[In the National Tribune (Washington, D.C.) of Aug. 20, 1891, R. S. Macarthur, D.D., of Calvary church, N. Y., gave a synopsis of the Baptist faith. The following extract contains what he claims are the fundamental principles of the Baptist belief in regard to the question of religious freedom and the relation of Church and State. In the crisis now visibly approaching on this subject, we wonder if the large body of Baptists will stand true to their principles.—Ed.]
There is another doctrine, which though originally a Baptist tenet, is now held outside Baptist circles; namely, the doctrine of religious freedom—the doctrine that the civil magistrate has no rightful authority in purely religious matters.
In the Hebrew nation, and in ancient Gentile governments also, the Church and the State were one. The Jewish high priest was a civil functionary, and the Roman emperor was Pontifex Maximus. The civil and ecclesiastical governments were identical, or at least affiliated, and the civil magistrate concerned himself about religious matters. In the Middle Ages, the prevalence of the doctrine of baptismal regeneration and the consequent practically universal baptism of infants, made every person a church-member as well as a citizen. Thus Church and State again became identical, or at least conterminous, and the civil magistrate concerned himself with religious as well as secular interests.
But the Baptist doctrine, that one became a true Christian and a—
RIGHTFUL MEMBER OF THE CHURCH
only when he personally made a profession of faith, left a vast number, indeed, a great majority, of citizens outside the church, and there was a separation between the ecclesiastical body and the civil community. The church became what it was in the apostles’ day, a private society, a group of persons apart from the main body of citizens, and thus Church and State were divorced, and each was remanded to its own sphere.
Again: in the days when there was a full adherence to the doctrine of baptismal regeneration and of direct spiritual efficacy of ecclesiastical ceremonies, it was logical for the civil power to attempt to make men Christians. If baptizing a person would change his spiritual nature and his relations to God, all that was necessary to make a nation a Christian nation was to compel its members to be baptized and to observe the other ecclesiastical rites. If salvation came through outward ceremonies, the observance of which could be compelled by force, it was possible for the civil power to compel men to become Christians. It could not only lead them to the water of life, but by thumbscrew and fagot could make them drink.
Thus Charlemagne and other Christian conquerors compelled vanquished barbarians to go down into the water by tens of thousands to be baptized. And such compulsion seemed a solemn duty to those who believe that the failure to be baptized left the—
SOUL TO BE LOST.
If baptism could make one a Christian, the colonel in our late war was sound, who gave orders for a detail of men to be baptized.
But the Baptist doctrine that a man could become a Christian only by the voluntary and free action of his own spiritual nature, made religion a matter which could be settled only between the man and his God, thus leaving nothing to be done by the civil magistrate, who could control only the man’s outward actions, and could not reach his heart.
A moment’s thought will show that there is no ground whatever for saying that the only reason why the Baptists did not strive to extend their doctrines by force as did others, was that they had no power so to do. It was a part of their fundamental belief that external force was utterly ineffectual to make men Christians. Others might abstain from persecution because their pity was stronger than their religious zeal; but the Baptists were restrained from it by logical deductions; namely, because they held that becoming a Christian was an act of the spirit which outward force could not compel.
So they always taught that the civil power should take no cognizance of religious beliefs or purely religious practices of men, whether orthodox or heretic, Turk or heathen, but that these should be left solely to the—
JUDGMENT OF GOD.
Other Christians have been very candid in recognizing that it was the Baptists who first preached the great doctrine of religious freedom. But it has not always been perceived that this doctrine was a logical outgrowth of the fundamental Baptist principle of a converted church membership, and that church ceremonies are to be used only when men have already become Christians.
The divorce between Church and State was not merely a lucky thought of astute Baptist philosophers; it was the logical outcome of distinctive Baptist principles. The Baptists preceded others in declaring the true relations of the civil and ecclesiastical bodies, not because they were superior to other Christians in their understanding of civil principles, but because they held an ecclesiastical tenet which was correct where others were in error.