(Concluded.)
THE TEACHINGS OF THE FATHERS; THE LOST-TIME QUESTION; THE ROUND-EARTH THEORY AND THE SABBATH AT THE POLES DISCUSSED; MR. THOUGHTFUL EMBRACES THE SABBATH, AND MR. NOLAW AGREES TO DO SO IN THE NEAR FUTURE.
BY ELD. W. H. LITTLEJOHN.
Mr. Biblist.—How is it, gentlemen, about new theories respecting the change of the Sabbath? Have you any to offer?
Mr. Surplice.—We revere the writings of the Fathers very highly in our church, and I think I could prove the change of the Sabbath from them.
Maud.—Excuse me, father, but I do not understand Mr. Surplice. Who are the “Fathers” to whom he refers? I remember that Paul says that “God spake in time past unto the fathers by the prophets.” Are these the Fathers to whom Mr. Surplice alludes?
Mr. B.—No, my daughter; the Fathers of whom Mr. Surplice speaks, are nowhere mentioned in the Bible. God has never spoken of them nor through them. They were men who lived in the centuries lying just this side of the apostolic age. Some of their writings have come down to us in a mutilated form, but they are utterly unreliable, as they have been interpolated by the papacy in order to make them teach the doctrines of the Catholic Church. If you please, hand me the third volume of Clarke’s Commentary from the book-case. I read from his remarks on the eighth chapter of Proverbs: “But of these [the Fathers] we may safely state that there is not a truth in the most orthodox creed that cannot be proved by their authority; nor a heresy that has disgraced the Romish Church that may not challenge them as its abettors. In points of doctrine their authority is, with me, nothing. The word of God alone contains my creed.” If these gentlemen insist upon doing so, we will enter into an investigation of what these Fathers say in regard to the Sabbath question. I am prepared to show that every word favorable to Sunday sanctity that purports to have been written before the third century is a fraud.
Mr. Nolaw.—I think that you must be hard pressed, gentlemen, when you appeal to the Fathers in your Sunday argument. If you keep on, you will be putting somebody else into purgatory, if you don’t get there yourselves before long.
Maud.—What does Mr. Nolaw mean, father?
Mr. B.—He means, Maud, that any one who will appeal to the Fathers in matters of doctrine, must, if consistent, become a papist. He is right there, too; for as Mr. Clarke intimates in what I have just read, they can be quoted to prove every heresy of Romanism, purgatory and saint-worship not excepted.
Mr. Dipper.—Yes, or trine immersion, infant baptism, or almost any other absurdity. I wish it distinctly understood that I take no stock in the writings of the Fathers on a question like this.
Mr. Shouter.—Neither do I. John Wesley never would have quoted them, I am sure.
Mr. Westminster.—Our church standards recognize the authority of nothing but the Bible in matters of faith. But what is the use of talking about this question any longer? We couldn’t find the seventh day of the week if it were our duty to keep it. You know that in the change from “Old Style” to “New Style,” time has been lost since the days of Christ. Besides, if no time had been lost since Christ’s day, we have no way of determining which day of the week was the original rest day of Jehovah.p. 418 The only change made was that of calling the third of September, the fourteenth of September. To illustrate: if the third of September in 1751 fell on Wednesday, by the change made, it was called Wednesday the fourteenth, instead of Wednesday the third, of September.
Mr. B.—Can it be possible that my ears do not deceive me? Are you not the very gentleman who a few evenings since argued with much apparent candor that we ought to hallow the first day of the week in obedience to the example of the early Church?
Mr. W.—I believe I did take that position.
Mr. B.—A duty to do, implies the ability to perform. If it is our duty to hallow the first day of the week in obedience to the example of the early Church, as you argued, then certainly we must be able to locate that day. Please tell us how you do so, therefore, and we shall have no difficulty in identifying the Sabbath, or seventh day; for we learn from Matt. 28:1 that the Sabbath immediately precedes the first day of the week.
Mr. W.—W-e-l-l, what about the lost-time question?
Mr. B.—Oh! no matter about that just now; tell us how you find the Sunday, if you please, and perhaps that will help us out of our difficulty.
Mr. Nolaw.—Don’t quibble, Mr. Westminster, don’t quibble. You know that this thing is just as broad as it is long. As sure as it is that figures will not lie, you can find the seventh, when once you have located the first day of the week.
Mr. B.—Nothing tries my patience more than to see men compass heaven and earth to bring others to the point of hallowing the first day of the week, and then take the position, when convinced that the seventh-day Sabbath is binding, that time has been lost, and that we cannot identify the days of the week as they existed in Christ’s time. Perhaps, however, it is one’s duty to stretch the lines of charity as far as possible, and patiently show such persons that their theory about the loss of time in the change from Old to New Style is purely mythical.
Maud.—What do you mean, father, by “Old Style” and “New Style”?
Mr. B.—I will tell you, Maud; or rather I will read to you what Noah Webster says about it:— “Style is Old or New. The Old Style follows the Julian manner of computing the months and days, or the calendar as established by Julius Cæsar, in which every fourth year consists of 366 days, and the other years of 365 days. This is about eleven minutes in a year too much. Pope Gregory XIII. reformed the calendar by retrenching ten days in October, 1582, in order to bring back the vernal equinox to the same day as at the time of the Council of Nice, A. D. 325. This reformation was adopted by act of Parliament in Great Britain in 1751, by which act eleven days in September, 1752, were retrenched, and the third day was reckoned the fourteenth. This mode of reckoning is called New Style, according to which every year divisible by 4, unless it is divisible by 100 without being divisible by 400, has 366 days, and any other year 365 days.”
You see from what I have just read that the change from Old Style to New Style in no wise affected the days of the week. They remained the same as they were formerly and as they now are.p. 419
Now a word about the difficulty of locating the day of the creation Sabbath. We learn from John 15:10 that Christ kept the commandments of the Father. One of those commandments required the observance of the creation Sabbath. Christ certainly knew what day that was in his time, and observed it; else he could not be said to keep the commandments of the Father. But he hallowed the same day that the Jews celebrated as the Sabbath. From that time to this, all over the world, they have observed, as they do now, the Sabbath of their fathers. From that time to the present, also, the heathen have consecrated the first day of the week to their deities. From the sixth century down, the Mohammedans have made Friday a holy day. You see, consequently, that it is utterly out of the question that the days of the week have been displaced since the first century. But this being so, our Saturday, or seventh day of the week, is the very day that Christ hallowed as the Sabbath, and consequently, the same as the one upon which God rested, and which he blessed and sanctified in the beginning. To doubt this, would be to doubt without reason.
Before passing from this branch of the subject, I might add that so far as the Old and the New Style are concerned, the Russians still follow the former method, and their days of the week are numbered the same as our own; thus demonstrating again the absurdity of the notion that the change from Old Style to New Style in any way affected the numbering of those days.
Mr. Shouter.—I don’t care anything about your lost-time question. I have an objection which you cannot dispose of as easily as you have of that.
Mr. B.—Well, what is it, Mr. Shouter?
Mr. S.—Why, sir, the world is round, as you must know, and turns upon its axis every twenty-four hours. You can no more find the seventh day on a round earth that revolves on its axis, than you can find a beginning in a complete circle.
Maud.—Is the world any rounder on Saturday than it is on Sunday, father?
Mr. Nolaw.—That’s pretty good for you, Miss Maud. I was about to ask that question myself.
Mr. B.—This reminds me of one of our ministers, who, by the way, was a little eccentric in his argumentative methods. He used to carry around with him a small rubber globe about the size of an apple. This was so arranged that by a certain process it could be expanded to its full size in a moment. This done, it could be made to collapse in an instant by touching a spring. Whenever Sunday-keepers—as they were sure to do during a course of lectures—would fetch up this round-world theory, he would immediately bring his rubber globe to the elucidation of the subject. Holding it in his hand in full view of the congregation he would turn it over and over to represent the movement of the earth during the last six days of the week. When, however, he came to the first day, he would suddenly touch the spring remarking as he did so: “You see, ladies and gentlemen, that the earth, though round as a ball on other days, becomes as flat as a pancake as soon as we reach the first day of the week.” You can imagine the result. The whole assembly, perceiving from this practical illustration the absurd predicament which one occupied who, while advocating the sanctity of the first day of the week, denies that the seventh day of the week can be found on a round earth, would break out into loud laughter, much to the chagrin of the first-day objector. It is an old adage that “Those who live in glass houses, should not throw stones.” I commend this wise maxim to the careful consideration of those who, while advocating the strict observance of the first day of the week, deny that the seventh can be identified.
The Sabbath and the first day stand or fall together so far as the argument drawn from the round earth is concerned. In view of this fact, perhaps our first-day friends will not reject an explanation which is the only one that will enable us to do away with the difficulties of locating one and all of the days of the week. I begin by suggesting that, practically speaking, the objection that the earth is round and revolves upon its axis daily, has no force. The traveler who departs from New York City or any other point, and circumnavigates our globe, will find men observing Sunday the whole length of his trip. It is true that their Sunday in different degrees of longitude neither begins nor ends at the same time. It is, nevertheless, one and the same day that they keep. The revolution of the earth carries the day around our world, if I may be allowed the expression, from east to west, and men in different localities celebrate it when it comes to them. The same thing can be done with reference to the seventh day. It was not the design of the Lord that the Sabbath should be hallowed by the inhabitants of the different hemispheres on the same identical hours.
Mr. Dipper.—Where is your proof for that?
Mr. B.—It can be proved in various ways. Mount Sinai lay to the west of Jerusalem. The sun sets in the latter some minutes before it does in the former place. Nevertheless the children of Israel, under the direct supervision of the Lord, and without his rebuke, commenced their Sabbaths at Jerusalem at the same time that they did at Sinai; i. e., at sunset. The Jews, no matter how far eastward or how far westward they traveled, acted upon the same principle; that is, they commenced their Sabbaths at the going down of the sun. Indeed, God gave them an express command to do this. In Lev. 23:32, a text that has already been cited, he directed explicitly that they should celebrate their Sabbaths “from even to even,” or from sunset to sunset. You see, therefore, that we have the very highest authority in the universe for commencing the Sabbath at sunset wherever we may be. But this implies two things; first, that all men cannot hallow the Sabbath on the same hours; secondly, that as we travel from the Eastern to the Western hemisphere, following the day in its course, we shall find that individuals will commence their Sabbath later and later, in the ratio of their distance from the Eastern hemisphere, where Adam, (for whom the Sabbath was created) was made, and where the Sabbath itself was brought into being by the fiat of Jehovah, and commenced for the first time its passage around the world.
There must be somewhere on the surface of the earth that which is sometimes termed a day line, or a meridian of longitude on which the day begins its course around our globe. That line is located right where an individual, if standing there, might have seen the sun go down at the close of the sixth day of creation. In passing from one to the other side of that line one would pass the boundary line at which one day of the week ends, and another begins. It will be seen, therefore, that if the day line, as it passes from north to south, should cross any habitable portion of the globe, confusion would result; for it would be very difficult to determine at all times just where the day line was to be found. The only way to avoid this confusion would be to have the day line pass from the north to the south somewhere through the Atlantic or Pacific Ocean. But it would not do to have the line pass through the Atlantic Ocean; for it could not do so without crossing large islands or bodies of land capable of sustaining millions of people. Not so, however, would it be with the Pacific Ocean. A line drawn northward and southward through the latter, and starting from a point somewhere in Behring Strait, would, as you will perceive by examining a large globe, pass the whole length of that vast body of water either without touching any land whatever, or at least without crossing any but one or two of the very smallest of its islands.
Here, then, right where the Eastern and Western hemispheres approach each other the most nearly, the topography of the world would seem to indicate that the day line should be located. Right here, also, the Bible record would appear to place it. The Jews, whenever traveling to the eastward of Jerusalem, in the exact ratio of their distance from that place, were compelled to commence the Sabbath earlier and earlier than they did in the latter city. Again, when they went in a westerly direction from Jerusalem, they were in the habit of commencing the Sabbath with the going down of the sun, or a little later and later as they passed farther and farther from their place of departure. From this it is readily inferred that the day line in the conception of the God of the Bible lay east of the Eastern continent, and west of Jerusalem. But as already shown, there is but one place on the round world where it could properly be located; viz., in the Pacific Ocean, on the longitude of Behring Strait. It is not a little remarkable that, practically speaking, the commercial world have located the day line within a few miles of the point where I have argued that it properly belongs. The masters of vessels either drop out a day from, or add a day to, their reckoning as they cross the 180th meridian of longitude. If they are sailing in an easterly direction, they drop a day; if in a westerly, they add a day. By following this practice they circumnavigate the globe again and again, and always find themselves in harmony with the men of all longitudes in the matter of numbering the days of the week.
If the theory that I have advanced upon this subject is not correct, it must be true, nevertheless, that there is some method by which it is possible to determine the exact point of time at which the Sabbath commences in every part of the world. If this be not so, God himself is impeached; for the fourth commandment certainly enforces a definite Sabbath-day on all men everywhere, a fact which would show a lack of wisdom on the part of its Author, if indeed it were impossible for men of all longitudes to identify the Sabbath when it comes to them. But why multiply words. As already remarked, the Sunday and the Sabbath stand together in this particular. If you can find one, you can certainly find the other.
Mr. Westminster.—Let us drop this day-line question, and consider another objection not so easily handled. In the regions near the poles they have six months’ day and six months’ night, alternately. Now I would like to know how they can find the seventh-day Sabbath.
Mr. B.—Suppose they cannot; what then?
Mr. W.—Why, that would prove that they are under no obligation to hallow the seventh day.
Mr. N.—Well, neighbor Westminster, I think that you must have reached the very last ditch in your argument. A pretty cold place it must be, too. I rather pity you away up there in those frozen regions. By the way, I think I could help those Northerners out of their Sabbath trouble.
Mr. W.—How would you do it, pray?
Mr. N.—How would I do it? Why, if I were in their place I would run down a first-day man; and after finding out the day which he keeps, I would hallow the one that comes just before it. That would put me all right, you see.
Mr. B.—You observe, Mr. Westminster, that our friend Nolaw has brought you face to face again with the ugly fact that men who advocate the binding obligation of the first-day Sabbath the world over, simply stultify themselves when they take the position that the seventh-day Sabbath cannot be identified in all latitudes and longitudes. There is point as well as wit in what Mr. Nolaw says. If, however, I were to answer your objection, I would do it in one of two ways. As a matter of fact, it is true that in the northern regions of which you speak, it is possible to mark the coming and going of the days by the changes in the twilight during the six months of night, and by the position of the sun in the heavens during the six months of day. Again, the eternal ice and snow as well as the invisibility of the sun during six months in the year, declare in unmistakable language that God never designed that men should inhabit localities where nature is so unpropitious. If, therefore, individuals refuse to heed the fiat of the Creator as expressed in his works, they need not be surprised if they find themselves placed under circumstances where it will be more or less difficult for them to observe his written laws. Let these men return to the regions which God intended that they should occupy, and it will result in benefit to themselves, and relieve them at once from all embarrassment in the matter of finding the true seventh day.
If you have any other objections, gentlemen, which are worthy to be called such, please bring them forward. If I mistake not, you have nearly run the circle of those which are ordinarily presented. I think of no more.
Mr. Shouter.—John Wesley observed Sunday, and I know that he was a good man. You may say what you please, I shall do as Wesley did.
Mr. W.—Sunday is recognized by the standards of our church, and I should not be a good Presbyterian if I did not follow the teachings of those standards. The Westminster Assembly certainly knew which day was the Sabbath.
Mr. Surplice.—The Episcopal church is a unitp. 420 on the Sunday question. She will cling to the Sabbath of the Prayer-book and of the traditions of the past.
Mr. Nolaw.—You mean by that, I suppose, that you will continue in your ritual service to invoke the aid of the Lord in the matter of keeping the fourth commandment, and yet persist in breaking it every week. I do not know what to make of these things. I once asked one of your church members how it was that when the minister read the fourth commandment in the public service he could respond with so much unction, “Lord, have mercy upon us, and incline our hearts to keep this law,” when he knew all the time that it required the observance of the seventh-day Sabbath. His response was that he always uttered those words with a “mental reservation”! I think, Mr. Surplice, that it is a pretty serious thing to ask God to help us to keep one of his commandments when we know that it requires something at our hands that we do not intend to perform. As for your Prayer-book, there may be in it many good things, but it will not be the standard of judgment in the great day. It will not avail a man much then to insist that he has kept the Sabbath of the Prayer-book, unless it be also the Sabbath of the Bible.
Mr. Dipper.—It looks to me to be preposterous that a little handful of Seventh-day Adventists should undertake to revolutionize the world in the matter of Sabbath observance. You might as well give it up, Mr. Biblist, as a hopeless task; it never can be accomplished.
Mr. B.—No doubt you are correct there, Mr. Dipper. If I needed any additional proof to satisfy me that the world cannot be revolutionized on the Sabbath question, I have it before me to-night. One could hardly expect that the rank and file of the churches could be brought to obey the commandments of God when their ministers make them of less authority than prayer-books and church creeds and traditions. There are times, however, when it is the duty of those who fear God to “cry aloud and spare not;” whether men hear or forbear. We are now standing in just such an epoch. The Lord is about to come. A people who will be prepared to meet their coming King, are to be gathered out from the wicked world and the fallen churches. God in his wisdom is making obedience to his law the test of fidelity to his government. He has, for reasons best known to himself, allowed the papacy for a time to change the Sabbath from the seventh to the first day of the week; but now he calls upon men everywhere to return to the observance of the only Sabbath which he has ever commanded any one to hallow. It seems to me that he could not have chosen a more successful method of making manifest the counsels of all hearts. Duty is made so plain in the order of his providence that none need err. At the same time, those who wish to evade the plain teachings of the Scriptures, now as ever find abundant opportunity to cavil. It is true that Sabbatarians are in the minority; but it is neither new nor strange that God should intrust a great reform to a few instead of to many. Indeed, a man who would reject the light and the truth because it was not received by the masses, could never be a reformer. From the very necessity of the case, we must differ with those whom we wish to help; and as the masses of men need help, reformers must always expect to be singular.
As it regards prayer-books and church creeds, let me say that they are of no account when they are not in harmony with the book of God. One “thus saith the Lord” is worth more to me in the settlement of matters of doctrine than all the creeds that men have ever formulated.
Respecting the good men of the past who have been Sunday-keepers, I remark that they will stand approved before God because they lived up to the best light which they had. The time had not been reached in their day and generation for the inauguration of the Sabbath reform. If it had been introduced in their epoch we feel assured that they would not have rejected it; because they followed implicitly the teachings of the Scriptures, as they understood them, on all points. If Mr. Shouter would honor the memory of John Wesley, he should do so, not by slavishly adhering to his errors, but by catching the spirit of reform which animated the soul of that great and good man. He has studied the life of Wesley in vain who does not know that he would have counseled others to follow him only as far as he followed Christ.
Mr. Thoughtful.—I cannot contain myself longer. When I first came to interview Mr. Biblist on the subject of the sanctuary, I knew little or nothing about the faith of his people. I very soon found that they had light on the types and ceremonies of the old dispensation not possessed by any other denomination. Step by step, I was led along the line of prophecy until I could see very clearly that the coming of the Lord was just at hand, and that the Judgment even now is in session. These were important truths, and I naturally inferred that those who held them might be in possession of others of equal consequence. In this I found that I was not mistaken when Mr. Biblist presented to me the claims of the seventh-day Sabbath. The argument seemed to be straightforward and conclusive. I prayed much and studied the Scriptures with a view to ascertaining the facts in the case. As a last resort, I invited you gentlemen of the ministry to meet Mr. Biblist in friendly discussion on the subject. You assured me that you would silence him in short order. I trusted that you would not break to the heart the promise that you made to the ear. How great was my disappointment, therefore, when I found that your theories of the change of the Sabbath were contradictory in the extreme, and most unsatisfactory in every respect. Your efforts, instead of bringing relief to my mind, have confirmed me in the opinion that Seventh-day Adventists are right when they argue in favor of the ancient Sabbath of the Lord, taking the position that it has been changed by the papacy to the first day of the week. It cannot be possible that men who are defending the truth and the right should be compelled to make such shifts in their reasoning as you gentlemen have been compelled to do in your efforts to find Bible authority for Sunday-keeping. I am sure that no unbiased mind could fail to see, not only that your theories have been conflicting, but also that your inferences have either been far-fetched or positively illogical. I wish it distinctly understood that, cost what it may, henceforth I shall hallow the only day that is called the Sabbath in the Bible, and the only one that God has ever commanded any man to observe. Let those tamper with the oracles of God who do not fear his name. As for me, I shall hereafter proceed on the safe principle that as God says what he means, and means what he says, he would never have commanded men to hallow the seventh day of the week, and then change the law in which he had made this requirement, without notifying those concerned of the alteration in his purpose. From this time forward I shall identify myself with Seventh-day Adventists, as I believe with all my heart that they are indeed the people of whom the Revelator said, “Here is the patience of the saints; here are they that keep the commandments of God, and the faith of Jesus.”
Mr. N.—I honor you for the decision which you have made. If God will forgive me for the insult which I offered to him in opposing his law, I will stand by your side. When I came to these interviews, I knew very well that the seventh-day Sabbath was binding if the law of God was still in force. Now that I am satisfied that it is obligatory in this dispensation, I see no way of escaping the conclusion that we must hallow the day which it requires us to observe.
As for the efforts of these my brethren in the ministry to bolster up the Sunday institution, I must say that in my judgment they have been consummate failures. As men in a quagmire sink lower and lower in the ratio of their efforts to extricate themselves, so these gentlemen have made confusion worse confounded as they have crossed and recrossed the line of their argument in the vain endeavor to escape from the absurdities of one situation after another. At first we were told that Christ changed the Sabbath by direct command. Finding themselves utterly unable to prove that such was the case, they informed us next that redemption was greater than creation, and that the church, therefore, had changed the Sabbath in order to commemorate it in a fitting manner. Finding a second time that the argument was against them, they fell back upon the example of Christ as something that furnishes a warrant for Sunday-keeping. When it was made clear to them that an argument based on the example of Christ would make it necessary for them to hallow three Sabbaths instead of one, they deliberately abandoned that line of logic, and took the ground that the early Church, instructed by Christ and the apostles, habitually assembled for worship on the first day of the week. Finding that a careful examination of the record brought to view but one instance in twenty-eight years in which the apostolic Church actually assembled for worship on Sunday, and that the latter portion of that particular day was spent by Paul and the disciples in travel either on the highway or on the sea, they all of one accord deliberately adopted the seventh-part-of-time theory, thus surrendering altogether every theory which they had formerly advocated respecting the special sanctity of the day of the resurrection. Was there ever a more tangled skein than this? Every position in order swallows up its predecessor, until the last is reached, when all are engulfed in the doctrine that there is, after all, no day which is, in a special sense, holy time. As a rule, it is safe to decide that any doctrine is not sound when it becomes apparent that its advocates seek to establish its correctness by dissimilar and conflicting lines of argument.
Great truths lie out upon the surface of the word of God, where all can see them; and they are reached by a route so broad and so direct that no one thinks of approaching them by any other avenue. It is for these reasons that, after having watched the progress of this discussion carefully, I have become satisfied that the seventh-day Sabbath is binding, and that the first day of the week was never designed to take its place. You gentlemen who have been advocating the change of the Sabbath have had the advantage in numbers, and have not been lacking in ability; and yet, though laboring hard, you have been easily routed at every point by your antagonist. While you have met at every turn obstacles which you did not anticipate, Mr. Biblist has easily found helps in either the text or context which would almost seem to have been placed there by providential design for your confusion and his support. As I have before intimated, this can only be accounted for on the ground that Mr. Biblist is in the right and you in the wrong. I exceedingly regret that in the outset I should have been found fighting the truth of God. I humbly confess my fault, and hope in the future to make some reparation for the mistakes in the past by studying the word of God more carefully, and living out its teachings in every particular.
Mr. B.—Mr. Nolaw has presented so complete a summary of the points discussed by you and myself, gentlemen, that I need not go over them again. I commend to your candid and prayerful consideration the arguments which I have introduced from time to time in support of doctrines which I believe bear the stamp of God. In a matter of such consequence as the one which we have been discussing, you certainly cannot afford to be in the wrong.
I recommend to you the course pursued by Mr. Nolaw. Finding that he was in error, he has frankly acknowledged his mistake, a thing which is honorable under all circumstances. In closing these interviews which I have held with Mr. Thoughtful and others, since he first called at my house to obtain light respecting the tabernacle of Moses and its services, I can but express my gratitude to God that he has rewarded my labors by adding two individuals to the number of those who will henceforth regard and advocate the claims of his law and his Sabbath. As I welcome them to a share in the toils and the reward of faithful commandment-keepers, permit me to express the earnest hope that it may be my good fortune in the near future to see you all engaged in a work so exalted as that committed to those who are trying to restore to its proper place in the hearts of his people the down-trodden Sabbath of Jehovah.
Battle Creek, Mich.