BY ELD. O. A. JOHNSON.
Although several articles have appeared in the Review showing that the Sabbath command still exists after the stoning penalty has passed away, there is an additional thought to which I wish to call the attention of its readers; viz., the stoning of the Sabbath-breaker is no part of the original Sabbath law or command, but was given long after the institution of the Sabbath, and long after the Sabbath command was given; and if this be true, the stoning penalty might pass away and leave the Sabbath law as it was before this penalty was added. In support of this I offer the following:—
1. The Sabbath was instituted at creation. Gen. 2:1-3. Yet nothing is said here about stoning any who might violate it.
2. Some object, and say that the Sabbath command was not given at creation, but that such a law was given to Israel when they came out of Egypt into the wilderness of Sin, about one month before the law was given on Mt. Sinai. While the transactions in the wilderness of Sin rather prove the previous institution of the Sabbath and its law, yet it proves positively that the Sabbath command existed there; for thus we read: “That I may prove them, whether they will walk in my law, or no.” “This is that which the Lord hath said, To-morrow is the rest of the holy Sabbath unto the Lord.” Ex. 16:4, 23. Here we see that God has a law, and that the Sabbath command is a part of it; but as yet we learn nothing about the stoning penalty. Although the Lord had positively forbidden any to go out to gather manna on the seventh day, and although he withheld the manna so that none fell on that day, yet “there went out some of the people on the seventh day for to gather, and they found none;” whereupon the Lord said: “How long refuse ye to keep my commandments and my laws.” Ex. 16:27, 28. Here we have the Sabbath law, and people are required to keep it. Yet nothing is said about stoning those who might profane the Sabbath. Some here break the Sabbath and are not stoned for it. Hence we see that God can have a law requiring man to keep the seventh day Sabbath without the stoning penalty.
3. About a month after this, Israel came to Mt. Sinai, where God spoke the ten commandments with his own voice. See Ex. 20:3-17; Deut. 4:12, 13. None will dispute the fact that here is a positive command to keep the Sabbath. See Ex. 20:8-11. But mark, nothing is said about stoning any who should break it. This is a fact that none can dispute. Therefore it must be a fact that the stoning of the Sabbath-breaker is no part of the original Sabbath law, and hence we see that the Sabbath law can exist without the stoning penalty.
4. About a year after Israel left Egypt, a man was found breaking the Sabbath by gathering sticks on that day. This man was “put in ward, because it was not declared what should be done to him.” Observe that as yet they had not learned what to do with those who willfully profaned God’s holy day. The command to keep it existed, but they had not yet learned what to do to such as trampled God’s Sabbath under their feet. It was at this time that God commanded that the Sabbath-breaker should be stoned, which was accordingly done. See Num. 15:32-36. Thus we see that the stoning penalty was not a part of the original Sabbath law; and if the command to keep God’s holy day could exist long before such a penalty was added, it could also exist after the penalty had passed away. The passing away of the penalty would not affect the Sabbath command; for the penalty was no part of the Sabbath law.
The command forbidding adultery existed from creation, and was spoken and written by God on Mt. Sinai. But it was not till a long time afterward that the death penalty was pronounced upon the adulterer. See Lev. 20:10. The passing away of this penalty does not repeal the law against adultery. This will be clearly seen from John 8:3-11. But while Christ set aside this death penalty, he did not say that the accused was at liberty to break the command forbidding adultery; for he said, “Go and sin no more;” that is, go and transgress this command no more. Hence the stoning of the adulterer was to pass away, while the command forbidding adultery should remain in full force.
So with the Sabbath and its penalty: the Sabbath was instituted at creation, was spoken and written by God; but it was not till a long time afterward that God directed the presumptuous Sabbath-profane to be stoned. That penalty has passed away, and of course leaves this command as it was before the penalty was added.
This same principle holds good in regard to the prohibition of building fires on the Sabbath. See Ex. 35:3. This prohibition is no part of the original command, but was given by God long after the Sabbath command was given. This prohibition relating to the building of fires might pass away and still leave the original Sabbath command unchanged.
The heart that truly loves God will not seek to invent excuses for disobeying his commands, but will cheerfully say, Lord, thy will, not mine be done. “This is the love of God, that we keep his commandments: and his commandments are not grievous.”