AdventAI

“A FRAUD EXPOSED.”

By E. Kelsey

From Review and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 27., July 7, 1885

E. KELSEY: You will find the subject of your inquiry treated upon in another column in the article by Eld. R. S. Webber, entitled “A Fraud Exposed.” It is but just to Eld. W. to state that he left it to us to give the article a heading, and we give it the one it bears, which we think is none too strong for the case in hand. The flourish made over English astronomers in the article which Eld. Webber reviews is one of the tricks of sophists in which they presume that the common reader will never take the trouble to investigate the correctness of the statements made; and hence with many they will have as much weight as if they were true, and so help to establish the view which the writer seeks thus unworthily to maintain.

Not more firmly are the cables of Brooklyn Bridge anchored in their rocky beds, than the argument which sustains the application of the 2300 days, as it was made in 1844, and as we still make it, is anchored in the eternal rock of truth. The event from which they date—the going forth of the commandment to restore and build Jerusalem—occurred, according to the 7th chapter of Ezra in the 7th year of the Persian king Artaxerxes Longimanus; and the 7th year of this king, B. C. 457, is one of the most clearly established dates of all chronology. If this date can be set aside, then every system of chronology is unsettled, and the study may be given up2 as of no certainty or any possible benefit whatever. See Dr. Hales. All the attempts that have ever been made to unsettle this date have no more effect than the playing of thistle down around the base of Bunker Hill monument.

Beginning the 2300 days in 457 B. C., we find the end of the 69 weeks in the autumn of A. D. 27, where our Lord’s ministry commenced, the crucifixion in the spring of A. D. 31, where the best authorities place it, the end of the seventy weeks in the autumn of A. D. 34, and the termination of the whole period of 2300 days in the autumn of 1844.

In this exposition Seventh-day Adventists are unanimous, and have been from the beginning of their history; and there is nothing, nor ever has been, in the writings of Mrs. White, at variance with this view. The talk of Mr. S. about a part of our people locating the cross at the end of the seventy weeks, or in A. D. 34, is simply a piece of puerile ignorance or mendacity.

The reader would not be able to take the full measure of the man with whom Eld. Webber is dealing without a little specimen of his expository ability. In the Voice of the West of Nov. 16, 1864, then published by J. V. Himes, at Buchanan, Mich., Mr. Sheldon undertook to explain how the past Advent movement of 1840-44, could be in the order of Providence, and yet, according to his view, an entire failure. He held it to be a subject of prophecy, and that the movement was set forth by the striking symbol of Rev. 10—a mighty angel coming down from heaven, clothed with a cloud, a rainbow on his head, crying with a loud voice that time should be no longer, etc. This he applied to the great advent proclamation, of the years named, which we hold in common to be true. But instead of calling the time prophetic time, which did there end, as the angel declared, and which explains the whole matter, he takes the position that it is literal time, which did not there end. Now he has on his hands the problem how to account for the solemn oath of the angel, and vindicate the movement as in the order and providence of God, while, in his view, the time was wrong, the movement wrong, and everything about it wrong. A happy thought strikes him. It will be noticed, he says, that the angel was “clothed with a cloud,” that is, he could not see all things clearly, and so proclaimed a time which was wrong; and when he got out of the cloud, he found he was mistaken, and commissioned John to prophesy again. This put into plain language means that this angel whose “face was as it were the sun,” got lost in the fog, and not knowing where he was, or what he was about, he launched out with a tremendous oath, in the name of high Heaven, that time should be no more; but the fog at length cleared away, and lo! he found that his message was all a mistake; and then, instead of manfully correcting his own errors, he slips this work off upon John, telling him he must prophesy again, and ignominiously retires from the field. Mr. S. is still at the work of trying to correct the mistake of that angel. We respectfully submit that he has just transposed the parties, and that he and not the angel is the one who is lost in the fog. The reader will agree with us that an exposition like this deserves to be swept with such a storm of derision as never to presume to lift up its head again.