AdventAI

UNION OF CHRISTIANS.

By R. F. Cottrell

From Review and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 10., March 11, 1890

BY ELD. R. F. COTTRELL.

(Battle Creek, Mich.)

It seems to be a pretty general impression that the union of all Christians would be a good thing. This is in harmony with the prayer of Jesus, as recorded in John 17. He prayed that his disciples might be one, even as he and the Father are one. That signifies a very close union. But those of our time who are proposing “evangelical alliance,” or a “federation of American churches,” do not propose so close a union as that, as the following from the Christian Statesman will show:—

We noted recently the fact that the committee from the Presbyterian General Assembly to confer with a similar committee from the Protestant Episcopal Church, concerning the basis of union proposed at the Episcopal General Convention in Chicago, will report that organic union is impossible. Presbyterians will not consent to recognize the claims of Episcopalians as to the authority of bishops and the necessity for Episcopal ordination. The committee, however, resolved to report in favor of a federation of American churches. This most significant proposal has been discussed by Dr. McCosh in an article in the Christian Union of New York. Dr. McCosh does not urge consolidation, but confederation on lines following somewhat the model of the Constitution of the United States. He says, “The plan which I propose does not interfere with the arrangements of any church. It does not profess to be a church organization; it is simply a provision by which each church, adhering to its own constitution, may carry out the will of the Master. The Episcopal minister is still under his bishop, the Presbyterian minister is still under his presbytery or classes, and the Congregational pastor has the benefit of the advice of a council.” Dr. McCosh shows the workings and benefit of the system—its chief purpose being to see that the whole field is covered by comprehensive parish work. Now churches overlap and duplicate each other in many districts, while large areas in town and country are neglected by all, and allowed to sink into heathenism and vice. This he would remedy by having all evangelical churches co-operate and confederate together for all purposes which they have in common.

The “basis of union” as here proposed, is not the basis which our Lord laid down. His basis was the truth as contained in the word of God. “Sanctify them through thy truth: thy word is truth.”

Two doctrines which contradict each other cannot both be true. Therefore a union of discordant sects, such as that proposed in the above extract, can be effected only by compromising the truth which some of them hold, putting it upon an equal footing with the errors which others of them may hold.

The purpose, as stated, is that “all evangelical churches co-operate and confederate together for all purposes which they have in common.” Now, since there must be error on the part of some, where there is division, is it not possible that there may be some error which they hold in common? If so, that error cannot be made the truth of God, should all agree and vote it so. And suppose it should be a “purpose which they have in common” to enforce some religious institution, which they hold in common, by civil legislation, what would be the result?—It would subvert the fundamental principles of our American government. Some of our wisest statesmen have warned us against such a religious combination,—a religious combination for political purposes.

We have also a warning from an ancient prophet. If you read carefully Isaiah 8, from verse 9 to the end of the chapter, you can see that it is a prophecy which applies to the last days, when the Church is looking for the coming of the Lord, and Spiritualism is seducing the people, and preparing its victims for the great day of wrath. In verse 12 he says, “Say ye not, A confederacy, to all them to whom this people shall say, A confederacy; neither fear ye their fear, nor be afraid. Sanctify the Lord of hosts himself; and let him be your fear, and let him be your dread.”

A confederacy by compromise is not the Christian union of the Scriptures; and yet it is expected that such a union will be the means of introducing a glorious millennium. What could be more preposterous? The true basis of Christian union is found in 1 Cor. 1:10: “Now I beseech you, brethren, by the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that ye all speak the same thing, and that there be no divisions among you; but that ye be perfectly joined together in the same mind and in the same judgment.”

It is not the fault of the Bible that Christians are divided in doctrine and practice. All practical doctrines and duties are clearly revealed. The grand test of doctrine is: “To the law and to the testimony: if they speak not according to this word, it is because there is no light in them.” Isa. 8:20. With the Spirit of God in our hearts, leading us to love, unity, and obedience, the Scriptures are able to make us wise unto salvation, and bring us into unity of faith and practice. This is genuine Christian union.