THE PERFECTION OF CHRIST'S SACRIFICE.
The salvation of perishing men hangs upon the sacrifice of Christ. This is the world's only hope. And if there is anything imperfect or incomplete about this, all is lost. On this point, then, faith calls for assurance of the clearest and most satisfactory kind. But certain views have grown up in the theological world which tend greatly to mystify and perplex the believer on this most important of all questions. 1. The doctrine of the trinity makes Christ inseparable from the Father, so that if there was the death of any divine being upon the cross, God died. 2. The doctrine of the immortality of the soul exempts some part of the human organism—what is called the essential part, the real being—from death; so that in the death of Christ, according to this view, only the human body died, the divine spirit passing unscathed into the other world. But in this case we have only a human sacrifice, which would certainly be wholly inadequate to meet the necessities of a lost world. Thus our friends find themselves in a dilemma, either horn of which is a very serious one. As a sample of the perplexity involved in these views, and the arguments which are considered best adapted to a solution of them, we quote the following article from the Worker and Expositor, a paper published by the Friends, in Chicago, Ill. The writer, W. G. Coffin, under date of “Lawrence, Kan., 8th mo. 13, ’85,” addresses the editor of the Worker, as follows:— “In the Worker of 8th mo. 6, 1885, under the head of, ‘A Serious Apology for Dissent,’ over the name of our venerable and worthy friend, David Hunt, whose opinions and interpretations of Scripture are usually very correct, and always entitled to most careful consideration, he criticises with great energy and force some venerable friend who objects to the phrase, ‘God died upon the cross,’ as unscriptural and incorrect; in point of fact stating that it was the human body of Christ that died. Now I desire to ask my venerable friend, Was it indeed the divine, spiritual body of Christ, ‘that was God with us that died?’ ‘God is a Spirit, and they that worship him must worship him in Spirit and in truth,’ etc. Was it that spiritual God that died on the cross? ‘And the Lord God formed man of the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul.’ Now the body was doubtless perfect in all its parts, flesh, bones, heart, blood, and all, but there was no life in it, until God breathed into it the breath of life; then, not before, man became a living soul. Now what is death? When the vital principle that God breathed into the nostrils of Adam, which is life, leaves the body, that is death, simply that, nothing more. Now does the breath of life breathed into the nostrils by God himself, which and which only makes him a living soul, die? Most assuredly not. If it does die with the body, where is immortality? ‘Then shall the dust return to the earth as it was; and the spirit . . . unto God who gave it.’ Can language be more pointed, direct, or conclusive? But it may be claimed that Christ was created different from all other human beings. Granted, and yet he was perfect God and perfect man, ‘in all points tempted like as we are,’ etc.; in him dwelt ‘all the fulness of the Godhead bodily.’ Then did all that die? Such an assumption shakes all common sense. But if more conclusive testimony is still demanded, let Christ himself testify, when in the death throes of dissolution on the cross, he calls out in the agony of despair, ‘My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?’ The reason clearly was, that for the redemption of the world, Christ must then die, and ‘all the fulness of the Godhead bodily that dwelt in him’ could not die, and must leave him, and did leave him, Christ himself being the witness.” Thus exception is taken to the phrase, “God died upon the cross;” and to prove that the exception is well taken and God did not die, appeal is made to the record of man’s creation, and the argument is rested on the “breath of life,” the “vital principle” which God breathed into man. Does this breath of life, asks Mr. C., die? And he answers, “Most assuredly not. If it does die with the body, where is immortality?” Ah, yes! with believers in man’s natural immortality, that is the question. That shows where the difficulty comes in. This doctrine that man is by nature immortal, must be maintained, and all else harmonized with that. But imagine that doctrine for a moment set aside; would not the subject be relieved at once of more than half its difficulty? Let us see. A question or two arises concerning this “breath of life” which God breathed into man, and which our friend is so sure does not die. What is it? Has it an organization of its own, independent of the man into whose body it was breathed? Can it of itself see, hear, and feel? Can it think? Can it act, and perform all the functions of an independent being, after leaving the body? If these questions are answered affirmatively with respect to man, then we ask the same with respect to all the lower orders of animals; for we read that they all have the “breath of life” equally with man. The record giving the results of the flood says: “And all flesh died that moveth upon the earth, both of fowl, and of cattle, and of beast, and of every creeping thing that creepeth upon the earth, and every man: all in whose nostrils was the breath of life, of all that was in the dry land died.” Gen. 7:21, 22. This record is as explicit as it can well be. Man is classed with all the animals and creeping things, and it is expressly affirmed of them all that they had the “breath of life.” And if we look at the marginal reading we find a still stronger expression—“the breath of the spirit of life,” or “lives,” as it might be rendered, the word being in the plural. In harmony with this Solomon declares of both man and all the lower animals that they all have one “breath” (Eccl. 3:19); and he means the “breath of life,” for he uses the same word, ruah, that is rendered “breath,” in Gen. 7:22, and the same word that is rendered “spirit” in Eccl. 12:7: “Then shall the dust return to the earth as it was, and the spirit [ruah] shall return unto God who gave it.” Now if this “breath of life” cannot die in the case of man, can it any more die in the case of the lower animals? In the language of our friend we can answer, “Assuredly not.” Then are all beasts immortal? Have they all deathless spirits? Are we to find in the spirit world the immortal souls of all bugs and beetles, cats, caterpillars, and creeping things, dogs and donkeys, ready there to challenge us, with them, to an unending existence? If the reasoning of649 our friends is correct, this is certainly to be so. Alas! to what conditions will men suffer their theology to lead them. But there is another question to be asked concerning this breath of life, which our friends are so sure is a conscious, intelligent being after it leaves the body; and that is, Was it a conscious, intelligent being before it was breathed into the body? If it was, then we must shoulder, however onerous the load may be, the old heathen doctrine of the pre-existence and transmigration of souls. But few will be willing to do that. But if it was not a conscious, intelligent entity before it was breathed into man’s body, it is not such after it leaves the body, for it goes back to its source in the same condition in which it was imparted to man. This is embraced in the declaration, “The spirit shall return unto God who gave it.” After it has returned to him, it is of course in the same condition it was before he gave it. If it is insisted that the breath of life was not a conscious being before entering the body, but is such on leaving it, we ask how it is that its connection with the body works this change in it; what brings it about? how is it accomplished? And further, how is it that this once non-existent but now immortal part sleeps when the body sleeps, is well when the body is well, sick when the body is sick, crazy when the body is crazy—follows it and takes on its every condition down to death’s door, yet just as soon as the body dies refuses to follow it further, but presto! becomes at once an angel? Thus the popular view is hedged about on every side with perplexities, which to our view assume very much the form of absurdities. If any one should ask how the breath of life could return to God, we would answer by asking how it could come from him; for in the same sense, and to the same degree in which it could be said to come from him, or be given by him, it could also go back to him or he could take it. Job seemed to take a view of the matter in harmony with this idea. He says: “Yea, surely, God will not do wickedly, neither will the Almighty pervert judgment. If he set his heart upon man, if he gather unto himself his spirit and his breath, all flesh shall perish together, and man shall turn again unto dust.” Job 34:12, 14, 15. Here we have both spirit and breath mentioned, and God calls them both his; that is, if God should withdraw his Spirit from the earth, and gather to himself the breath which he has imparted to all breathing animals, all flesh would perish together and man go back to dust. In this sense the breath may be said to go to God. To return from this digression concerning the nature of man, we come again to the question, Did Christ die? If he did, we have a divine sacrifice, and a good ground of hope. If he did not, if what is called the spirit, the real man, survived the cross, and only the human part, the body, died, then we have only a human sacrifice, which can never save us. But who can doubt, in view of the testimony of the Scriptures, in whatever way he may suppose Christ to have been constituted—who can doubt that he, in his entirety, died? If it is said that his soul escaped death, Isaiah replies that “he poured out his soul unto death” (Isa. 53:12); and our Lord himself said, “My soul is exceeding sorrowful even unto death” (Matt. 26:38); and Peter on the day of Pentecost interprets the psalm, “Thou wilt not leave my soul in hell,” as applying to Christ. Speaking of the prophet David, he thus says: “Therefore being a prophet, and knowing that God . . . would raise up Christ to sit on his throne; he seeing this before spake of the resurrection of Christ, that his soul was not left in hell [hades, the grave], neither his flesh did see corruption.” Then Christ’s soul tasted death for every man, and went into the grave, but did not remain there simply because he had a resurrection therefrom. Hear Paul also speak on this subject: “Let this mind be in you which was also in Christ Jesus: who being in the form of God, thought it not robbery to be equal with God, but made himself of no reputation, and took upon him the form of a servant, and was made in the likeness of men, and being found in fashion as a man, he humbled himself, and became obedient unto death, even the death of the cross.” Phil. 2:5–8. To whom do all these pronouns refer? to Christ himself or only to his human body? Did he humble himself from an exalted position of equality with his Father, and die on the cross? or did he only humble and put to death on the cross a human body which never had been exalted anywhere? Let us believe the Scriptures that Christ himself died, and that we have a complete and efficient sacrifice on which to build our hope of everlasting life. And what objection is there to this? The representations of the Scriptures all seem straightforward and simple enough. To be sure the mystery and the miracle of the incarnation—the descent from the ineffable heights of divine glory to the marred visage and the mortal nature of the lowliest of men—can never be comprehended by finite minds. But the Scriptures assure us that so it was; and faith precludes all objections. We are told that “the Word was made flesh and dwelt among us.” We waste no time in splitting hairs over the union of the divine nature and the human nature, the independence of the two, and the functions and provinces of each—this to the human and that to the divine—“the Word was made flesh;” and though subjected for a time to the humiliation and the limitations of the human sphere, he was all divine, because he was the only begotten Son of God. And in man’s nature he died—died as man dies, not merely dropping a clog and impediment and soaring to a higher life in the spirit world, but passing wholly from the plane of life into the embrace of death; the cry on the cross, “My God! my God! why hast thou forsaken me?” not being merely the cry of the body to the soul as it was leaving it, nor the cry of the human part to the divine part as it was taking its departure, but the cry of the Son himself to his Father, as that Father for a time hid his face, as if he were indeed guilty of the sins of the world. And God still stood at the helm of the universe, while his divine Son lay in the tomb. Then he raised him from the dead, and exalted him to his own right hand, to the glory he had with him before the world was. Thus was the life-rope attached to this wandering world, which, thanks to our gracious Redeemer’s ever-blessed name! all may lay hold upon who will, and thus be rescued from death, and brought home at last to share in his glory. But “what then becomes of immortality?” Sure enough. We are content to leave it where the Scriptures leave it. Christ brought it to light in the gospel. It is hid with Christ in God. Col. 3:3. “God hath given unto us eternal life, and this life is [not in us, but] in his Son. 1 John 5:11. And “when Christ who is our life shall appear, then shall” we “also appear with him in glory.” Col. 3:4.