A DESPERATE ATTEMPT AND WHAT CAME OF IT.
Has it ever yet been determined how fast and how far a lie will travel, and how tenacious it is of life? Some idea of this may be gained from the old scandal that Adventists in 1844 arrayed themselves in long robes of white, and perambulated into adjacent graveyards, or climbed to housetops or hilltops, and there waited in their unique apparel to ascend to meet the Lord. From the center to the utmost verge of Christendom, ministers are to be found with this story at their tongue’s end, ready to hurl it (the best weapon they have) at the first appearance of Adventism in their vicinity.
It is of no particular consequence to us, to be sure, whether this story be true or false; for suppose some were foolish enough in 1844 to put on ascension robes to meet the Lord, what has that to do with the preaching or practice of Seventh-day Adventists, a separate and distinct class of people, forty-one years afterward? To affect our work at all they should show that Seventh-day Adventists have at some time and in some place, put on ascension robes. But this would be impossible, for S. D. Adventists have never believed in any fixed time for the Lord to come; and no one would ever think of putting on a robe to meet the Lord unless he had in his mind some particular day or hour when he expected him to appear.
Why then do we interest ourselves in this question? Simply because such a method of attack is so ignoble, and the fraud they make use of is so barefaced, that it adds not a little satisfaction to evident duty to expose the nature of the work in which they are engaged.
We make these remarks by way of introduction to a notable and interesting case that has recently come up under this head, as set forth in the following narrative.
In July last, Eld. H. A. St. John commenced meetings in Santa Barbara, California. The Methodist minister of the place opposed him, and brought up the usual ascension robe story, expatiating upon it, and emphasizing it to the evident prejudice of his hearers against the doctrine of the soon coming of Christ. Eld. St. John denied the story, and stated that a reward had for years been offered in the East for the well-authenticated testimony of an eye-witness to the fact that any one had ever put on an ascension robe to go up to meet the Lord. Whereupon the minister produced two witnesses who testified as follows:—
STATE OF CALIFORNIA, SANTA BARBARA COUNTY, JULY 29, 1885.
I, Capt. W. H. Johnson, a resident of Santa Barbara, Santa Barbara Co., California, hereby state that I was an eye-witness to the scenes of Millerite Adventists, with their robes on, prepared for the purpose of ascension to heaven. They publicly professed this as a result of Miller’s teaching, and it was a matter of public notoriety. They went out on the green near a Presbyterian church. I remember the name of one was Sayer. He had been a member of the M. E. church, but was a proselyte to Millerism, and was afterward expelled for non-attendance, because I preferred charges against him. There were about ten or fourteen persons, who were from different churches. This occurred at Bristol, Rhode Island, in or about the fall of 1843 or 1844. It was about dark in the evening.
W. H. JOHNSON.
Signed in presence of— E. W. PYLE, H. A. St. JOHN.
STATE OF CALIFORNIA, SANTA BARBARA COUNTY, JULY 29, 1885.
I, Thomas Cowell, in 1843, A. D., in the city of Providencep. 633 Rhode Island, did see with my own eyes, Adventists, followers of Wm. Miller, arrayed in white robes, at night, going to Christian Hill, to meet Christ at his second advent. I should say that there were perhaps about fifteen or twenty of them. I passed them on Westminster Street as I was going to a large fire. I remember the name of but one of the number, which was William Wirling, a boss rigger and stevedore in Providence at the time.
THOS. COWELL.
Signed in presence of— H. A. St. JOHN, W. S. DUNSHEE, S. P. LOW.
P. S.—Capt. Cowell will testify to the above under oath if required. H. A. St. JOHN.
As Eld. St. John stated, the subject of ascension robes has been much agitated in this part of the country. Testimony to prove the story has been persistently called for; and in order to bring it out if any could be found, Eld. White for years before his death offered a reward of fifty dollars for the statement of any eye-witness to the fact. Yet none responded. It became very evident that there were none to be found. When, therefore, the foregoing letters from Bro. St. John were received, it struck us as not a little singular that witnesses should at this late date turn up so plentifully away in California; how should it happen that all who saw the ascension robe business were either dead, or had migrated to the Pacific coast?
As Bro. F. A. Buzzell is now living in Providence, R. I. (22 Cranston St.), we decided to forward the testimonies to him, requesting him to look the matter up, and learn what he could concerning them. He kindly took hold of the work, and in a few days returned the following response. Beginning the investigation, naturally, in his own city, he first took up the testimony of Mr. Cowell concerning
ASCENSION ROBES IN PROVIDENCE, R. I.
He first called on Dr. Josiah Litch, well known throughout the Advent ranks in 1843–4, as an able writer and preacher, associated with Wm. Miller, J. V. Himes, and others, and one well able to speak on such a matter as this. Mr. L. testifies as follows:—
“I have lived here since before 1843, and knew all about the work, the stories, etc. I have traced out many such stories and always found them lies.” Of the statement concerning ascension robes in Providence, Dr. Litch said, “It is a fraud, there is no truth in it whatever.”
Bro. B. continues: “Eld. Litch is still preaching, and is a believer in the soon coming of the Lord. He gave several instances of his own handling of the ascension robe lies, which can be furnished if desired. I will here mention one as stated by him: A Presbyterian minister in Philadelphia soon after 1844 preached against Adventists, and told the ascension robe story. Dr. L. soon after requested witnesses. Three were named—they all denied it. A second lot were furnished—they were just as good as the first lot. Lot No. 3 were procured, but they proved a match for the others. The minister got ‘sick’ and said he ‘heard so.’”
“For more particulars the Dr. advised me to interview Dea. Anthony Pearce. Mr. P. was found at the office of the Providence Machine Co., where he has filled the position of book-keeper and cashier for nearly forty years. When the story was unfolded to him, he smiled and said, ‘It is a lie, the whole of it. No such thing happened here, nor elsewhere. I have lived here fifty-five years. I knew all about the work here, and took part in it. [Mr. P. took a very prominent part in the movement here.] I never saw any such thing, nor heard anything of the kind,’ and it could not have happened and not been publicly known.”
“Was there any division in the Adventist body then, Deacon?—‘No sir; there was but one company.’”
“I then inquired for the Wm. Wirling mentioned in Mr. Cowell’s testimony, and Mr. Pearce referred me to Mrs. John Lonsdale, a widow.”
“Mrs. Lonsdale cheerfully entered into conversation; and in answer to the question relative to her memory of events in 1844, she said: ‘Oh yes; I am seventy-four years old, but I remember well about it. My husband was very zealous in the doctrine, and we talked about it a great deal.’”
“Did you ever know a Mr. Wm. Wirling?—‘Why, yes, he was my husband’s step-father.’”
“Do you remember of ever seeing any Adventists put on robes for ascension in 1844?—‘Oh, no, indeed!’”
“Do you think Mr. Wirling did so at any time?—‘Oh, no, no, no, indeed! Bro. Wirling never would be one to do so; he was a very quiet man, and talked but little.’”
“Did you ever hear of any in Providence putting on ascension robes?—‘No, never.’”},{
“At a second interview, in answer to the question, Do you remember whether Mr. Wirling was a believer in ‘time,’ that is, as to the set day? Mrs. L. said, ‘Do you mean the seventh month?’ I answered, Yes. She replied, ‘No, indeed! Mr. W. and his wife never accepted the “time” theory. They couldn’t see it, neither did my husband until afterward, and they were much together.’”
“Mrs. L. is a member of the Christian church, yet an Adventist, and an excellent woman.”
“I next found a Deacon King, who testified that he never heard of any such event taking place in Providence. He was all through the work in 1844, and did not know of any one doing so, nor hear of it as taking place here, but ‘I did hear of it,’ he said, ‘as taking place elsewhere; but it is all a lie.’”
“Mr. David Cady, a good Methodist, who has a House Furnishing establishment on High Street, and did business in the same place in 1844, was next interviewed. In answer, he said, ‘Well, you have asked me a question, and I’ll give you an answer. I have heard that some did put on ascension robes to go up in, in 1844; but I never saw anything of the kind.’ Did you hear that any did so in Providence? ‘No, I never did.’ Showing him Cowell’s statement, he said, ‘Oh, that never took place here. I should have known something about it. I don’t think it took place anywhere. I never believed in the story.’ Mr. Cady’s store is on the brow of Christian Hill, where the procession, according to Mr. Cowell, would pass to gain suitable ground.”
“The Providence Daily Journal of 1844, was examined. A careful examination of the files of this paper discovered no statement or allusion to any persons’ putting on ascension robes, at the appointed times, although frequent allusions were made to the Millerites; and further, no notice could be found of any fire on the evenings of such times, or near to them, as Mr. Cowell says.”
ASCENSION ROBES IN BRISTOL.
Extending his investigations to Bristol, in pursuance of Mr. Johnson’s testimony, Bro. Buzzell readily found that the Mr. Sayer he mentions was Mr. Rouse Sayer; and of him he writes:—
“This gentleman lived in Bristol in 1844, but died quite a number of years ago. Mr. S. was one of the best men in the Methodist church, according to the testimony of Mr. Leonard Simmons, a member of the same church, and never an Adventist; and also the testimony of Mr. Lorenzo Kenney, a member of the Methodist church and not an Adventist; also of Mr. Benj. Tilley, who was a member with Mr. Sayer, and of Mrs. Benj. Tilley, who is Mr. Sayer’s step-daughter. These last two are Adventists, though Mrs. T’s name is on the Methodist church book yet. The facts concerning his expulsion from the M. E. church are these:—”
“Mr. Sayer, together with quite a number of ‘Millerites,’ was expelled—if that word can be rightfully used, I doubt if it can—in this wise: According to the statement of Mr. Simmons, a minister by the name of Bonny had charge of the church at the time—spring and fall, 1844. For some reason he was in jeopardy of being turned out, and to save himself, the Millerites must go, as they would vote against him. A church meeting gave Bonny the privilege of ‘reading’ the disaffected ones out. They were read out for non-attendance, but immediately were given the permission to come into fellowship again by promising to abide by the M. E. rules. Some did, some did not.”
“W. H. Johnson, according to Simmons and Kenney, was in sympathy with Bonny, and in this act took a prominent part. This probably was the way he ‘preferred charges.’ Mr. Simmons’ memory in this affair was rendered serviceable by the fact that his father was one of those read out,—one of the Millerites.”
“Mr. Sayer could not certainly have been one of the company that went out on the ‘green with ascension robes,’ as he did not believe in time. He and Mr. Tilley, and some others, did not accept the appointment of time. Mr. James Gladding, who was, and is, considered as thorough an Adventist as there is in Bristol, said, ‘Sayer was only a broken-winged Adventist.’ Why, said I, did he not believe in time? ‘No,’ said Mr. Gladding. This led to a second visit to Mr. Tilley’s. Mrs. T. was asked, Did not Mr. Sayer believe in the time-setting in 1844? ‘Oh, no! he and Mr. Tilley took no stock in that.’ This certainly nullifies the testimony of Mr. Johnson in this case.”
“In regard to ascension robes, I learn these facts: Mr. Benj. Tilley and wife are Adventists. They were in the faith, excepting time, through 1844. They are positive that nothing of the kind ever did occur anywhere, much less in Bristol. They knew it could not have occurred there, as no such thing came to their eyes or ears. Mrs. T. said several went to Providence on a day appointed for a meeting there. These were ‘timeists.’”
METHODIST AND EPISCOPAL TESTIMONY.
“Mrs. Martin, Episcopal, said she ‘had laughed many times at thoughts of what some did as to property, etc., but had never heard that any ever put on robes in Bristol, and did not believe they did.’ Mr. Martin, a Methodist, bore the same testimony in substance.”
“Another Methodist, Mr. Leonard Simmons, carriage maker, lives in a house fronting the green, called now ‘common.’ There is only a street between him and the common—no fence. He testified that he had never seen nor heard of any ascension robes on the common. He was there in clear view of the common in 1844, and remembered the movements of the Millerites well. Says he would certainly have known of it, if it had occurred. His father was one of the most active in the Millerite movement, and said, when Bonny gave the ‘read out’ ones privilege to come back, on certain terms, ‘I never did perjure myself, and I won’t begin it now,’ and went with those who left the church.”},{
“Another Methodist, Mr. Lorenzo Kenney, lives near the common, in sight, within a stone’s throw. He testified that he had heard some did put on the robes, but does not think it possible to have occurred on the common and no one know about it in Bristol, and he himself not know of it. He did not believe it did.”
“Mr. Charles Simmons, a non-professor, said he had no faith whatever in the story. He never saw or heard anything of it, although he knew all about the Advent work in the place.”
“Another gentleman, present part of the time when this conversation was going on with Messrs. Simmons and Kenney, voluntarily testified to substantially the same facts as did Mr. Charles Simmons.”
“A FULL-BLOODED ADVENTIST.”
Mr. J. H. Gladding, said, when the subject was broached to him, ‘I’ll give anybody $50 to point out a single person that ever did put on the ascension robe. It’s a lie from beginning to end. If anybody here ever put on an ascension robe, I should have done so; for I was one of the strongest believers. No, it never did happen here. I was in the movement from the beginning to the end, and I knew them all, and all about them.’
“Do you remember, Mr. Gladding, I asked, where you were when the ‘times’ came?—‘Yes sir, I do.’ Where were you on the night of the 10th day of the 7th month?—‘I was in a house here, with three others.’”
“Still another Methodist, living near the southeast corner of the green, said he never saw anything of the kind, but had only heard such stories.”
“Mr. Peck, the clerk of the M. E. church, said he thought Mr. Sayer’s name was now on the church record. The business records he said were missing from 1834 to 1866 on account of the drowning of a former clerk.”
NOTORIETY.
Concerning Mr. Johnson’s statement that it was a matter of notoriety that a company of ten or fourteen went out on the green, robed for ascension, is it not a little singular that none of those who have lived here and so well knew the Adventists and those who were of the number, should so soon forget so wonderful a piece of fanaticism?
Some weeks after the testimonies of Messrs. Cowell and Johnson were received, lo! another witness turned up in Santa Barbara, Cal., whose testimony Eld. St. John promptly forwarded to us as follows:—
STATE OF CALIFORNIA, SANTA BARBARA, AUG. 5, 1885.
I, Mehitable Forebush, resident of the city of Santa Barbara, California, in the autumn of the year of 1843 or 1844, lived with my brother-in-law, James Seymour, in the city of Auburn, New York. His mother, Mrs. Lydia Seymour, and myself lodged in the same room. Mrs. Lydia Seymour was a Millerite Adventist, and expected the end of the world upon a certain night (in the month of November, I think). Mrs. Lydia Seymour had made, or caused to be made, a white ascension robe, as she herself called it, in which she arrayed herself in the evening. The robe was long and white, and made of fine material. She also had a peculiar white cap for the occasion. I saw, with my own eyes, Mrs. Lydia Seymour arrayed in her robe and cap. She was a member of the Baptist church at the time. She wore the robe and cap all the evening, before the family, and through the night.
MEHITABLE FOREBUSH.
Signed in presence of— R. A. St. JOHN.
As Eld. J. E. Swift has been laboring in Auburn quite recently, and was therefore prepared to attend to this testimony, we forwarded it to him, requesting him to investigate it. In a short time we received the following response, dated “52 Crouse Building, Syracuse, N. Y., Sept. 17, 1885”:—
“BRO. SMITH: Yesterday I visited Auburn to look up the matter mentioned in the testimony of Mrs. Forebush. In looking up the records of the Baptist church of which Mrs. Lydia Seymour was a member in 1844, I very readily found a man who had been intimately connected with that church for the last fifty years. He directed me to the home of two sisters of Mehitable Forebush. The facts in the case concerning the ascension robe story, according to their testimony, are as follows:—”
“Mrs. Seymour, with these sisters and others, attended the meetings held by the Millerites at that time, and was interested in them. In the night following the day set for the Lord to come, in the month of October, 1844, there came a dreadful storm; and the head-board to the bed occupied by Mrs. Seymour fell out, at which Mrs. Seymour sprang out of bed, and ran to the window, exclaiming that it was the Lord coming. One of these sisters, who was occupying the same room with her, said, ‘No, Mrs. Seymour, it is only the head-board falling out.’ And this is as near as Mrs. Seymour ever came to making an ascension robe!”},{
“Both of these sisters testify that they lived in the same house with Mrs. Seymour on State St., and were with her upon the night in question, as well as right along. I then asked them if Mrs. Seymour ever made or wore an ascension robe to meet the Lord. They both exclaimed immediately, with a good deal of emphasis, ‘No!’ seeming to be horrified at the thought of such a thing. I then asked them if they knew a lady by the name of Mehitable Forebush. Said they, ‘Yes; she is our sister.’ I then read to them the letter written by Mrs. Mehitable Forebush. They thought she never could have written the letter.”
“They testified still further concerning this Mehitable, that she was then a girl thirteen years of age, and that she was neither in the house, nor in the city, on the night in question; but was with her father, Lucas Wheaton, on his farm in the country, seven miles from the city. So this story turns out like all the rest. Probably Mrs. Forebush heard some such story when a child, and has repeated it so many times that she has now come to believe it is the truth.”
“Faithfully yours, J. E. SWIFT, per W. L. LEONARD.”