AdventAI

A Dispute Between the Bible and the Hymn Books on Immortality

By Isaac Morrison

From Review and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 45., November 17, 1885

A DISPUTE BETWEEN THE BIBLE AND THE HYMN BOOKS ON THE DOCTRINE OF THE IMMORTALITY OF THE SOUL.

BY ISAAC MORRISON.

(Concluded.)

Bible.—“For our conversation is in heaven; from whence also we look for the Saviour, the Lord Jesus Christ; who shall change our vile body, that it may be fashioned like unto his glorious body.” Phil. 3:20, 21.

Doctrine.—Paul is mistaken again; for our books on theology teach that God and Christ are the same, one personal being, and that God is “without body or parts” (“Methodist Discipline,” Arts. I. and II.). Our bodies cannot be fashioned like unto his glorious body when he has none. Neither have angels any bodies or parts; and when we die, we become angels; and angels do not need the second coming of Christ, as they are already in heaven, and do not have any vile bodies to be changed in the resurrection.

“There fell upon the house a sudden gloom, A shadow on those features fair and thin; And softly from that hushed and darkened room, Two angels issued where but one went in.” —Obituary in California Teacher.

B.—“Every one which seeth the Son, and believeth on him, may have everlasting life; and I will raise him up at the last day.” John 6:40.

D.—He will not leave them out of heaven that long, nor will he raise them up out of their graves; for they will not go into the grave, because he takes them to heaven as soon as they die.

“Why do we mourn for dying friends, Or shake at death’s alarms? ’Tis but the voice that Jesus sends To call them to his arms.” —M. E. Hymnal, No. 970.

B.—“Thy dead men shall live, together with my dead body shall they arise. Awake and sing, ye that dwell in dust; for thy dew is as the dew of herbs, and the earth shall cast out the dead.” Isa. 26:19.

D.—Not so; men are not dead, nor dwelling in the dust, but are alive in heaven or hell, whence they must come to be judged, and then be sent wherever they ought to go.

“Death enters; there is no defense; His time there’s none can tell: He’ll in a moment call thee hence To heaven or to hell.” —Methodist Hymns, No. 338.

B.—“If after the manner of men I have fought with beasts at Ephesus, what advantageth it me, if the dead rise not? Let us eat and drink; for to-morrow we die.” 1 Cor. 15:32.

D.—Why, it would be a great advantage to him to fight for the truth, even if there were no resurrection; for that would take him to heaven when he did die. And what would he care if there was no resurrection, when through death, with all of his good friends that should die, he would be in heaven long before the resurrection; besides, when he was once freed from this bodily prison, why should he want a resurrection, to be imprisoned in it again?

“Physician of souls, unto me Forgiveness and holiness give; And then from this body set free, And then to the city receive.” —M. E. Hymnal, No. 1064.

“Weep not for a brother deceased; Our loss is his infinite gain: A soul out of prison released, And freed from its bodily chain.” —M. E. Hymnal, No. 1011.

B.—“Then said Martha unto Jesus, Lord, if thou hadst been here, my brother had not died. . . . Jesus saith unto her, Thy brother shall rise again. Martha saith unto him, I know that he shall rise again in the resurrection at the last day.” John 11:21–24.

D.—He had been raised up to heaven four days already, which Martha should have known from the previous teachings of the Saviour; not what is said in John 5:28, 29: “The hour is coming, in the which all that are in their graves shall hear his voice, and shall come forth;” or in John 6:40: “I will raise him up at the last day;” but from what the Saviour said that is not recorded. We know that people go to heaven as soon as they die; for our ministers, learned divines, eminent logicians, wise theologians, doctors of divinity, reverends, very reverends, right reverends, and most right reverends, have all so taught us. We will stand by what they say; then we shall know that we are right.

“Jesus, Saviour, when I’m dying, When the world recedes from view, Let me see thy banner flying As I mount above the blue; Let me join the saints in glory, Who have fought and won the day; And with golden harp the story Chant as ages pass away.” —The Revivalist (Methodist), No. 478.

B.—“Then said Jesus unto them plainly, Lazarus is dead [he had lain in the grave four days already]. . . . And when he thus had spoken, he cried with a loud voice, Lazarus, come forth. And he that was dead came forth, bound hand and foot with grave-clothes; and his face was bound about with a napkin. Jesus saith unto them, Loose him, and let him go.” John 11:14–44.

D.—The Saviour should have said, “Lazarus, come down;” for Lazarus was not dead and in the grave, but was alive in heaven, with the angels and friends that had gone before; and when the Saviour called him, he came down and entered the body again, happy to leave the joys of heaven and meet his friends on earth once more.

“Grant us the power of quickening grace, To fit our souls to fly; Then when we drop this dying flesh, We’ll rise above the sky.” —Methodist Hymns, No. 1069.

B.—“Then came unto him the Sadducees, which say there is no resurrection; and they asked him, saying, . . . Now there were seven brethren: and the first took a wife, and dying left no seed; . . . and the seven had her, and left no seed: last of all, the woman died also. In the resurrection, therefore, when they shall rise, whose wife shall she be of them? for the seven had her to wife. And Jesus answering said unto them, . . . When they shall rise from the dead, they neither marry, nor are given in marriage; but are as the angels which are in heaven.” Mark 12:18–25.

D.—They ought to have known that that matter was settled long ago, when the woman died, and went to heaven, where the brothers had gone before her. It is a wonder that the Saviour did not tell them so, instead of making them believe that they would have to wait in the grave till the resurrection before they would be as angels in heaven. Although there seems to be no need of a resurrection, it would hardly do to say, with the Sadducees, that there is no resurrection.

“There everlasting spring abides, And never-withering flowers; Death, like a narrow stream, divides That heavenly land from ours.” —Gospel Hymns, No. 67.

“This robe of flesh I’ll drop, and rise To seize the everlasting prize; And shout while passing through the air Farewell, farewell, sweet hour of prayer.” —Gospel Hymns, No. 77.

B.—“Thy wrath is come, and the time of the dead, that they should be judged, and that thou shouldest give reward unto thy servants the prophets, and to the saints, and them that fear thy name, small and great; and shouldest destroy them which destroy the earth.” Rev. 11:18.

D.—There can be no particular appointed time for the dead to be judged, neither for the reward to be given to the saints and prophets, nor for the wicked to be destroyed; because the prophets have been rewarded in heaven long ago, and the saints are dying every moment and going to their eternal reward. Neither can the wicked be destroyed; but are continually going to their eternal torment in hell, and do not wait to be judged, to see whether they should be rewarded or punished. Paul also must have been mistaken when he “reasoned of a Judgment to come,” and preached that the Lord had “appointed a day in the which he would judge the world.”

“Infinite joy or endless woe, Attend on every breath, And yet how unconcerned we go Upon the brink of death.” —Methodist Hymns, No. 1058.

“Our brother the haven hath gained, Outflying the tempest and wind; His rest he hath sooner obtained, And left his companions behind.” —Methodist Hymns, No. 1089.

B.—“Thousand thousands ministered unto him, and ten thousand times ten thousand stood before him; the Judgment was set, and the books were opened.” Dan. 7:10. “And the dead were judged out of those things which were written in the books, according to their works. And the sea gave up the dead which were in it; and death and the grave [margin] delivered up the dead which were in them: and they were judged every man according to their works.” Rev. 20:12, 13.

D.—It is a mistake that there is to be a general future Judgment to decide how people should be rewarded, when, by death, they have already received their just deserts; for how could there be any greater reward than dwelling in heaven in the presence of God and the angels, and loved ones gone before; or any greater punishment than writhing in hell fire to all eternity! Besides, the grave and the sea cannot deliver up the dead that are in them when there are none there, as all of the dead will have gone to heaven or hell at death.

“So then will heaven and hell appear When death’s decisive hour is near.”

“We are going, we are going, When the day of life is o’er, To that pure and happy region Where our friends have gone before.”

“They are singing with the angels In that land so bright and fair, We shall dwell with them forever, There will be no parting there.”

B.—“Many bodies of the saints which slept arose, and came out of the graves after his resurrection, and went into the holy city, and appeared unto many.” Matt. 27:52, 53. See also Eph. 4:8, margin.

D.—There never were any saints asleep in the grave. They were awake in heaven, praising God. They just came down, and appeared to the people, and then went back to heaven.

“Many are the voices calling us away To join their glorious band.” —Gospel Hymns, No. 168.

B.—“Rachel weeping for her children, and would not be comforted, because they are not.” Matt. 2:18.

D.—She ought not to have wept; they were not dead, but— “Each one out of prison released, And freed from its bodily pain,”p. 708 had gone to heaven to be happy in the presence of the angels of God.

“Death may the bands of life unloose, But can’t dissolve my love; Millions of infant souls compose The family above.” —Methodist Hymns, No. 1071.

B.—“The writing of Hezekiah king of Judah, when he had been sick, and was recovered of his sickness: I said in the cutting off of my days, I shall go to the gates of the grave: I am deprived of the residue of my years. I said, I shall not see the Lord, even the Lord, in the land of the living.” Isa. 38:9–11.

D.—Oh, no! Hezekiah would not have gone into the grave, nor have been deprived of his days and years, nor of seeing the Lord; for death is the time when eternal life begins, and when good men like Hezekiah go to heaven where the Lord is. He ought to have been glad and anxious to go.

“Lend me wings like a dove that with love I may fly To meet thee in glorified realms when I die; Evermore to have rest with the pure and the blest; Evermore to be happy on high.”

B.—“If I wait, the grave is mine house; I have made my bed in the darkness.” “They shall go down to the bars of the pit, when our rest together is in the dust.” Job 17:13, 16. “For now shall I sleep in the dust; and thou shalt seek me in the morning, but I shall not be.” Job 7:21.

D.—Why, no, you will not sleep in the dust, with worms; the grave will not be your house when you die: that is just the time when you will exist in reality—when you go to heaven, and are no longer hindered by this vile body of clay.

“How blest is the brother bereft Of all that could burden his mind! How easy the soul that has left This wearisome body behind!” —Methodist Hymns, No. 1087.

“I trust thy truth and love and power Shall save me till my latest hour; And when I lay this body down, Reward with an immortal crown.”

B.—“Men and brethren, let me freely speak unto you of the patriarch David, that he is both dead and buried, and his sepulcher is with us unto this day.” “For David is not ascended into the heavens.” Acts 2:29, 34.

D.—David is not dead and in his grave, but is alive, and has ascended to heaven, where all good men go when they leave this body.

“Burst thy shackles, drop thy clay, Sweetly breathe thyself away; Singing to thy crown remove, Swift of wing and fired of love.” —Methodist Hymns, No. 674.

B.—“But the rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years were finished.” Rev. 20:5.

D.—It could not be said that the rest of the dead lived not again, when there would be no persons dead, but would all be living in greater reality than ever before. People are never really dead, but at what we call death, they begin to live forever.

“So when my latest breath Shall rend the veil in twain, By death I shall escape from death, And life eternal gain.” —Methodist Hymns, No. 943.

B.—“Man dieth, and wasteth away.” Job 14:10.

D.—Man does not die, for he is immortal. He is only separated from the body in which he has been staying, to be sent either to heaven or to the place of torment.

“Dissolve, O house of clay, And let my spirit soar With all the ransomed host above, To praise him evermore.”

B.—“To them who by patient continuance in well-doing seek for glory and honor and immortality [God will render], eternal life.” Rom. 2:7.

D.—You should not seek for immortality; for you already have it, and you cannot seek for what you already have.

“Deathless spirit, now arise; Soar, thou native of the skies; Pearl of price by Jesus bought, To his glorious likeness wrought.” —Methodist Hymns, No. 674.

B.—“This mortal must put on immortality.” 1 Cor. 15:53.

D.—Not so; how can we put on immortality when we already possess it?

“The cheerful tribute will I give, Long as my deathless soul shall live; A work so sweet, a theme so high, Demands and crowns eternity.” —Methodist Hymns, No. 924.

“It is not death to die,— To leave this weary road, And mid-the brotherhood on high To be at home with God.” —M. E. Hymnal, No. 993.

B.—“The King of kings and Lord of lords; who only hath immortality.” 1 Tim. 6:16, 17.

D.—That cannot be; all mankind have immortality. They only live in this body until they are called to leave it and go to heaven.

“No longer imprisoned in the clay, Who next from the dungeon shall fly? Who first shall be summoned away? My merciful Lord, is it I? “O give me a signal to know If soon thou wouldst have me remove, And leave the dull body below And fly to the regions above.” —Methodist Hymns, No. 1088.

B.—“The last enemy that shall be destroyed is death.” 1 Cor. 15:26.

D.—That is a mistake. Death should not be called an enemy; it is one of our best friends; for through death we go to that place of endless happiness.

“Why should we start and fear to die? What timorous worms we mortals are! Death is the gate to endless joy, And yet we dread to enter there.” —Methodist Hymns, No. 1070.

B.—“That through death he might destroy him that had the power of death, that is, the devil.” Heb. 2:14.

D.—The Devil cannot be the one that has the power of death; that would make him the angel that takes us to heaven.

“And when my Saviour calls me home, Still this my prayer shall be, Hinder me not! Come, welcome death, I’ll gladly go with thee.” —Service of Song (Baptist), No. 539.

B.—“It is appointed unto men once to die.” Heb. 9:27.

D.—It is not appointed unto men to die; for their real being is immortal and cannot die.

“It is not death to close The eye long dimmed by tears, And wake in glorious repose To spend eternal years.” —M. E. Hymnal, No. 993.

B.—“And the serpent said unto the woman, YE SHALL NOT SURELY DIE.” Gen. 3:4.

D.—That is just what our hymn book teaches.

“It is not death to fling Aside this sinful dust, And rise on strong, exulting wing To live among the just.”

“It is not death to bear The wrench that sets us free From dungeon chains, to breathe the air Of boundless liberty.” —M. E. Hymnal, No. 993.

Then away with the talk about being dead, staying out of heaven, and waiting in the gloomy grave until the Judgment day, the second coming of Christ, and the resurrection. We will cling to the teaching of our divines, standard theological works, “Disciplines,” confessions of faith, and hymn books. We know that they are right in everything. Then sing some of those good old hymns over again, dear orthodox brethren,—sing with all the energy and enthusiasm you can command; and let our departed ancestors and divines who wrote those hymns hear and know that we are still loyal to the faith.