AdventAI

DISCIPLE VS. DISCIPLE.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 34., August 23, 1887

The Christian Oracle, Disciple paper of Des Moines, Iowa, publishes that the Sabbath was solely a Jewish institution, and that the ten commandments were abolished at the cross. The Christian Standard, another Disciple paper, published in Cincinnati, Ohio, in its issue of Aug. 6, 1887, publishes a communication from a correspondent radically controverting such views, taking the position that the Sabbath did not originate at Sinai but at the beginning, and that the ten commandments were not abolished at the cross. We quote herewith so much of the article as pertains to this point. It must be entertaining reading to the Oracle from a member of its own denomination. This man speaks according to the oracles of God, and we commend his words, his direct scriptures and sound arguments, to the careful attention of the Delphic Oracle of Des Moines. He says:—

“1. The Sabbath not an exclusively Jewish institution. The foundation-argument of our brother’s paper is that the Sabbath was exclusively a Jewish institution. This cannot be, because—

“(a) The very reason assigned to the Israelites as the ground of its obligation was that God had sanctified it from the beginning of human existence. ‘Six days shalt thou labor and do all thy work: but the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God: in it thou shalt not do any work, . . . for in six days the Lord made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day: wherefore the Lord blessed the Sabbath day, and hallowed it.’ Ex. 20: 9–11.

“Here the statement is made as in Gen. 2: 1–3, that God blessed and hallowed the seventh day centuries before there was a Jew in existence; and it was sanctified for the world of mankind and not merely for a little portion of it two thousand years distant in point of time.

“(b) The Israelites were bidden to remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy. It was not spoken of as an institution brought to their notice for the first time, like the passover, but as of a distinction which had been recognized in the past, and which they were to continually remember as having been instituted from the beginning when God finished the work of creation.

“(c) It was not a ritual institution like the shadowy code of exclusively Jewish forms and observances.

“It stands in the midst of nine other grand moral enactments which are world-wide and time-lasting, and it is false reasoning which argues that this one institution has been abrogated by the gospel system when there is not one jot of testimony to that effect.

“It always has been, and will be, wrong for any man to serve idols. It always has been, and will be, wrong for any man to profane the name of God. It always has been, and will be, wrong for any man to steal, or kill, or covet, or commit adultery. These things are fixed and eternal principles of righteousness, and he is a bold man who will take up one of the equal decrees of the decalogue and declare it to be null and void when God Almighty has nowhere said so.

“The Son of God emphatically stated that the heaven and earth should pass away before one jot or tittle should pass from the law till all should be fulfilled.

“The types of the law were fulfilled in and by him, and their observance ceased to be obligatory by reason of statutory limitation; but Jesus Christ never fulfilled the moral law in such a way as to render it nugatory or as releasing mankind from its observance.

“Paul, who is quoted by the brother as arguing against the perpetuation of the Sabbath, and who, in his contentions with the legalists of his day, made use of very strong language against the error of regarding the law as a ground of justification, yet declares that the law is not made void through faith. ‘God forbid: yea, we establish the law.’ Rom. 3: 31.

“And when the libertines of the apostolic church wrested the argument against legalism into license to indulge in sin, James and John both found it necessary to assert the obligation of the moral precepts of the decalogue, the latter declaring and defining sin to be the transgression of the law. James. 2: 8–18; 1 John 3, 4.

“(d) The Israelites were commanded to observe the sanctity of the seventh day before the law was given at Sinai.

“Here we must positively contradict our brother’s statement that the obligation to observe the Sabbath depended solely upon the fourth commandment.

“The law was not given until the third month of their journey from Egypt. Ex. 19: 1. Yet the observance of the Sabbath was commanded in connection with the gathering of the manna in the second month. Ex. 16: 1–26, etc.

“The Israelites were not to rest on the seventh day because they were Jews, but because they were men and obligated thereto with the rest of mankind.”