LOUISIANA

17%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 11, 1890

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 10.

Read the full edition

LOUISIANA

MARTHAVILLE.—The discussion mentioned in my last report began according to appointment, Feb. 5, and continued one week, there being a meeting two hours in length each evening. We had agreed to debate eight questions, Eld. Capers expressing a desire to fully investigate every one, if it required six weeks or six months. But before we finished the first question, he seemed very anxious to leave it, hoping to stand a better chance on some other one. He seemed, however, unprepared to meet the arguments on other points, so he proposed to close the debate after we had merely introduced some of the questions, and before we had touched several of them. The most of the time was occupied in the investigation of the Sabbath and Sunday question. I affirmed that the fourth commandment is obligatory upon Christians, and that they should keep holy the seventh day instead of Sunday, the first day. Then Eld. Capers was to affirm that Sunday, the first day of the week, is the Lord’s day, and should be kept holy by all Christians until Jesus comes. The word of God was to be the guide in discussing these questions; so all can see how little chance the Elder had to sustain his positions.
On the first question his principal effort was to make it appear that the Sabbath was a part of the ceremonial law, and that it was abolished at the cross. This was easily refuted by showing the clear distinction between the two laws. When I established the facts in regard to the institution of the Sabbath,—when, how, of what, by whom, and for whom it was made, and that it was long before the Jewish nation existed, and before the Mosaic law was given,—the Elder seemed altogether unprepared to meet the arguments. He did not even know how to try to meet them, but closed his speech in half his allotted time. I desired to continue this question another session, but he insisted upon taking up the second proposition. When he was denying the Sabbath, he asserted that it could not be kept on a round earth, in Northern latitudes, etc.; so when he came to affirm that Sunday should be kept holy by all Christians, he saw that his past arguments were fatal to his own position. He had exhausted his arguments on the first question, and when he came to the second, he could say but little. He used Acts 20:7; 1 Cor. 16:2; John 20:26, and a few other texts entirely foreign to the question, such as, “This is the day which the Lord hath made,” &c. Ps. 118:24. When he utterly failed to meet the issues, he began to denounce the S. D. A. doctrines as false and dangerous, and warned the people to keep away from them. All could clearly see that he was defeated, and that what he failed to gain by argument, he wanted to gain by other means. He had procured a copy of a book written in opposition to Seventh-day Adventism, and depended largely upon that to help him out. But when the Elder saw the position taken in the book, on the nature of man, punishment of the wicked, etc., he saw that it was as much opposed to first-day Adventist views as to ours; and I think he was disgusted with the book, and was sorry he ever introduced it into the debate.
As above stated, before the other questions were fairly introduced, and while as yet some were not touched at all, he proposed to close the discussion; so I only need to say that the farther we went, the weaker were the arguments against the blessed truth. The truth gained a decided victory, and we can see that it was the best thing that could have been done, under the circumstances, to set the truth before many who would not otherwise have heard it. We already see some good results, and expect yet to see more. Several persons were fully decided in favor of the truth, as a direct result of the discussion, and a number of others acknowledge that we are right. I am willing to admit that my opponent did as well as almost any one they could select on that side, being quite a good talker; but this could not make up for the great lack of truth on his side. Before the discussion, he seemed to have some hold in the neighborhood of Marthaville, but at its close I think he had lost it all. Those for whom he had strongest hopes were fully brought to the truth. Those who indorsed him were as sadly disappointed as he.
On the Sabbath after the debate two more new members were received into the Marthaville church, and there are two or three others who are expected to join in the near future. Never have we seen the work in a better condition at this place. We praise the Lord for all the good done. The work looks encouraging in this field.
Feb. 27. B. F. PURDHAM.