AdventAI

SHALL IT BE OBSERVED?

By R. A. Underwood

From Review and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 28., July 14, 1885

I MEAN the solemn ordinance of feet-washing. In these last days the law of God is being rejected, and the means of the gospel given to help man to obey the law are lightly esteemed. The anxious inquiry of many is, not, “Lord, what wilt thou have me to do”? but, “Lord, what requirement wilt thou release me from.” “What excuse or argument can I frame that will justify me in the day of Judgment for not obeying the commands of God”? This seems to be the burden of many who profess to be the followers of Christ. Perhaps no requirement of the gospel has been more generally ignored by professed Christians than the one brought to view in the 13th chapter of John’s Gospel. The third angel’s message of Rev. 14:9–12 brings to view a class keeping not only the commandments of God but also the faith of Jesus. Every argument that the enemy of all truth could invent has been brought against every step that has been made to accept the truth of Christ, and “walk even as he walked.” We may reject the truth of the Bible on a given point without due consideration. I am aware that it is not the easiest task for men to lay aside long-cherished views and weigh evidence with unbiased judgment.

There is an effort made by some to release themselves from obeying the precept of Christ concerning the ordinance of feet-washing by an attempt to separate it from the Lord’s supper. The position is taken that the supper referred to in John 13 is the same as the one at Simon the leper’s house, mentioned in John 12; Matt. 26:1–16, etc. The act of washing the disciples’ feet, and what Christ said concerning it, all took place, say they, at least two days prior to the night of Christ’s betrayal, when he instituted the Lord’s supper. After taking the position that the feet-washing and the Lord’s supper were instituted at different times and under different circumstances, they claim that feet-washing is therefore not a church ordinance, and should never be associated with the Lord’s supper as an ordinance of the church. Should the position be sustained that this ordinance was instituted at a different time and under different circumstances than that of the Lord’s supper, I fail to see that it would follow that we are released in any sense from our obligation to keep it as appointed by Christ. If so, we could do away with the ordinance of baptism for the reason that it was not given to thep. 443 church on the night of Christ’s betrayal. It is asked, Where is feet-washing ever called a church ordinance? We could ask, Where is it said that baptism or the Lord’s supper are church ordinances? An ordinance of the church is that which Christ has ordained for the church to be kept as directed by the great Head of the church.

Let us examine more fully the arguments used to separate these two institutions of Christ’s own appointment.

1. It is claimed that when, at the supper at Simon’s house, Christ reproved Judas for his covetousness in desiring the costly ointment used by Mary on that occasion (Matt. 26:1–16; Mark 14:1–11; John 12), then Satan entered into Judas. We learn that from that meeting he went out and covenanted with the priests to deliver Christ into their hands for thirty pieces of silver. In John 13, after speaking of Christ’s washing the disciples’ feet, and the question, as they sat around the table, as to who should betray him, then Christ answered this question by giving Judas the sop or morsel. Then the record says, “After the sop Satan entered into him. Then said Jesus unto him, That thou doest do quickly.” Verse 27. From the statement that Satan entered into Judas at the house of Simon, and that from there he went to the priests and planned with them the work of betraying Christ; and because we read in John 13 that after the feet-washing Satan entered into Judas,—from these statements, I say, it is claimed that the supper, feet-washing, etc., of John 13 all refer to the supper at Simon’s house. To sustain the assumption, it must be proved, (1) that Satan was not in Judas prior to his receiving the sop referred to in John 13:27; and (2) that after Satan has once entered into a person he cannot enter the second time. In answering the first point, I would say, Christ said that one of the twelve was “a devil,” “believed not” (John 6:64, 70), “was a thief” (Chap. 12:6). “Ye are not all clean.” Chap. 13:11. All of the above expressions Christ used concerning Judas prior to giving him the sop. Proving that Satan was in Judas before he received the sop, and that he also entered him at that time, shows the fallacy of the second position. We might just as well claim that by entering a house once it would forever bar us from entering it again! Satan can enter our hearts as often as we open the door and let him in.

The Evangelists plainly locate at the Passover supper, which Christ ate with his disciples, the giving of the sop and the inquiry as to who would betray their Lord. Matt. 26:17–22. No one will say that the above does not refer to the evening on which Christ gave the Lord’s supper. The 23rd verse points out the one that should betray him, in answer to the question of each of the disciples, “Lord, is it?” (John 13:21–27 describes the same event. And then what followed? Satan inspired Judas with additional hellish courage to go out and commit the awful deed which he had planned two days before; and as he was about to leave the other disciples, Christ said, “What thou doest, do quickly.”

The disciples began to realize that one of their number would betray the Son of God. No wonder that surprise and indignation were expressed by the words or looks of the disciples at such a thought! Then Christ turned to the eleven saying, “All ye shall be offended because of me this night.” Peter thought that if all the rest should forsake their Lord he would remain true. How deceptive is the human heart! But Jesus turned to him and said, “This night, before the cock crow, thou shalt deny me thrice.” What night? Only one answer can be given. See Matt. 26:20–34; Mark 14:17–30; Luke 22:14–34. The Evangelists vary some in recording these facts, but all are substantially the same.

Now turn to John’s record of the same. After Judas had left that company to do the murderous deed, Jesus said, “Now is the Son of man glorified,” etc. John then introduces other points omitted by the other Evangelists, as he did in the fore part of this chapter, and then refers to Christ’s words to Peter, which forever settle the question concerning the night on which the feet-washing occurred. “I say unto thee the cock shall not crow till thou hast denied me thrice.” John 13:38.

2. Another argument is raised against the feet-washing being on the night of Christ’s betrayal, from the expression in John 13:1: “Now before the feast of the passover,” etc. In answering this we will notice another point drawn from the 28th verse of this chapter, as follows: Some of the disciples thought that because Judas had the bag Jesus had said to him, “Buy those things that we have need of against the feast.” From this it is claimed that the events of this chapter took place “before” the feast of the passover, for the reason that it would be but foolishness to think that Judas was going out to buy something “against” the feast when it was in the past, or being observed. Those who maintain that the events of the 13th chapter of John’s Gospel took place at the house of Simon two days before the Lord’s supper was instituted, think that here they have unanswerable arguments to sustain this position, and that thereby all is made smooth and harmonious. In doing this they involve themselves in other difficulties. John in his account notices several points omitted by Matthew, Mark, and Luke; but he locates the events of chapter 13 by two points in his narrative, which are settled by the other Evangelists as having occurred on the night of Christ’s betrayal. For (1) Matthew says that, in answer to the question, “Lord, is it?” (as given in chap. 26:11) or (as John 13:25 says) “Lord, who is it” that should betray him? Jesus answered, “He that dippeth his hand with me in the dish, the same shall betray me.” Chap. 26:23. But John’s record says, in answer to the same question, “He it is, to whom I shall give a sop, when I have dipped it. And when he had dipped the sop, he gave it to Judas.” And (2) after recording what Christ had said, “All ye shall be offended because of me this night,” and that Peter had affirmed that though all should forsake him he would not, Matthew says, “Jesus said unto him, ‘Verily I say unto thee, That this night before the cock crow, thou shalt deny me thrice.’” Chap. 26:34. But in John 13:38 we read, “Verily, verily, I say unto thee, The cock shall not crow till thou hast denied me thrice.” These are Christ’s words to Peter, the night of his betrayal, in answer to his confident words of fidelity to the Master.

These points locate beyond a doubt the events of John 13. To maintain that the disciples’ not understanding the meaning of Christ’s words is any proof in the case, is nonsense. Although Christ had repeatedly told them of his death, burial, and resurrection, yet they did not understand it at all.

The opinion that buying “against the feast” was a preposterous idea for the disciples to entertain at the supper with Christ in that upper room on the night of his betrayal, is worthy of our notice. Let us turn to the 18th chapter of John. After having interrupted the narrative to insert the 14th, 15th, 16th, and 17th chapters, he in chapter 18 continues the account of the betrayal, trial, etc. In the 28th verse we read: “Then led they Jesus from Caiaphas into the hall of judgment; and it was early; and they themselves went not into the judgment hall, lest they should be defiled; but that they might eat the Passover.” If the Jews would not go into the judgment hall after Christ had had his first trial before Caiaphas, lest they should be defiled, that they might eat the Passover, which was future from that point of time, we see that the reasoning (under the supposition that that feast was past) that it was absurd for the disciples to think that Judas had taken the bag to buy something “against” the feast, falls to the ground.

This 28th verse of John 18 is in perfect harmony with the truth, and will throw some light on the first verse of John 13, “Now before the feast of the Passover,” etc., which is claimed to be proof that all the events recorded in this chapter occurred two days before the Passover. Undoubtedly the Passover which Christ ate with his disciples on Thursday night, was before the regular hour for that feast. This was absolutely necessary; for Christ was the antitype of the paschal lamb. 1 Cor. 5:7. Thus we see that the hour when Jesus gave up the ghost on the cross was the time that the Jews were preparing for the “feast,” the Jewish Passover. It was this which caused the perplexity of the Jews when they desired to secure the condemnation of Christ before the Roman court; for should they go into the judgment hall to accomplish this, it would so defile them that they could not participate in their annual feast, so near at hand.

But what about the Passover which Christ ate? That was of a necessity “before the feast of the Jews.” John 19:31 says that this Sabbath was “an high day.” Thus the truth is made harmonious and clear. “What therefore God hath joined together, let not man put asunder.”

The ordinance of humiliation was doubtless given as a rebuke to the spirit of emulation arising in the hearts of the disciples. Luke 22:22–27. After correcting them by precept for their desire to be the greatest, Jesus said, “I am among you as he that serveth.” Verse 27. Matthew, Mark, and Luke fail to inform us how the Saviour sent home to them this truth he had just uttered by example; it is left for the beloved disciple to do this. Had the other Evangelists given all of the truth John’s Gospel would never have been written. It was not given to increase the size of the Bible, but to bring in points of truth that had not been mentioned by the other disciples, and to so connect them with the points the others had given, as to show their proper place.

By comparing John 13:1–17 with Luke 22:22–27, we learn how the disciples each sought to be accounted the greatest. Christ, knowing their thoughts, reproved them. Then with the exalted thought in his mind that he had come from God, and was about to go to God, and also with the knowledge “that the Father had given all things into his hands” (John 13:3); with such feelings and a knowledge of such power, Christ gave to the church an example of meekness, ever to be followed, in washing his disciples’ feet. After he had finished, he said, “Know ye what I have done to you? Ye call me Master and Lord; and ye say well; for so I am. If I, then, your Lord and Master, have washed your feet, ye also ought to wash one another’s feet. For I have given you an example, that ye should do as I have done to you. Verily, verily, I say unto you, The servant is not greater than his Lord; neither he that is sent greater than he that sent him.” And does he leave it here? No; he adds, “If ye know these things, happy [or blessed] are ye if ye do them.” Could language be used the meaning of which would be plainer? Yet many say, “There is no moral obligation resting upon the church to carry out these words.” Could the obligation to follow Christ’s example in this be made clearer?

Dear reader, have you ever placed yourself where you could receive this special blessing? “Why call me Lord, Lord, and do not the things which I say”? says Christ.

Was baptism instituted because of a physical need? Did Christ give the bread and wine to his disciples because they were hungry? Did he wash their feet for physical cleanliness? You say, No, No! Then for what purpose were all these acts performed? Baptism shows our faith in the death, burial, and resurrection of Christ; the bread and wine point to the bruised body and to the spilled blood of the Son of God; and the humble act of our divine Lord, exalted by heaven, yet humble enough to wash the feet of fallen, depraved, ignorant men, was to be ever a standing rebuke against the proud spirit which leads mortals to seek to be greatest. Have we a command for the Lord’s supper? We have a stronger one for feet-washing. Christ says (John 13:34), “A new commandment I give unto you, That ye love one another, as I have loved you.” The world had never seen such love as this! No king upon his throne had ever performed such an act! Peter was unwilling that his Lord should do such menial service for him, and said, “Thou shalt never wash my feet.” Jesus answered, “If I wash thee not, thou hast no part with me.” Then he desired that not only his feet should be washed, but also his hands and head. Christ well knew that he did not then understand the object of this service, and said: “What I do thou knowest not now; but thou shalt know hereafter”; that is, they did not then understand the purpose for which Christ was giving this example and precept; but they should know afterwards.

The Maker of the heavens and earth, the King of kings, our Redeemer and perfect Pattern, does not say to fallen man, Do this or that, until he has set us the example. He tells us what to do to form a righteous character. Then he shows us how to do it by giving us a perfect example. There is no exception to this rule. Baptism, the Lord’s supper, feet-washing, and obedience to the moral law in all its parts, are brought out in all their living colors by example as well as precept of the Man of sorrows.

If it were not necessary to be reminded of the agonies of Christ in the garden, and the scenes of Calvary, we would have no occasion to partake of the emblems that point to these scenes. If men’s hearts were different in this age of the world, if there were no proud spirit of emulation, no seeking to be the greatest, all loving one another as Christ loved us, with no danger of losing that love, then we would have no need of the ordinance of humiliation. But while men live in this dark world of sin, they must have something to call their minds from self to Christ. The Saviour knew that nothing would accomplish this so well as humble obedience to the ordinances he gave, pointing to his humiliation and death. Those who thus learn of the meek and humble Teacher realize the fullness of the blessings contained in his words: “If ye know these things, happy are ye if ye do them.” Who would not desire to bow before the Master, and bathe those feet that were nailed to the rugged cross? From his lips fall these gracious words: “Inasmuch as ye have done it unto one of the least of these my brethren, ye have done it unto me.” We can thus minister unto him by “walking in all the commandments and ordinances of the Lord blameless.” R. A. UNDERWOOD.