AdventAI

WHY I DARE NOT.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 42., October 27, 1885

“Will you hear Ingersoll when he comes to Detroit?” said a professing Christian, but a man of somewhat “liberal” views, to the writer recently. “No, I think not.” “But why? may I ask, since he is one of our finest rhetoricians and a magnificent orator. It seems a pity to forego the pleasure of listening to so gifted a speaker because his ideas are obnoxious. After all, he is certain to say a good many true things, if they have an unpleasant edge. He is a moralist if he is not a religionist, and does not design to break down the restraints of good society and good citizenship.”

“A reason which has some weight with me is the influence of example. In my individual case, it might be very slight; but the world hasn’t much respect for the sincerity of a professing Christian who runs about listening to blatant skeptics because they are brilliant orators. A second reason is that Mr. Ingersoll delivers these lectures to accomplish two ends; viz., to make money, and to tear down a faith that he hates with a deadly hatred. If I buy a ticket to hear him, I contribute my quota to replenish his pocket and to further his ulterior purpose. Shall I give aid and comfort to a man who seeks to pull down about my head the house that shelters me?”

“Now for reason number three: Your first and second carry weight with a great many good people, I admit, though they would not keep me from hearing anybody that I wanted to hear.”

“My third reason is that I am afraid to hear Ingersoll on my own account.”

“Ah! that’s as I suspected, but I did not think you would be frank enough to admit it. You cannot be very well grounded in your own faith if that’s the case.”

“I am and I am not. Faith is a relative, not an absolute term. There cannot be too much of it. There may be too much credulity, but that is something heaven-wide from faith. Credulity is earth-born, the child of ignorance and superstition. Faithp. 667 is from above and can only linger and thrive in hospitable hearts, where congenial guests are entertained. If I were to hear Ingersoll, not once but many times, I have no fear that I should become his conscious and avowed disciple. If I were to read the Police Gazette, or drink in the subtler poison, from which many apparently virtuous people do not shrink, of Ouida or Zola, it is not probable that my outward life would greatly change. I should not disregard the canons of respectable society, but it does not follow that the virus would be powerless for harm. Said a good man in reviewing the influences and experiences of his youth: ‘I saw a picture once that I would give anything almost to this day never to have looked upon. It fades away and then it starts up again with all its hideous suggestiveness. I feel sometimes as if it would hang in the gallery of my memory to all eternity. The lesson I have thus learned, I teach my boys—that they cannot be too careful in regard to the impressions they voluntarily receive.’”

“Now with regard to the matter of hearing this notorious skeptic, I have come to understand that faith belongs to the higher nature, doubt to the lower, originating, if unconsciously, in intellectual conceit and selfish desires. I once read that ‘the measure of a man is the measure of his faith’ and did not then quite understand or believe it. It seems to me now to be obviously true and an important truth. Bible teaching aside, there is something earthly, sensual, devilish about doubt—at least it leads to the sensual and the devilish. Faith is broadening, inspiring, uplifting. Faith is a sky-lark, doubt a burrowing earth-worm, or a slimy, subtle, crawling serpent. To attain high faith is to do Alpine climbing. It requires a steady look forward and upward, a firmly planted step, a strong staff, and a sure Guide. To doubt is ‘as easy as falling off a log.’ The law of mental gravitation—if you don’t believe in natural depravity—is all on its side. A man with one hundredth part of the mental caliber of Ingersoll can ask questions that the wisest cannot answer. Neither nature nor revelation, neither prophet, priest, nor sage, has disclosed the whole mystery of the life that now is, nor of that which is to come; the wherefore of that dark presence, the principle of evil; the whither and bound of that principle.”

“Says one writer: ‘I never enjoy a poem, however beautiful, if I have once seen it cleverly parodied. By some impish trick of my mind, the parody will ever after recur before the poem, or at the merest mention of it, and all the influence of its noble sentiment or graceful fancy is dissipated.’ So the charm of an honored face may be marred for many eyes by a cruel caricature.”

“Ingersoll is nothing if not a caricaturist of truth—of Biblical truth. Is anything sacred to his touch? He has the gift of distortion, and it is an essentially mean and unworthy one.”

“You may not believe that it is an actual spirit of evil that is forever suggesting to you that the world is full of carking care, of bitterness and hardship; that there is not much honor or unselfishness in men, not much truth in women; that life is not worth living, and that the ‘let us eat and drink; . . to-morrow we die’ principle is more sensible than any other. You may be a strong-willed philosopher, able easily to turn aside such suggestions with little care whence they come, to bear your burdens manfully, and to shoulder, mayhap, many for your neighbors, but you are well aware that the world is not made up of strong-willed philosophers. Take away from the maimed souls and bodies, the sin-sick and the sorrow-laden, any hope of a ‘boundless better,’ any fear of a ‘boundless worse,’ and why should they not a ‘quietus take with a bare bodkin’? Why not cut short what must seem to the faithless a dreary farce at the best, a terrible tragedy at the worst?”

“There is much speculative reading which is fascinating to a certain order of minds, and at the same time is very dangerous. It leads to a brooding over unanswerable questions until every phase of life and duty is seen darkly through a veil of skepticism. The query, ‘What is it all when all is done?’ becomes a haunting echo in the soul. If the writer is thoroughly self-deceived, and if he brings to the task of stultifying others a brilliant intellect and versatile pen, he is all the more successful. If Robert Ingersoll were a blatant bungler, he might be as venomous as now, but would be comparatively harmless. There are doubtless those who can listen to his eloquent unfolding of a subtle web woven out of the skepticism of all the ages without personal harm, even possibly with profit; but most of us need to seek all the helps to faith, and forever to abjure the helps to unbelief. If our train of life is on a down grade, we do not need to feed the fires with infidel arguments. If we are upward bound, faith will be the only sufficient motive power.”—Selected.