AdventAI

A DISPUTE

By Isaac Morrison

From Review and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 44., November 10, 1885

BETWEEN THE BIBLE AND THE HYMN BOOKS ON THE DOCTRINE OF THE IMMORTALITY OF THE SOUL.

BY ISAAC MORRISON.

Bible.—“Thou shalt surely die.” Gen. 2 : 17.

Doctrine.—“Ye shall not surely die;” for God has made your real being immortal, therefore you cannot die.

“It is not death to fling Aside this sinful dust, And rise on strong, exulting wing To live among the just.” —M. E. Hymnal, hymn No. 993.

B.—“And now, lest he put forth his hand, and take also of the tree of life, and eat, and live forever; therefore the Lord God sent him forth from the garden of Eden, to till the ground from whence he was taken.” Gen. 3 : 22, 23.

D.—The Lord could not keep him from living forever; for he had created him immortal, so that he could not die: besides, why should he want to keep him from living forever; for if he was good, God wanted him to live eternally in heaven as soon as the real man left his earthly body at death; and if he was wicked, he wanted to torment him eternally in hell.

“Grant us the power of quickening grace, To fit our souls to fly; Then when we drop this dying flesh, We’ll rise above the sky.” —M. E. Hymnal, No. 972.

“The breath of God, his angry breath, Supplies and fans the fire; Then sinners taste the second death, And would but can’t expire.” —Social Harp (Presbyterian).

B.—“As the soul of the father, so also the soul of the son is mine: the soul that sinneth, it shall die.” Eze. 18 : 4.

D.—The soul that sinneth can never die, but must live eternally in torment.

“A charge to keep I have, A God to glorify; A never-dying soul to save, And fit it for the sky.” —Methodist Hymns, No. 570.

B.—“Fear him which is able to destroy both soul and body in hell.” Matt. 10 : 28.

D.—There is no one able to destroy the soul; for it is immortal and indestructible, and is to exist in heaven or hell to all eternity.

“But, oh! when both shall end, Where shall I find my destined place? I shall my everlasting days With friends or angels spend.” —Methodist Hymns, No. 1072.

B.—“The wages of sin is death.” Rom. 6 : 23.

D.—The wages of sin is eternal life in hell fire.

“What after death for me remains? Celestial joys or hellish pains To all eternity.” —Methodist Hymns, No. 1072.

B.—“For yet a little while, and the wicked shall not be: yea, thou shalt diligently consider his place, and it shall not be.” Ps. 37 : 10.

D.—This is not true; for both the wicked and their place of torment shall always exist, as our Christian poet says:—

“Infinite years in torment shall I spend, And never, never have an end. Ah! must I live in torturing despair As many years as atoms in the air; When these are past, as many millions more As grains of sand that bound the ebbing shore; When these run out, as many more behind As leaves of forests shaken by the wind; When these are spent, as many more to flow As blades of grass on hills and dales that grow; When these run out, as many on the march As starry lamps that gild the spangled arch; When these are gone, as many millions more As every moment in the age before; When all these doleful years are spent in pain, And multiplied by myriads yet again, I must in that fierce gulf in misery lie And madly writhe to all eternity.”

B.—“For, behold the day cometh, that shall burn as an oven; and all the proud, yea, and all that do wickedly, shall be stubble; and the day that cometh shall burn them up, saith the Lord of hosts, that it shall leave them neither root nor branch.” “And ye shall tread down the wicked; for they shall be ashes under the soles of your feet.” Mal. 4 : 1, 3.

D.—No, it will not do that, it will burn them eternally, but they can never become ashes.

“What! to be banished from my Lord And yet forbid to die; To linger in eternal pain, And death forever fly?” —Methodist Hymns, No. 1114.

B.—“His fan is in his hand, and he will thoroughly purge his floor, and gather his wheat into his garner; but he will burn up the chaff with unquenchable fire.” Matt. 3 : 12.

D.—He may purge the floor, and gather the wheat (the righteous), but he will never burn up the chaff (the wicked), but will let them live eternally in the lake of fire.

“Hail! ye ghosts that dwell in darkness, Groaning, rattling of your chains! Christ has now pronounced my sentence, I’m to dwell in endless pains; Down I’m rolling, Never to return again.” —Camp-meeting Chorister, No. 157.

B.—“For while they be folded together as thorns, and while they are drunken as drunkards, they shall be devoured as stubble fully dry.” Nah. 1 : 10.

D.—They shall never be devoured as stubble fully dry, but shall learn to live forever in the fire, like the fabled salamander.

“Sinner, hell is deep and yawning; Quenchless fires are raging there; Not a ray of hope is dawning On those regions of despair.” —Social Harp (Presbyterian).

B.—“They shall be as though they had not been.” Obad. 16.

D.—They shall be as though they always had been; in fact, like a boulder increasing its speed, rolling down a bottomless hill, their sins will keep on increasing, and their torments in the lake of fire will increase correspondingly to all eternity.

“Sinner, canst thou forever dwell Amid the fiery deeps of hell? Has death no warning sound for thee? Oh! turn, and to the Saviour flee.”

B.—“The Lord knoweth how to deliver the godly out of temptation, and to reserve the unjust unto the day of Judgment to be punished.” 2 Pet. 2 : 9.

D.—That cannot be; for the wicked dead are already being punished in hell fire. At the Judgment they will be brought up and judged, to see whether they were worthy of being rewarded in heaven or punished in hell.

“Where are the dead?—In heaven or hell Their disembodied spirits dwell.” —Methodist Hymns, No. 336.

“Your way is dark, and leads to hell, Why will you persevere? Can you in endless torments dwell, Shut up in black despair?” —M. E. Hymnal, No. 371.

B.—“His breath goeth forth; he returneth to his earth, in that very day his thoughts perish.” Ps. 146 : 4.

D.—His body perishes, but his thoughts do not; he thinks more than he ever did, as he now has no brains to hinder him.

“Nor will I cease Thy praise to sing When death shall close mine eyes; My thoughts shall then to nobler heights And sweeter raptures rise.” —M. E. Hymnal, No. 705.p. 692

B.—“The living know that they shall die; but the dead know not anything.” Eccl. 9 : 5.

D.—The dead know more than all of the living.

“Come, let us join our friends above, That have obtained the prize; And on the eagle wings of love, To joys celestial rise.” —Methodist Hymns, No. 572.

B.—“Also their love, and their hatred, and their envy, is now perished.” Eccl. 9 : 6.

D.—No, it is just the time when the righteous are able to love in reality, when they meet God and their loved ones in heaven; and it is the very time when the wicked in hell envy the righteous, and hate God in good earnest.

“I’ll love Thee in life, I’ll love Thee in death, And praise Thee as long as Thou lendest me breath; And say, when the death-dew lies cold on my brow, If ever I loved Thee, my Jesus, ’tis now.”

“Chains of darkness, shrieks and groanings, Blasphemies and madness dwell ’Mid these everlasting burnings; This, O sinner, this is hell.” —Social Harp (Presbyterian).

B.—“The dead praise not the Lord.” Ps. 115 : 17.

D.—A part of them praise him in heaven, and the rest curse him in hell.

“And in a nobler, sweeter song I’ll sing thy power to save, When this poor lisping, stammering tongue Lies silent in the grave.” —Gospel Hymns, No. 91.

“Stop, poor sinner! stop and think Before you farther go! Will you sport upon the brink Of everlasting woe?” —The Revivalist (Methodist), No. 291.

B.—“There is no work, nor device, nor knowledge, nor wisdom, in the grave, whither thou goest.” Eccl. 9 : 10.

D.—We shall not go into the grave; for as quick as we die we shall be taken to heaven, where there is all knowledge and wisdom.

“Angels, joyful to attend, Hovering round thy pillow bend; Wait to catch the signal given, And convey thee quick to heaven.” —Methodist Hymns, No. 674.

B.—“Man dieth, and wasteth away.” “His sons come to honor, and he knoweth it not; and they are brought low, but he perceiveth it not of them.” Job 14 : 10, 21.

D.—That cannot be; for our departed friends have not died, but have gone before, and see and know all that we do, and return to watch over and cheer us.

“Friends fondly cherished have passed on before; Waiting, they watch me approaching the shore; Singing to cheer me through death’s chilling gloom; Joyfully, joyfully haste to thy home.” —The Revivalist, No. 132.

“It is a beautiful belief That ever round our head Are hovering on viewless wings, The spirits of the dead.” —Mrs. Harriet Beecher Stowe.

B.—“Then said Jesus unto them [the Jews], Yet a little while am I with you, and then I go unto him that sent me. Ye shall seek me, and shall not find me; and where I am, thither ye cannot come.” John 7 : 33, 34. “Little children, yet a little while I am with you. Ye shall seek me; and as I said unto the Jews, Whither I go, ye cannot come; so now I say to you.” John 13 : 33.

B.—Oh, yes! they could go where the Saviour was going, the same as people do now; for he was going to heaven, and hundreds had died and gone there already. If any one could go to heaven, certainly those holy disciples whom the Saviour chose, went there when they died.

“Happy are the saints above, Who once went sorrowing here; But now they taste unmingled love, And joy without a tear.” —M. E. Hymnal, No. 666.

“They have braved cold Jordan’s billows, And have passed through death’s alarms; They are freed from every sorrow In the Saviour’s loving arms.” —Winsome Hymns, p. 106.

B.—“I go to prepare a place for you. And if I go and prepare a place for you, I will come again, and receive you unto myself; that where I am, there ye may be also.” John 14 : 2, 3.

D.—We shall not have to wait for the Saviour to prepare a place for us, nor until he comes again; for we shall go to heaven at death.

“Then persevere till death Shall bring thee to thy God; He’ll take thee at thy parting breath To his divine abode.” —George Heath, in Gospel Hymns.

B.—“The Son of man shall come in the glory of his Father with his angels; and then he shall reward every man according to his works.” Matt. 16 : 27.

D.—Not so; the reward is given when we die, long before the Son of man will come.

“In condescending love, Thy ceaseless prayer he heard; And bade thee suddenly remove To thy complete reward.” —Methodist Hymns, No. 1086.

B.—“When the chief Shepherd shall appear, ye shall receive a crown of glory that fadeth not away.” 1 Pet. 5 : 4.

D.—That is not the time when the crown is given; it is when we die and go to heaven.

“The consecrated cross I’ll bear Till death shall set me free; And then go home a crown to wear, For there’s a crown for me.” —M. E. Hymnal, No. 666.

B.—“Henceforth there is laid up for me a crown of righteousness, which the Lord, the righteous Judge, shall give me at that day; and not to me only, but unto all them also that love his appearing.” 2 Tim. 4 : 8.

D.—We need not care about the appearing of the Lord if we are only prepared to die and go immediately to heaven. Paul ought to have known better than to infer that the crown would be given only to those that love the appearing of Christ, and to say that only “unto them that look for him shall he appear the second time without sin unto salvation” (Heb. 9 : 28), when he knew that he and all the good people that die would, through death, go to heaven, where the Saviour is, and receive a crown, without loving, looking, and waiting for the Saviour to come; and he knew that we could not know when to look for our Lord’s coming, as he might come to-night or not for a thousand years. True, there are some texts that give signs of his coming (Matt. 24 : 3–30), and say that when all have come to pass, the Saviour’s coming is near, even at the door (Matt. 24 : 32, 33); but what those texts teach is “Advent” doctrine, and we cannot believe that. Besides, if we should believe what those texts say,—that like the warnings given to Sodom and Gomorrah, to Nineveh, and to the people that were living when the flood came, so a warning of this most terrible, momentous, and impending event should now be given to the world (Joel 2 : 1),—it would not do to preach it; for our bishops, brother ministers, and church members would not bear it, and we should lose their favor, and be turned out of the good old church (John 9 : 21, 22, 34), in which all of our pious grandfathers and grandmothers lived and died and went to heaven long ago; and there is no danger but that we shall be all right if we live and die in the good old way and belief in which our grandfathers lived. John 9 : 28, 29. Then—

“Awhile in flesh disjoined, Our friends that went before We soon in Paradise shall find, And meet to part no more. In yonder happy seat Waiting for us they are, And thou shalt there a husband meet, And I a parent there.” —Methodist Hymns, No. 954.

B.—“For the Lord himself shall descend from heaven with a shout, with the voice of the archangel, and with the trump of God; and the dead in Christ shall rise first: then we which are alive and remain, shall be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air; and so [in that way] shall we ever be with the Lord. Wherefore comfort one another with these words.” 1 Thess. 4 : 16–18.

D.—We shall not all go at once; for how could we be caught up together when some are already there, and some are dying every moment, and going there? Poor comfort to think of lying in the grave hundreds of years, until the Lord comes!

“One army of the living God, To his command we bow; Part of his host have crossed the flood, And part are crossing now. “Ten thousand to their endless homes, This solemn moment fly; And we are to the margin come, And we expect to die.” —Methodist Hymns, No. 956.

B.—“Thou shalt be recompensed at the resurrection of the just.” Luke 14 : 14.

D.—We shall not have to wait until the resurrection to be recompensed, but will be recompensed when we go to heaven—at death; for what greater recompense could be given than to be freed from the pains and sorrows of earth, and taken into the joys of the angels of heaven?

“I love to think of the heavenly land, Where the white-robed angels are, Where many a friend is gathered safe From fear and toil and care.”

“Sing on, O ye ransomed, now safe on the shore; Sing on, you have anchored, your trials are o’er: We’ll follow your footsteps, we long to behold The river of life and the city of gold.” —Pure Gold.

B.—“Marvel not at this; for the hour is coming, in the which all that are in their graves shall hear his voice.” John 5 : 28.

D.—There are none in the graves to hear his voice: all are gone to their everlasting reward beyond the bounds of time and space.

“Oh! think of the friends over there, Who before us the journey have trod; Of the songs that they breathe on the air, In their home in the palace of God.” —Rev. D. W. C. Huntington, in Gospel Hymns.

B.—“But they that shall be accounted worthy to obtain that world, and the resurrection from the dead.” Luke 20 : 35.

D.—The real man is not dead, and therefore he cannot have a resurrection, nor is there any use for one; at the separation of the real man from the body, he goes right to heaven in the full possession of all his faculties. What is the use of thrusting him back into that old clog?

“How is our brother bereft Of all that could burden his mind! How easy the soul that has left— This wearisome body behind!” —Methodist Hymns, No. 1087.

(Concluded next week.)