AdventAI

A SUNDAY LAMENTATION.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 43., November 3, 1885

The advocates of Sunday sacredness claim that for over eighteen hundred years the Church has been unanimous in observing the first day of the week as the Lord’s day, the Christian Sabbath.—It would certainly be supposed that long ere this every Sunday-keeper would have become perfectly satisfied why he observed the day, satisfied in regard to the nature of the time which he thus observed, and the manner in which it should be kept. But instead of this, the crying demand of the Sunday institution to-day is, a foundation on which it can rest with any degree of assurance of support, some clear view of its nature and obligations by which its advocates may be governed. This has long been apparent from the contradictory and self-devouring arguments to which its advocates have everywhere resorted. And the more the question is agitated, the more conspicuous does this weakness become; till now its own advocates feel obliged to deprecate openly the situation, and cry out lustily for some clear view of the subject and some uniform line of defense. A remarkable article of this kind appears in a late number of the New York Independent, written by Rev. Henry J. Van Dyke, Jr., of New York City. It is entitled, “Wanted—A Clear View,” and reads as follows:—

“We shall never get this question of Sunday observance rightly settled until we get a clear and consistent view of it. The trouble is not that Christian people have voluntarily and definitely abandoned or betrayed their principles; the trouble is that they have no principles distinctively formulated and firmly grasped. The trouble is not that the Church is indifferent or impotent to control the course of events; the trouble is that she is very much mixed on this question. She does not look it squarely in the face; she does not take hold of it intelligently and with a firm and earnest purpose; and, consequently, she does not act with unity and vigor. What we need is a clear view.

“And we need it at once. For, while we are waiting and talking melancholy sentiments about ‘the good old Sabbath of our fathers,’ and drifting vaguely in the dark, the question is settling itself in a very practical and a very unsatisfactory way. Without any serious philosophic or moral argument, without even an attempt to investigate candidly the teachings of the Scriptures, the amusement-mongers and the money-makers are taking possession of Sunday for themselves. The Sunday newspapers fly everywhere on the wings of the wind. The Sunday trains run all over the land. The Sunday whistles are blowing, the Sunday bands are blaring and squealing and scraping, the Sunday shops are open, the Sunday fisherman are casting their flies, the Sunday hunters are blazing away at the birds, the Sunday shows are crowded, and the notices of Sunday services at Coney Island display the names of popular divines to draw a larger patronage to the Sunday boats. Meanwhile the good Christian people are looking at each other somewhat blankly, and saying: ‘What do we think of it all, anyway? What is Sunday, a civil holiday or a divine institution, an ecclesiastical ordinance for Christians only, or a great humane provision for the wants of all men? How shall we agree to defend it? On what grounds and to what extent? Shall we go backward or forward? Shall we imitate our grandfathers or anticipate our grandchildren? And how far backward or how far forward are we willing to go? Has this question any real practical importance? Is there any way of deciding it? Are there any fixed principles involved, or any genuine statistics available?’”

“You see what we want first is a clear view on our points:—

“1. A clear view of the meaning of Sunday. Is it merely a ceremonial day, to be observed for its own sake, and in the strict keeping of which there is great merit? Or is it a day with a deep significance, and a high mission for the life of man; a day without which our spiritual life would shrivel and dry up, and blow away; a day the breaking of which carries its own punishment with it, and never fails to avenge itself upon its despisers? Is it a day which is to be observed solely by abstaining from certain employments and recreations, by denying ourselves in a sort of mild asceticism? Or is it a day which is to be observed by honestly and sincerely endeavoring to make some positive advance in the higher life, by enjoying to the full certain privileges? Which view shall we take? For, if we are clear, we cannot mix them.”

“2. A clear view of the authority of Sunday. Has it nothing more than custom and churchly tradition to enforce it upon us? or is it firmly fixed and definitely declared in the law of God? Are there only nine commandments in the decalogue? or is the fourth still binding? Did Christ do away with the necessity for a sacred rest day, or only with the Jewish Sabbath? Does the Lord’s day really rest upon the fourth commandment, and perpetuate its spirit? We must look clearly and candidly at these questions before we can advance a step in any direction.

“3. A clear view of the social and religious importance of Sunday. Is it altogether a matter of inheritance or of sentiment whether we shall follow the Puritan or the European model? Is it a question by itself, or does it involve other and larger interests? Has it any bearing upon national prosperity and social conditions and moral developments? Can we trace any connection between the secularization of Sunday and the decline of religion in France and Germany? Has the observance of Sunday as a day of rest and worship in England and Scotland done anything for the physical, intellectual, and moral welfare of the people? What will be the probable effect upon our churches and benevolent institutions, and the spiritual quality of our people at large, if Sunday becomes a day for money-or merry-making? Surely we do not wish to take a medicine without knowing whether it is likely to do us good or harm. We need to cast an eye toward the future, and look straight and square at the practical significance of the Sunday question.

“4. A clear view of the best way to protect and enforce the observance of Sunday. Is it to be done chiefly by the State, or by the Church; by law, or by example? By outward pains and penalties, or by the force of a general moral sentiment? How far has the State a right to go in saying what a man may not do on Sunday? And, above all, how far is it wise for the State to go? Can we summon any more potent force than has yet been invoked to preserve such a Sunday for the whole community as we honestly and clearly believe it ought to have? Is there any power to this end now latent in the Church, which has never been fully called out, and which is from day to day becoming more and more dormant, simply for want of a clear view of what is to be done and how to do it?

“These are some of the points that we must illuminate and elucidate, every Christian for himself, and then all together, as unitedly and as vigorously as we can, for the whole community. The simple fact is that we are groping and drifting aimlessly. We are allowing men whom we would not trust in business, or philosophy, or morals, to settle the Sunday question for us after their own fashion. We are to-day in a far more lax condition than England, and, in our great cities at least, rapidly going beyond Germany. We good folks, who dwell in our ceiled houses and go to church twice on Sunday, do not quite realize what is going on. Are we willing that the matter should take its own course, without any earnest effort on our part to understand it or to do anything about it? That is a coward’s part, and an imbecile’s as well. It is high time to awaken out of sleep, every one of us, and get a clear view of Sunday—what it is, what it will be, what it ought to be.”

We have given the foregoing article entire, assured that it will be of the utmost interest to every reader of the REVIEW. Every Sabbath-keeper understands his position. He has the desired “clear view” so far as regards his own views; for he stands on the Bible record, the testimony of which is not yea and nay, but explicit, consistent, and uniform throughout. And he also understands just the difficulty in which the Sunday question is involved. Having no support in the Bible, it rests wholly on the authority of men; and the arguments for it will therefore be as various as their authors. We apprehend, however, that some uniform position will soon be adopted. It cannot rest on the Bible; for there is nothing to be found there in its support. Hence it must rest on the authority, and be prompted by the policy, of the Church. On that issue let the struggle come.