AdventAI

A SPECIMEN.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 41., October 20, 1885

We have often wondered what the matter is with the opponents of God’s law. Is it a judicial infliction upon them on account of their hostility to God’s great standard of righteousness, that when they attempt to argue against it, their logic seems to be smitten with insanity? The psalmist says, “A good understanding have all they that do his commandments,” from which a very plain inference may be drawn concerning those who do not keep them. We submit the following from the Restitution as a specimen argument against the Sabbath which it would be difficult to parallel on any other subject, among any class claiming to have ordinary use of their mental powers.

“Admitting the Sabbatarians’ unproved inference to be correct—which we do not—that God enjoined the observance of the seventh day upon Adam and Eve in Eden before they transgressed the law concerning the tree of knowledge of good and evil, will these same Sabbatarians please specifically point out of what avail Sabbath-keeping would be to them and their posterity in their fallen condition as guilty sinners condemned to death? We would like to have it explained as to just what extent laws made to govern the relation of sinless beings in paradise to their Creator would benefit rebellious transgressors after being sentenced to death for their crime and then expelled from God’s presence in the blissful garden, even if observed. Would the observances ordained for the holy angels in their heavenly condition avail anything for those fallen angels who kept not their first estate even if observed by these lapsed beings? Telling us something about God’s subsequent arrangements with lost man, will be no answer to our question about the perpetuity of an Edenic law. There is another question back of this, which is, If a Sabbath law was given to Adam and Eve in paradise, what was its penalty? A law without a penalty is a nullity. If death was the penalty, then there were at least two positive institutions enjoined upon sinless beings, for the non-observance of which they would be inevitably doomed to capital punishment. The Bible teaching is clear and precise that there was only one positive institution enjoined upon man in paradise to which death was affixed as the penalty for disobedience.”

As to the claim that we have only an inference that God enjoined the keeping of his Sabbath upon man in Eden, it is wholly incorrect. There is no inference about it. It is just as plain a record as any other statement of the Scriptures. God sanctified the seventh day. Such is the record; and as the word “sanctify” means “to set apart to a holy or religious use,” which could be done only by giving a commandment how it should be used, the whole ground is covered by that positive statement, and there is no occasion for any inference whatever.

But the wonderful part of the argument is the question what good it would do them to keep the Sabbath after they had fallen, and a reference to the case of the Devil and his angels to clinch this marvelous logic. Well, if man is as bad off as the Devil and his angels, hopelessly doomed to death beyond the reach of any plan of salvation, perhaps there would be no use in attempting to obey God; but we had always supposed that through the plan of redemption man was given opportunity to return to God, and by obedience through Christ regain what by disobedience he had lost. “If thou wilt enter into life,” says Christ, “keep the commandments.” And again he declares, “Blessed are they that do his commandments, that they may have right to the tree of life, and may enter in through the gates into the city.” What Christ does for us is to cancel the guilt of all our past transgressions, and, in place of the carnal mind which is not subject to the law of God, and cannot be, to give us the new nature which will lead us to love and keep his requirements.

But if there was a Sabbath law in Eden, what was its penalty? If our friends have any difficult questions to raise, why don’t they propose them? This one answers itself. If there was a law, the transgression of that law would have been sin; and Paul lays down the universal rule when he says that the wages of sin is death. The penalty was the same as would have been visited upon Adam if he had set up other gods before Jehovah in Eden, or bowed down to images, or profaned God’s name, or killed his wife. The command respecting the tree was simply a test of his loyalty, the penalty named being such as would follow disobedience in any other respect.

A parallel case is found in Exodus 16. There God took his Sabbath as a test for the people, and gave special directions concerning that, to prove them, not simply whether they would keep the Sabbath or not, but whether they would walk in his law or not. But did not God then have other laws for the people besides the Sabbath? Most assuredly. Yet he specified the Sabbath only, as that would test them whether they had in their hearts the principle of obedience or not. Further comment would be superfluous.