AdventAI

THE NEW DEPARTURE.

By M. E. Kellogg

From Review and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 40., October 13, 1885

BY ELD. M. E. KELLOGG.

Years ago, before the Sabbath agitation had attained its present prominent position, commentators and ministers did not think of applying Paul’s words in Col. 2:16 to the weekly Sabbath. They were almost unanimous in holding that the Sabbaths here referred to were the yearly festivals of the Jews; or that, as the American Tract Society Bible says, in its notes upon the text, “The passage does not refer to the Sabbath of the moral law associated with the commands forbidding murder, theft, and adultery.” Nor did the old standard writers of the Protestant denominations ever imagine that the first Christian council held in A. D. 51, and described in the 15th chapter of Acts, met to decide whether Christians should keep the ten commandments or not? They would have been horrified at the thought of the perpetuity of the moral law being a subject even for apostolic discussion.

God’s voice from Sinai, and the words of Christ in Matt. 5:17, had established in their minds the law of God beyond the shadow of a doubt. But a great change appears to be coming over the minds of the ministers of the various churches upon this point. Pressed hard by the advocates of the Bible Sabbath, they find the old line of defense untenable; for if the moral law is binding, the logical sequence is that it must still enforce as the Sabbath the day which it specifies; namely, the seventh day, or Saturday; or in other words, they see that the old standard-bearers take positions which, if followed to a logical conclusion, are fatal to the Sunday Sabbath; for they virtually establish the seventh day as the Sabbath by establishing the law that plainly says, “The seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God.” So the theologians of the day are taking a new departure, and are assuming the position that the law of God is abolished, evidently thinking it easier to defend the observance of Sunday with the law abolished which says so plainly that the seventh and not the first day is the Sabbath. Or, to state it very plainly, they prefer a false premise that they may easier draw a false conclusion, rather than to have a correct premise, and yet be obliged, as their fathers have been, to adopt conclusions not in harmony with their own theories.

In this new theological somersault, we see another illustration of the words of the wise man, that “God hath made man upright; but they have sought out many inventions.” John Wesley charged the iniquity of his day to certain preachers who thought that the law was not binding; and to counteract their influence, Fletcher wrote his justly celebrated “Checks to Antinomianism.” And we raise the question, Will not the same teaching bring about the same result? and this belittling of God’s law break down the barriers of moral restraint, and thus help to usher in the terrible state of wickedness of the last days as described by Christ and his apostles?

Adam Clarke said that “True conversion does not take place when the moral law is not preached and enforced.” St. Paul, describing professing Christians in the last days, charges upon them a fearful catalogue of sins—unmistakable evidence that they have never experienced true conversion. 2 Tim. 3:1–5. These thoughts were suggested while listening to a prominent and gifted minister’s discourse upon the subject of the Sabbath. While he did not say in express terms that the ten commandments were abolished, yet his position was such that this would be the natural conclusion. The following statement is verbatim: “Paul simply repeated to the Colossians the negative half of the decree of the Council of Jerusalem. He summarized the Jewish ritual, and set it aside. Those things of a general moral reference had been mentioned which the Gentiles must observe. Paul now mentions an equal number among those things that they need not observe, and among them is the seventh-day Sabbath!”

Here the claim is made that the council at Jerusalem decided that the Sabbath need not be observed by Gentile Christians. But the Sabbath is not mentioned as a subject for discussion, nor does James in his decision mention the Sabbath at all. Acts 15:19, 20. How, then, could the speaker have supposed that the Sabbath was one of the topics discussed, when the record is entirely silent upon this point? Only upon the supposition that the law, whose relations to the Gentiles they were discussing, was the law of which the Sabbath was a part; namely, the law of ten commandments. And as James decided that the Gentile Christians need not observe the law under discussion, it surely follows that Gentile Christians are released from obedience to the ten commandments. We would now ask what advantage they have gained by their new departure? The old theory was right in principle, and nine-tenths right in practice. The new theory is all wrong in principle and certainly no better in practice, but with a great liability of far worse results; for the former position, if fully carried out, led only to the observance of one more precept, the fourth, while the new position, carried to the same extreme, leads as surely to the violation of all the ten commandments, as well as the one obnoxious one. I said that this new position was wrong in principle; for there is not the least evidence that the moral law, or any part of it, was ever made the subject of the apostolic council.

The ten commandments must stand or fall together. The observance of the Sabbath was probably the first moral duty required of man, and the God of infinite wisdom made no mistake when he put the law for the observance of the Sabbath, not in the ritual law, but in the very bosom of those moral duties which have been made the basis of the laws of every civilized government.

But granting, for the sake of argument, that the apostolic council was held in reference to that law of which the Sabbath was a part, let us see to what absurd conclusions we shall inevitably come. Let me quote once more a part of the sentence under consideration: “Those things of a general moral reference had been mentioned which the Gentiles must observe.” Now, to particularize, what were those things of a “general moral reference” which were mentioned in the decision of the apostolic council as binding upon the Gentile Christians? We have no difficulty in finding what they were; for they are mentioned twice in Acts 15:20, 29 as meats offered to idols, fornication, things strangled, and blood, “from which if ye keep yourselves, ye shall do well.” Now, if the moral law was the subject of discussion (and it must have been if the obligation to keep the Sabbath was to be decided), and also granting that those things of a “general moral reference” had been mentioned “which the Gentiles must observe,” we are inevitably drawn to the astounding conclusion that abstaining from things strangled and from blood are more moral actions than is the observance of the commands forbidding profanity, murder, theft, etc., since these commandments are not mentioned in the decision of the council as being binding on the Gentiles; and yet, we are told, “those things of a general moral reference had been mentioned.” And even if both laws, the moral and the ceremonial, had been under consideration, we should come to the same absurd conclusion; so nothing has been gained by this new departure in theological tactics. When they acknowledged the law to be binding, but claimed that the Sabbath had been changed, we met them there, and proved their theories wanting. And now, as they shift their line of argument from the Sabbath precept alone to the law as a whole, they are compelled to take positions like the one we are considering, and which are as easily met and refuted as was their former position.

But what law was the subject of the apostolic council held at Jerusalem A. D. 51? We answer, the ceremonial law of the Jews; or, as it is called, the “Law of Moses.” The distinction between the moral and the ceremonial laws is plainly marked in both the Old and the New Testaments. If we do not allow this distinction, we involve the sacred writers in endless absurdities and contradictions. Thus St. Paul says, in Rom. 3:31: “Do we then make void the law through faith? God forbid: yea, we establish the law.” And again he says, in Eph. 2:15: “Having abolished in his flesh the enmity, even the law of commandments contained in ordinances,” which is a square contradiction, unless the apostle is speaking of distinct and separate codes of law. And James, who presided at the apostolic council, and who brought in the decision: “Forasmuch as we have heard, that certain which went out from us have troubled you with words, subverting your souls, saying, Ye must . . . keep the law; to whom we gave no such commandment,” this same James, writing the general epistle of James eight years later, said, “For whosoever shall keep the whole law, and yet offend in one point, he is guilty of all.” James 2:10. So while one law is not to be kept, another law is still binding; and the next verse, by direct quotations of the sixth and seventh commandments, makes it very plain that James is here speaking of the moral law, of which the Sabbath was a part, and which, allowing James to be consistent with himself, never had been the subject of apostolic discussion.

Meats offered to idols are mentioned; for this was a very general practice in all heathen countries. And though, as St. Paul writes to the Corinthians, “an idol is nothing in the world,” yet all did not have this knowledge; and so the conscience of the weak brother might be defiled. It had also a slight bearing on the command found in the moral law, “Thou shalt have no other gods before me;” and like all other moral precepts, must be carefully guarded. Fornication was noticed for the same reason. Those acquainted with history know that even the greatest and best of heathens looked with wonderful complacency upon this crime, while the worship of their gods was often attended by the most licentious rites. And while there was a ceremonial law relating to this sin, it also has a close relation to the seventh commandment, and hence is especially noticed. The commands concerning blood and things strangled, are purely and entirely in the ceremonial law; and yet so much even of this law is retained as binding upon Christian believers everywhere.

If the fourth commandment read, “The first day is the Sabbath,” the majority of the Christian world would think it meant just what it said, and they would never think of such a thing as the law’s being abolished. What a pity that an institution so beneficent, made for man, should be the object of man’s untiring hate! Certainly we must conclude, “an enemy hath done this;” and we may well adopt the language of the psalmist: “It is time for thee, Lord, to work; for they have made void thy law.” By and by, God will arise in judgment to vindicate his law. Then will the wickedness of the wicked come to an end; and—

“’T will be a priceless treasure then to know That in the moral darkness here below, We tried his holy law to keep in view, And prove ourselves of loyal hearts and true.”