Concluded.
To verify the statement made in the previous article, that the Emperor Constantine did not do for the Church what Professor Blanchard says is necessary for such a union, I will make a few extracts from history. The statement which the professor makes is that “union of Church and State is [1] the selection by the nation of one church, [2] the endowment of such a church, [3] the appointment of its officers, and [4] the oversight of its doctrines.”
Constantine did none of these things; for (1.) he established Christianity, not a single sect, as the national religion—just what the Reform Association is laboring for in this country. As evidence on this point, a few words from the Emperor himself will be to the point. In Eusebius’s “Life of Constantine,” book 2, chap. 66, we find the following from him:—
For I was aware that if I should succeed in establishing, according to my hopes, a common harmony of sentiment among all the servants of God, the general course of affairs would also experience a change correspondent to the pious desires of them all.—From Constantine’s letter to Alexander and Arius.
And in the edict of Constantine on Polytheism, we find the following:—
Victor Constantinus, Maximus Augustus, to the people of the Eastern provinces.
My own desire is, for the general advantage of the world and all mankind, that thy people should enjoy a life of peace and undisturbed concord. Let those, therefore, who are still blinded by error, be made welcome to the same degree of peace and tranquillity which they have who believe. For may be that this restoration of equal privileges to all will have a powerful effect in leading them into the path of truth. Let no one molest another in this matter; but let every one be free to follow the bias of his own mind.—Life of Constantine, book 2, chap. 56.
But to show how soon after the establishment of Christianity all had to be conformed to “orthodox” Christianity, we quote from Gibbon’s “Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire,” chap. 21, par. 1. We read:—
The Edict of Milan [A. D. 313], the great charter of toleration, had confirmed to each individual of the Roman world the privilege of choosing and professing his own religion. But this inestimable privilege was soon violated; with the knowledge of truth the Emperor imbibed the maxims of persecution; and the sects which dissented from the Catholic Church [which was orthodox], were afflicted and oppressed by the triumph of Christianity. Constantine easily believed that the heretics, who presumed to dispute his opinions, or to oppose his commands, were guilty of the most absurd and criminal obstinacy. Not a moment was lost in excluding [after Christianity had been established] the ministers and teachers of the separated congregations from any share of the rewards and immunities which the emperor had so liberally bestowed on the orthodox clergy. But as the sectaries might still exist under the cloud of royal disgrace, the conquest of the East was immediately followed by an edict which announced their total destruction. (Euseb. Vit. Const. 1. iii. c. 63, 66.) After a preamble filled with passion and reproach, Constantine absolutely prohibits the assemblies of the heretics, and confiscates their public property to the use either of the revenue or of the Catholic Church. The sects against whom the imperial severity was directed, appear to have been the adherents of Paul of Samosata; the Montanists of Phrygia, who maintained an enthusiastic succession of prophecy; the Novatians, and others. The design of extirpating the name, or at least of restraining the progress, of these odious heretics, was prosecuted with rigor and effect. Some of the penal regulations were copied from the edicts of Diocletian [!]; and this method of conversion was applauded by the same bishops who had felt the hand of oppression, and had pleaded for the rights of humanity.
(2.) It is actions similar to these that the National Reform Association have in view. They say, “There should be [the Christian] religion [established by this Government], but no church;” and then “enforce upon all that come among us the laws of Christian morality.” But if there are any Christians who presume to dispute their opinions, or dare to oppose their commands, they must be counted as “infidels” and “atheists,” and be banished “to some wild, desolate land,” to “stay there till they die.” The church was supported by its own members; it was not endowed by the state. Gibbon, speaking of Christianity after it had become “the religion of the emperor and the empire,” says:—
As the wants and expenses of the church increased with her prosperity, the ecclesiastical order was still supported and enriched by the voluntary oblations of the faithful. Eight years (A. D. 321) after the Edict of Milan, Constantine granted to all his subjects the free and universal permission of bequeathing their fortunes to the Holy Catholic Church; and their devout-liberality, which during their lives was checked by luxury or avarice, flowed with a profuse stream at the hour of their death.—Decline and Fall, chap. 20, par. 23.
(3.) Further, the Christians elected their own officers; they were not appointed by the state. On this point Gibbon says:—
The freedom of elections subsisted long after the legal establishment of Christianity; and the subjects of Rome enjoyed in the Church the privilege which they had lost in the republic, of choosing the magistrates whom they were bound to obey.—Id., par. 21.
(4.) Neither did he have the “oversight of its doctrines” to any greater extent than the “reformers” propose to give this Government the “oversight of its doctrines.” All the “oversight” that the state had can be seen from the following words of the historian:—
The session [of the Council of Nice, A. D. 325], which lasted about two months, was frequently honored by the presence of the emperor. Leaving his guards at the door, he seated himself (with the permission of the council) on a low stool in the midst of the hall. Constantine listened with patience, and spoke with modesty, and while he influenced the debates, he humbly professed that he was the minister, not the judge, of the successors of the apostles. . . . Such profound reverence of an absolute monarch toward a feeble and unarmed assembly of his own subjects, can only be compared to the respect with which the senate had been treated by the Roman princes who adopted the policy of Augustus.—Id., par. 27.
It was the Church, as a whole, that had the “oversight of its doctrines,” either through their councils or by the bishops which they elected. Concerning this Gibbon says:—
The representatives of the Christian republic were regularly assembled in the spring and autumn of each year, and these synods diffused the spirit of ecclesiastical discipline and legislation through the hundred and twenty provinces of the Roman world. The archbishop or metropolitan was empowered, by the laws, to summon the suffragan bishops of his province; to revise their conduct, to vindicate their rights, to declare their faith, and to examine the merit of the candidates who were elected by the clergy and people to supply the vacancies of the Episcopal college.
In A. D. 314 the Council of Arles assembled.
Eleven years afterward (A. D. 325), a more numerous and celebrated assembly was convened at Nice in Bithynia, to extinguish by their final sentence, the subtle disputes which had arisen in Egypt on the subject of the Trinity. . . . The Catholic world has unanimously submitted to the infallible decrees of the general councils.
In a note on this last sentence, Gibbon states:—
Beveridge (ad Pandect. proleg., p. 2) remarks, that the emperors never made new laws in ecclesiastical matters; and Giannone observes, in a very different spirit, that they gave a legal sanction to the canons of councils. Istoria Civile di Napoli, i. p. 136.—Decline and Fall, chap. 20, par. 27.
That this is also according to the National Reform doctrine is proved by the words of J. C. K. Milligan, an old “stand-by” in the work:—
The churches and the pulpits have much to do with shaping and forming opinions on all moral questions, and with interpretations of Scripture on moral and civil, as well as on theological and ecclesiastical points; and it is probable that in the almost universal gathering of our citizens about these, the chief discussions and the final decisions of most points will be developed there. “Many nations shall come and say, Come and let us go up to the mountain of the Lord, and to the house of the God of Jacob; and he will teach us his ways, and we will walk in his paths; for the law shall go forth of Zion.”
Again:—
We will not allow the civil Government to decide between them [the churches] and to ordain church doctrines, ordinances, and laws.—Statesman, Feb. 21, 1884.
So we find that in every vital point the National Reform movement is like the movement in the Roman Empire which resulted in the establishment of the papacy, and brought on the scenes of the Dark Ages, which are a blot on the page of history; and in no point was the union of church and state in Constantine’s reign like that defined by Professor Blanchard. This is evident: The National Reform movement is contrary to the very principles which give this Government the superiority over other governments, and it seeks to destroy them. Such is the real object and work of the association.
W. A. BLAKELY.