IS THE CHURCH BUILT ON PETER?
IF SO, it would seem to be established upon a very slim and unstable foundation. We believe it rests upon a more solid and substantial basis than any human being, however good or great he may be. The Scriptures speak of a foundation in which Jesus Christ himself is the chief corner-stone. Eph. 2:20. And St. Paul says, in verses 19 and 20, that “the household of God,” the Church, is built upon this foundation. Nevertheless, a large part of Christendom believe that the Church is built upon Peter; and they quote as proof the words of Christ to Peter, as found in Matt. 16:18: “Thou art Peter; and upon this rock I will build my church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it.” It is claimed on this text that Peter is here set forth as the head of the Church, and that there must be an unbroken series of successors of St. Peter, who would stand all the way along as the head of the Church. This has been for ages the doctrine of the Catholic Church. They claim that St. Peter was the first bishop, or pope, of Rome (although it is susceptible of the clearest proof that St. Peter never visited Rome at all), and that they have in the popes of Rome that series of successors to St. Peter necessary to constitute a visible head of the Church, and to furnish a fulfillment of Matt. 16:18. Protestants, of course, do not agree with such an application of the scripture; yet a query often arises in regard to what Christ’s words really do mean, and how they are to be explained. One such query has just come to this Office, and hence we notice the passage. We do not take the view of Matt. 16:18 which is entertained by our Catholic friends; and we will give some reasons why we do not. A consideration of the context is almost always necessary to an understanding of any particular passage. Especially is this so in the case before us. The record of the incident of which this forms a part, commences with verse 13. When Jesus came into the coasts of Cæsarea Philippi, he raised the important question, “Whom do men say that I, the Son of man, am?” They replied by quoting the opinions of others concerning him. Then he said, “But whom say ye that I am?” Simon Peter answered, “Thou art the Christ, the Son of the living God.” “Jesus answered, and said unto him, Blessed art thou, Simon Bar-jona; for flesh and blood hath not revealed it unto thee, but my Father which is in heaven.” Consider now for a moment the great topic under consideration. It is the important announcement that Christ was the Son of the living God. For taking his stand so boldly upon this truth, Peter received the commendation, “Blessed art thou, Simon.” Then to show that it did not originate in Peter’s mind, he added that it was revealed to him only by his Father who was in heaven. Having said this, he adds a declaration containing a strong contrast, which, if Peter had understood it, would have been an impressive admonition to him. He says: “And I say also unto thee, That thou art Peter [Greek, petros], and upon this rock [Greek, petra], I will build my church.” It will be noticed that Christ here uses two different words, petros and petra, the first one of which he applies to Peter, and the second he uses to express that upon which he will build his Church; and there is an important difference of meaning between these two words which should not be overlooked. Petros, the word applied to Peter, signifies, according to Robinson, “a piece of rock, a stone.” Liddell and Scott, standard Greek lexicographers, define it, “a piece of a rock, a stone; and thus distinguished from petra.” Petra, on which the Church was to be built, is defined by Robinson to mean, “a rock, cliff, ledge; pr. a mass of live rock. In such, sepulchers were hewn. Matt. 27:60; Mark 15:46. On such also houses and villages were founded for security. Matt. 7:24, 25. Of this word Liddell and Scott say: “A rock, generally, whether peaked or ridged; when in or by the sea, a ledge or shelf of rock. There is no example in good authors of petra in the signification of petros, for a single stone.” It is thus seen that the word petros, which signifies only a fragment of a rock, a small piece, a movable stone, is well applied to Peter; for he was of an ardent, impulsive nature, which rendered him often unstable and movable in his course of action. For instance, he had here squarely announced the great truth that Christ was “the Son of the living God;” yet he was soon to deny with an oath that he knew anything about the man. He was the first to preach to the Gentiles (Acts 15:7, 14); yet he wavered in respect to the introduction of Jewish observances among them, for which he was openly reproved by Paul. Gal. 2:11. But Peter had here announced a great truth, fundamental to all Christian doctrine; namely, that Jesus was “the Christ, the Son of the living God;” and this—this truth, this confession of faith which Peter had made—was the petra, the great ledge, the immovable mass of living rock, on which his Church was to be founded. Thus Christ becomes the great corner-stone in the foundation on which the Church is built, as Paul declares to the Ephesians. Another reason to show that Peter is not the rock on which the Church is founded, may be drawn from the gender of the two words; thus, petros is masculine, but petra is feminine. So when Christ says, “Thou art Peter” (petros), he uses a masculine word which naturally applies to him; but when he says, “Upon this rock [petra] I will build my Church,” he uses a feminine word which cannot apply to Peter. What, then, was the rock upon which Christ would build his Church? It was the petra, the immovable rock, the great truth which Peter had so boldly announced; namely, “Thou art the Christ, the Son of the living God.” And what was Peter? He was the petros, the rolling stone, the unstable man. Christ did not say, Thou art petra, the solid, substantial, rock, and upon thee I will build my Church. No; but, thou, although thou hast announced this great truth, nevertheless art thyself petros, a movable, rolling stone; upon this petra, this great truth which you have announced, that I am Christ, the Son of the living God—upon this truth I will build my Church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it. The rock, therefore, upon which Christ would build, was not Peter himself, but the great truth which Peter had announced.