A FRAUD EXPOSED

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 7, 1885

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 27.

Read the full edition

A FRAUD EXPOSED.

BY ELD. R. S. WEBBER.
In the World’s Crisis, Eld. Wm. Sheldon published a private letter I wrote to him concerning a quotation he had made from a vision of Mrs. E. G. White, which he said was on page 61 of “Experience and Views.” I wrote to him that I did not find it on page 61 of the late edition, and asked him where he found it. I also said I did not find it in the edition I had; but I afterwards found it on page 64.
In the articles he had written for the Crisis, I saw he had greatly misrepresented this quotation, if he had quoted it correctly; hence my desire to see it. Eld. S., in the Crisis of Oct. 3, 1883, represented Seventh-day Adventists as teaching that the crucifixion occurred A. D. 34. Some of his brethren saw the statement was absolutely false, and called his attention to it. He attempted to shield himself by misrepresenting this quotation, as will be shown further on. A first-day Adventist saw the misstatement, and caused the following to be published in the Crisis of Nov. 28, 1883:—
“I noticed a statement in the Crisis of Nov. 14, from Bro. Sheldon, when writing upon the 2300 days ending in 1844, that a class of Advent believers held that the crucifixion occurred in A. D. 34 [a similar statement was made in the Crisis of Oct. 3], which he [Eld. Sheldon] claims could not be possible, as the passover came that year on Tuesday, and Christ could not have lain in the grave five days.
“We simply want to say, if he refers to the Seventh-day Adventist people, he does them an injustice, as they teach that Christ was crucified in the midst of the 69th week [he should have said the 70th week], bringing the crucifixion A. D. 31 (See ‘Thoughts on Daniel,’ pp. 254–260), and the ending of the 70 weeks A. D. 34. Please tell us on what day the passover occurred in A. D. 31.”
In the World’s Crisis of Dec. 19, 1883, Eld. Sheldon replies as follows:—
“In the Crisis of Nov. 28, Bro. L. D. Small thinks I am incorrect in the supposition that our Sabbath friends end the 70 weeks at the cross, etc. . . . We briefly respond: We were aware that a portion of them, like Andrews, put the cross in A. D. 31; but Mrs. White says, ‘I have seen that the 1843 chart was directed by the hand of the Lord, and that it should not be altered; that the figures were as he wanted them, that his hand was over, and hid a mistake in some of the figures so none could see it till his hand was removed.’ See ‘Experience and Views,’ p. 61. And all know that the 1843 chart ended the 70 weeks at the cross, and these figures should not be altered by her people.”
Eld. S. says, “We were aware that a portion of them, like Andrews, put the cross at A. D. 31.” But why didn’t he say, We were aware that every one of them puts the cross at A. D. 31; for in all their sermons and in all their writings, they uniformly put the cross at A. D. 31. There is not a hint in any of Mrs. W.’s writings that it occurred at any other date. The reader will notice Eld. S. was very careful in this article not to state where the 1843 chart placed the cross, but in a subsequent article he says it was A. D. 33. Therefore allowing his own construction of Mrs. W.’s words, he entirely fails to prove that Mrs. W. or any other Seventh-day Adventist writer places the cross at A. D. 34. He cannot fail to see this point. The construction he puts upon Mrs. W.’s vision is a perversion of facts. It does not teach what he claims or any such thing. It teaches that the great advent movement of 1843 was of God, that the 1843 chart had a purpose to serve in that movement, that there was a mistake in some of the figures, that God’s hand covered and hid that mistake that it could not be seen until the chart had served its purpose in the 1843 movement; then God’s hand would be removed, the mistake seen and corrected, and subsequent charts could, of course, be published with the mistakes corrected. It teaches that none of the figures should be altered until it had served its purpose. Mrs. W. makes this very plain. She says:—
“I saw the people of God, joyful in expectation, looking for their Lord. But God designed to prove them. His hand covered a mistake in the reckoning of the prophetic periods. Those who were looking for their Lord did not discover this mistake, and the most learned men who opposed the time also failed to see it. God designed that his people should meet with a disappointment. . . . I saw the wisdom of God in proving his people and giving them a searching test to discover those who would shrink and turn back in the hour of trial. Jesus and all the heavenly host looked with sympathy and love upon those who had, with sweet expectation, longed to see him whom their souls loved. Angels were hovering around them to sustain them in the hour of trial. . . . Those faithful and disappointed ones who could not understand why their Lord did not come, were not left in darkness. Again they were led to their Bibles to search the prophetic periods. The hand of the Lord was removed from the figures, and the mistake was explained. They saw that the prophetic periods reached to 1844, and that the same evidence which they had presented to show that the prophetic periods closed in 1843 proved that they would terminate in 1844. Light from the word of God shone upon their position, and they discovered a tarrying time—‘If the vision tarry, wait for it.’ In their love for Christ’s immediate coming they had overlooked the tarrying of the vision, which was calculated to manifest the true waiting ones. Again they had a point of time. . . . With clearness the believers explained their mistake, and gave their reason why they expected their Lord in 1844. Their opposers could bring no arguments against the powerful reasons offered.”—Early Writings, pp. 99–101.
This makes it plain, and agrees with Wm. Miller. In the Herald of Dec. 3, 1844, speaking of this event, Wm. Miller says:—
“Again it is to me almost a demonstration that God’s hand is seen in this thing.”
But in the Crisis of Feb. 18, speaking of Seventh-day Adventists, of their ending the 2300 days in the autumn of 1844, and the 70 weeks in A. D. 34, Eld. S. says: “Their re-arrangement gave their time, and not Miller’s.” But Eld. S. knows that Wm. Miller and the whole Advent body, 50,000 strong, did claim that they discovered a mistake in their calculations of the 1843 time, and preached that the prophetic periods would end in the autumn of 1844. Eld. Miller said, “If it should pass by, I should be more disappointed than I was in my first published time.” He could not have had a “first published time” without a second; and as respects prophecy, Wm. Miller and his associates were right in the time, but were mistaken in the event. After the time in the autumn of 1844 had passed, Eld. Miller, in the Advent Herald for Dec. 25, 1844, said:—
“I have had time for a few weeks past to review the whole subject; and with all the aid of Stewart, Chase, Weeks, Bush, and the whole school of modern writers, I cannot see why we are not right. And even by taking the whole together instead of disproving the position we have taken as it respects prophecy, they confirm me in my views.”
The crucifixion did take place in A. D. 31. The 70 weeks did end in A. D. 34. The 2300 days did terminate in the autumn of 1844, and all the wisdom of earth cannot disprove it. At the ending of these days the sanctuary was to be cleansed. The earth is not the sanctuary, as Eld. Miller supposed; the sanctuary is in heaven, where our High Priest ministers (Ps. 102: 19; Heb. 8: 1, 2); hence the disappointment. Again Eld. S. says:—
“But suppose we let a part of them, in spite of Mrs. White’s vision, alter the figures on the 1843 chart which ends the 70 weeks at the cross, and put the cross at A. D. 31; what have they gained by the transaction? It would be like jumping out of the frying-pan into the fire; for it turns out that the passover fell on Tuesday in A. D. 31 also, not only by my own computation but by the computations of the best astronomers in England and America.”—Crisis, Dec. 19, 1883.
Here he again declares that there is a division among the Seventh-day Adventists upon this point, notwithstanding he has every opportunity of knowing it is absolutely false. He also again declares that Mrs. White’s visions do not place the cross at A. D. 31, but at some other point not stated in this article; but A. D. 34 is indicated. But it does not appear to me that he believes one word of it to be true, for in a subsequent article he positively declares that they teach that the cross dated A. D. 31. The following is what he said:—
“In April, 1847, their prophetess wrote: ‘The Lord has shown me in vision that Jesus rose up and shut the door and entered the Holy of Holies at the 7th month, 1844.’ In the same vision she adds: ‘I believe the sanctuary to be cleansed at the end of the 2300 days is the New Jerusalem temple, of which Christ is a minister.’ She might just as well have said, The Lord has shown me that Christ was crucified in A. D. 31, on Tuesday; for this is involved.”—Crisis, Feb. 18, 1885.
After Eld. S. has turned and twisted in every way to make it appear that Mrs. W. teaches that Christ was not crucified in A. D. 31, he now turns right around and declares plainly that she teaches that Christ was crucified in A. D. 31. But he objects to placing the cross at A. D. 31 because, as he claims, according to his computation and the computations of the best astronomers in England and America, the passover happened that year on Tuesday, and Christ was crucified at a passover, and this would keep him in the grave five days if he arose on Sunday. But I have communications from some of the best astronomers in England and America concerning this point, and I aver that the passover did not happen on Tuesday. There is a diversity of opinions among them upon this point. Prof. Swift has been investigating this point for more than a year, and has sent me the opinions and some of the letters of those with whom he has communicated. In March I wrote and asked him if he believed that question could be settled by astronomy, and received the following reply dated at Warner Observatory, Rochester, N. Y., April 28, 1885:—
“Dear Sir: Your letter just received. I have also received an answer to the one I wrote to England, which I inclose. I don’t believe it is in the power of man to tell the exact day; if it was, there would be no question arising in regard to it. If I ever get more light on the subject, I will let you know. Yours truly, Louis Swift.”
Nearly all I have consulted say the passover happened in A. D. 31, on Maundy-Thursday. I have no confidence in Eld. Sheldon’s astronomical calculations; for it was by these means that he attempted with other arguments to prove that the 2300 days would end and Paradise be restored in 1875. See his book entitled “Adventism,” published in 1868, pp. 193, 206, 300. If his calculations were correct, the saints have been in Paradise nearly ten years.