A WORTHY clergyman who had been suspected of having improperly interfered in influencing some of the young people under his pastoral care to absent themselves from a ball that took place in the parish, received in consequence the following anonymous note:—
“SIR: Obey the voice of Scripture. Take the following for your text, and contradict it. Show in what consists the evil of that innocent amusement, dancing: ‘A time to weep, and a time to laugh; a time to mourn, and a time to dance.’ Eccl. 3:4.
“A TRUE CHRISTIAN, but no hypocrite.”
The minister wrote the following admirable reply, which appeared in public print:—
“MY DEAR SIR (or Madam): Your request that I would preach from Eccl. 3:4 I cannot comply with at present, since there are some Christian duties more important than dancing, which a part of my people seem disposed to neglect. Whenever I perceive, however, that the duty of dancing is too much neglected, I shall not fail to raise a warning voice against so dangerous an omission. Meantime there are certain difficulties in the text which you recommend to my notice, the solution of which I should receive with gratitude from ‘a true Christian.’ My first difficulty is respecting the time for dancing; for although the text declares that there is a time to dance, yet when that time is, it does not determine. Now this point I want to ascertain exactly, before I preach upon the subject; for it would be as criminal, I conclude, to dance at the wrong time, as to neglect to dance at the right time. I have been able to satisfy myself in some particulars when it is not ‘a time to dance.’ We shall agree, I presume, that on the Sabbath-day, or at a funeral, or during the prevalence of a pestilence, or the rocking of an earthquake, or the roaring of a thunder storm, would not be times to dance. If we were condemned to die, and were waiting in prison the day of execution, this would be no time for dancing; and if our feet stood on a slippery place beside a precipice, we should not dare to dance.
“But suppose the very day be ascertained; is the whole day or only a part to be devoted to this amusement? And if part of the day only, then which part is the ‘time to dance’? From the notorious evil effects of midnight meetings, both upon morals and health, no one will pretend that midnight is the time to dance.
“Is it a command to dance, or only a permission? Or is it merely a declaration of the fact that, as men are constituted, there is a time when all the events alluded to do come to pass? If the text be a command, do those who engage in the popular form of dancing do it to satisfy their conscience? Does it cultivate a wholesome restraint and a love to meet afterwards with humble Christians in the prayer-meeting? If a permission, is it optional? Or if it be merely that there is a time when men do dance, and there is a time when they die, then I might as well be requested to take the first eight verses of the chapter and show in what consists the evil of hating, and making war, and killing men.
“For the sake of abbreviating this letter, I will merely say that Ecclesiastes is enumerating some of the events that transpire among men, some of which are harmless, while some are expressly forbidden in the commandments of God and the precepts of Jesus. To those who wish to avail themselves of this as a special permission, or who deem it as a command, and dance for conscience’ sake, I would submit that while dancing is spoken of in the Bible, the mode and circumstances may be legitimate or illegitimate; and if we dance for conscience’ sake, we should be consistent and examine the Scriptures throughout, and discriminate between legitimate and illegitimate dancing.
“By searching the Scriptures you will find that dancing was performed by maidens only; that no instances of dancing are found upon record in the Bible in which both sexes united in the exercise, either as an act of worship or amusement; that there is no instance of social dancing for amusement, except that of the vain fellow devoid of shame, of the irreligious families described by Job, which produced increased impiety, and ended in destruction; and of Herodias, which terminated in the rash vow of Herod and the murder of John the Baptist.”—Sel.