AdventAI

Special Mention.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 62, No. 48., December 8, 1885

JUSTICE FIELD’S OPINION.

The following, which we clip from the New York Independent of Nov. 19, 1885, very clearly foreshadows the ground on which the observance of Sunday will be demanded by the State from all classes:—

“Mr. Justice Field, of the Supreme Court of the United States, in stating the policy of the law with regard to the Sabbath, recently made the following observations: ‘Laws setting aside Sunday as a day of rest are upheld, not from any right of the Government to legislate for the promotion of religious observances, but from its right to protect all persons from the physical and moral debasement which comes from uninterrupted labor. Such laws have always been deemed beneficent and merciful, especially to the poor and dependent, to the laborers in our factories and workshops, and in the heated rooms of our cities; and their validity has been sustained by the highest courts of the States.’ This is a very fair statement of the theory of the law in all its Sabbath regulations. The Sabbath, as it exists in this country, is made up of two elements, one of which is purely religious, while the other is the rest element, or suspension of the ordinary activities of our secular life. The fact that both of these elements coincide as to the day does not confound them or make them identical. With the purely religious element, which is of the highest importance, civil government has nothing to do, and can have nothing to do, beyond affording protection to those who religiously keep the Sabbath. It prescribes no religious duties to be performed, and annexes no penalties to the non-observance of the Sabbath as a religious day. All the religious questions connected with the day are left, as they should be, to be determined by the conscience of each individual for himself, without any direction or restraint by the civil law. The law proceeds upon a very different theory in respect to the rest element of the Sabbath. It assumes that a day of general rest at comparatively short intervals is useful to society in various ways, and prescribes such rest as a matter of police regulation, and enforces the same by appropriate penalties. The law is right in letting the religious element entirely alone, and equally right in establishing and enforcing a day of general rest. The extent to which such rest shall be enforced is a matter to be determined by sound legislative discretion.”

The opinion of a Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States, will of course have great weight, and many will be satisfied with such reasoning; but we are quite as positive that many will not be. Notwithstanding the apparent plausibility of the position taken, it strikes us that every lineament of this sheep’s head which Mr. Field holds out before us plainly reveals the wolf behind it.

1. It is claimed that the State in demanding that all shall rest from labor one day in the week, is not meddling at all with religious observances. Yet the laws on this question are called “Sabbath laws.” Why is this, if Sunday is not enforced as the Sabbath? But if it is enforced as the Sabbath, it is a religious institution, nothing more nor less.

2. If the State takes such a wonderful interest in the welfare of its citizens as to insist that they must rest one day in seven to save them from physical and moral debasement, can it make any possible difference to the State which day a man shall choose for his rest day, provided he in no wise interferes with others to disturb them in observing the day they may choose to keep? For instance, when a person has observed the seventh day of the week in rest and devotion, has he not guarded himself sufficiently against “the physical and moral debasement which comes from uninterrupted labor”? From the assumed stand-point of Justice Field’s opinion he certainly has. But will this be accepted?—Not by any means. All must not only keep a day, but they must keep a particular day. Then it is not merely to secure the citizen a day of rest that the State legislates. That is a false pretense.

3. Why is the Sunday chosen as the State rest day? Simply because the majority of people regard that day as the Sabbath. Under these circumstances, however much the State may claim to do so, it is impossible to separate the question from the sphere of religion. And what makes the matter peculiarly odious to the seventh-day observer is the fact that this first day has been substituted by human authority for the Sabbath of Jehovah; and hence the loyal adherent of the Bible Sabbath, cannot, without violating his conscience, perform any act which will in the least recognize Sunday as a Sabbatical institution.

4. When there are two parties, each observing a different day as a Sabbath, the State cannot take one of these days and make it binding on all alike, without discriminating against one class in favor of the other. Hence those who keep the seventh day are discriminated against by these Sunday laws. If the State wishes to be utterly impartial, let it take some day as the universal rest day which neither party observes as the Sabbath. Then all will stand equal before the law; they cannot otherwise.