AdventAI

PREFERRING HEATHENISM TO THE BIBLE.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 40., October 13, 1885

In the Wesleyan Methodist of Sept. 9, 1885 (a copy of which a sister has kindly sent us), there is a remarkable article headed “Worse than Heathen”—remarkable for its conspicuous lack of all logical foresight. It is an attack upon the view held by S. D. Adventists that immortality is to be obtained alone through Christ. And this it calls “worse than heathen.”

Concisely stated its argument is this: “The heathen believed in the conscious state of the dead and the immortality of the soul; Seventh-day Adventism denies this; therefore it is worse than heathen.” Such reasoning on the part of an intelligent journal is somewhat surprising. Suppose we should frame an argument like this: “The heathen believe in the worship of idols; our friends of the Methodist do not believe in this; therefore they are worse than heathen.” Would they accept such reasoning as that? Yet it is precisely the kind they use against us. The question first to be settled is whether or not these heathen doctrines of the worship of idols and the immortality of the soul are true, before they are made a test for others.

With the exception of its charges against our views, the whole article is devoted to proving, mainly by quotations from heathen writers, that the heathen did believe in the immortality of the soul. So far as we are concerned it might have spared itself this labor; for we admit that the doctrine has been very generally taught and believed in the heathen world; and it stands on a par with the rest of their heathenism—their idol-worship, pre-existence of souls, transmigration of souls, and Sunday holiday.

And the very fact that this doctrine of the immortality of the soul has been so long entrenched in the darkness of heathenism, is one reason why we reject it; for the heathen are not our oracles; we do not go to them for instruction. We believe we have a better source of light and truth, and that is, the oracles of God. We appeal to them. A person naturally introduces the best authority he has in support of his faith. We bring forward the Bible; the Wesleyan Methodist brings forward heathenism. We are sorry to see it giving the preference to that great system of darkness and error.

The blessed Bible has none of this doctrine. That book does not rob Christ of his glory as the Life-giver; it does not labor to set forth in the most solemn and impressive manner the great facts of a future general Judgment and a future general resurrection of the dead, as it does if it teaches anything, and then heap on another doctrine which completely nullifies them, by taking away all occasion for them, and all place for them. This the doctrine of the immortality of the soul does; and the bringing of it in within the precincts of Christian teaching is the work of that enemy who has from the beginning endeavored to sow the pernicious tares of error among the wheat of heavenly truth.

Our first parents were deceived by it when the first great liar told them in Eden that they should not surely die if they did disobey God. And when they did die, and his scheme was likely to be fully exploded, he undertook to save himself by inventing another story equally false, and that is that they did not die after all; that the real spirit man escaped death and became more alive than ever before. The rapid apostasy of mankind from God furnished a favorable soil for this great error. And when heathenism came into the Christian Church, and produced that mongrel, the papacy, it was careful to bring this in and make it one of the corner-stones of the new system; and through the papacy, the mother of harlots and abominations of the earth, it has been foisted into almost all the creeds of Christendom. But, thank God, the Reformation is still going forward, and the true Church will discard this error also. It is a doctrine philosophically absurd, Scripturally false, practically leading to the most monstrous conclusions, and is the prolific mother of a long series of errors as misshapen as itself.

The first deception will suffice. We do not propose to be taken in by the second. We have no interest in trying to bolster up the reputation of that being who has so woefully beguiled mankind. The Methodist may do so if it chooses. We presume it will, like the majority of Christendom, cling to this false doctrine till it is roped in by it to the last great and most fatal delusion of Satan—Spiritualism—which is wholly founded upon this doctrine, and by which he will decoy to their ruin all who are not established upon the pure truths of God’s word, and shielded by them from his insidious deceptions.