AdventAI

WHAT SHALL WE DO WITH THAT BOY?

From Review and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 42., October 27, 1885

If he is already in his teens, and you cannot control him except by the rod, you had better abandon the attempt to control him, and put him into other hands. The fault is certainly yours. We do not mean that you have sinned; all faults are not sins. But you have proved yourself incompetent to manage him, and the danger of continuing the experiment is altogether too great. It may be that your temperament and his are so antagonistic that you arouse each other's combativeness; it may be that they are so different that you cannot comprehend one another; it may be that he has greater force of character than you have, and therefore you cannot control him except by physical force, which is a very poor substitute. Whatever the reason is, if the fact is that you cannot control him, you had better get some one else to do it for you. If your colt, after three months under one trainer, kicked worse than when the trainer took him, you would look out for a change either in the colt or in the trainer. In this case you cannot very well change the colt; you had better, therefore, change the trainer. Seek for a good school, with a principal who cares more about character than about Greek and Latin, and about Greek and Latin chiefly as instruments in the development of character, who loves boys, and whom boys love, and who maintains a kindly, gentle, not severe, but firm discipline, and put your boy under him. There are such schools. You cannot find them by luck, nor by hitting on the one nearest home, or on the cheapest, or on one that somebody recommends, or that prints a fine list of references. You must look not merely for a good school, but for a good school for your boy; one adapted to your needs, one possessing the qualifications we have given above. It is quite likely that a year in such a school will make a great change in his character; that, coming into an atmosphere of obedience, he will fall into a habit of obedience, and that when he returns to you next summer it will only require a reasonable modicum of common sense on your part to avoid provoking anew the present chronic controversy. This is the only counsel we can give the father whose boy is in his teens and can be controlled only by the rod. But to other fathers we suggest some principles of action that may prevent such a dreadful condition.

1. The father's first duty is to sympathize with his children, and so to win their sympathy. If you want your boy to be manly, you must be boyish. If you want him to join in your ambitions for him, you must join in his sports and enter into his life. You cannot govern him by perpetual repression. You must guide him; and if you are to guide him, you must have hold of his hand, and keep hold. If you do not want him to play cards, play something better with him; if you do not wish him to seek fun in the streets at night, furnish him with fun in the parlor. It is said of our heavenly Father that he knoweth our frame, he remembereth that we are dust. A great many fathers do not know their boys' frames, nor remember that they are boys. Most natures will yield to love more quickly than to authority; or, to speak more accurately, to the authority of love than to that of force. We are not recommending the substitution of entreaty for command, or coddling for authority. We urge simply to keep up fellowship between yourself and your boy. Thus he will learn first to trust, then to obey you.

2. Give very few commandments; insist on prompt and ready obedience to those. Children who are kept in swaddling-clothes all the time will sooner or later rend them off. God put the law for the human race in ten commandments on two tables of stone; there are some families that would require a folio volume to contain all the restrictions of their domestic Mount Sinai. The best school in which to learn is the school of experience. It is better that your boy should make a hundred mistakes and learn ten lessons than that he should make no mistakes and learn no lessons. You irritate your boy by perpetual criticism and perpetual law-making. There are families where the sole intercourse between parent and child is confined to “John, don't do this; John, don't do that,” on the one side, and “Why not, father?” on the other. The best father we ever knew rarely gave any command to his boys; not often even any positive advice. He left them to get wisdom by experience. When he did command, they never thought of disobeying. Great sympathy; few laws; these few absolute and inexorable; this is the condition of good family government.

3. In the administration of this government, see to it that you have your boy's conscience on your side. Punish him, not merely when he deserves it, or when you think he deserves it, but when he thinks that he deserves it. Never, absolutely never, punish on suspicion. Never, absolutely never, condemn without first giving the accused a hearing. Do not condemn him even in your own mind till you hear what he has to say. Every boy, as every man, is to be presumed innocent until he has been proved guilty. There is no injustice more horrible than that practiced on children, and no victims who are more sensitive to it. The governor who always has the conscience of the governed on his side will never have a rebellion. It is not always easy to secure this; but it is possible. Never punish a child for the consequences of his wrong conduct. If his carelessness has broken a window or torn his clothes, quite likely that is of itself punishment enough. It is when he has been careless and no harm has come that he needs punishment. Never punish because you are angry, or because you have said you would and it will not do to retract, or until he yields and does what he is bidden to do. Whatever punishment may be in the government of God, in the government of man it is simply curative. Punish only for the sake of curing your boy of his sin; punish only so far as may be necessary for that purpose; punish the wrong act, and do not punish again until it is repeated. And when you have punished, do with your boy's sin what God does with ours: blot it out of the book of your remembrance, and remember it no more against him forever. Thus you may secure the sympathy of your boy even in the punishment you administer, and his co-operation in all your work of training him toward a perfect Christian manhood. It is certain that you cannot do much toward that training without such co-operation.—Christian Union.