles to meet.