AdventAI

A STONE FOR BREAD.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 7., February 14, 1893

An inquirer writes to Our Hope (a no-Sabbath-Adventist paper), asking why the disciples were directed by Christ to pray that their flight be not on the Sabbath day, at the time Jerusalem was to be destroyed, if it was not then binding upon Christians. To this the corresponding editor (whose name, so far as the no-Sabbath doctrine is concerned, has become a synonym for everything that is careless and illogical) replies, that that instruction referred to women who had young children, or were about to become mothers, and if they were found fleeing on the Sabbath day, they would be stoned to death by the Jews.

Such a shift, to get around the Sabbath, is either the last refuge of despair, or a pitiful revelation of ignorance. It strikes us that it is giving a stone to one who asks for bread. Verse 3 says that the “disciples” came to him to ask him about the things of which he had told them. It was therefore the twelve disciples to whom he was talking; and we never knew before that these were “only women.” Moreover, when he comes to speak about their flight from Jerusalem (verse 19), he does not say, “Woe unto you who are with child, and to you who give suck in those days,” but, “Woe unto them,” etc. Then, turning to his disciples, he says, “But pray ye that your flight be not in the winter, neither on the Sabbath day.” He does not say, “Let them [referring to those of whom he had spoken in verse 19] pray that their flight be not in the winter, neither on the Sabbath day,” but, “Pray ye.”

But that all this must refer only to some women, in a particular condition, this Goliath of no Sabbathism proceeds to argue that it must refer to such only, because “others might better endure the hardships attending a winter flight, or more safely run away from the Jewish stoning.” The reader will think that we have italicized these words to hold up to merited ridicule such reasoning, but this is not the case; for we give the italics just as we find them. We leave the writer himself to emphasize his own nonsense. He would have us understand that when Christ said, “Pray ye that your flight be not in the winter, neither on the Sabbath day,” he did not refer to those who could run (!) and who could endure hardship; that is, all who would be able to flee, such as strong women, and all men, would be all right, they could get away, and needed no directions; but he referred only to those who could not flee! But we should suppose that such would find it difficult to flee on any other day as well as the Sabbath, so it will not do to leave it there, and he therefore adds, “Flee from the stoning of the Jews;” just as if the Jews of Palestine, if they should see any one fleeing for his life on the Sabbath day would immediately take after him with clubs and stones, and kill him on the spot! Could anything be more supremely puerile, or betray more utter thoughtlessness? That was not the course the Jews pursued in the case of those they stoned; they either had the semblance of a trial, as in the case of Stephen (Acts 6: 9-14; 7:51-60) or were set upon by those who had become enraged by their teachings, as in the case of Paul. Acts 14:19; Lev. 24:14; Deut. 13:9, etc. There is no hint of any one ever having been stoned for passing through the country on the Sabbath day. Indeed, the fine-spun traditions of the Jewish doctors allowed a certain distance to be traveled on the Sabbath, which they called a “Sabbath day’s journey.” But we are astutely informed that if a man was nimble enough to dodge the stones which were thrown after him on the Sabbath, he might flee on that day!

Not content with this prodigious attempt at argument, the writer tries another tack, in these words: “Those women [all women, you see] were not told that it would be wicked to flee in the winter, or on the Sabbath day: If it would have been wicked to flee on the Sabbath, Jesus would have expressly forbidden flight on that day. But he did not do that.” Here again we give the italics as we find them. Of course, fleeing on the Sabbath under those circumstances, was not forbidden, because it would have been a matter of necessity; and no work of mercy or necessity was ever forbidden on the Sabbath. But it would have interfered with the proper use of the Sabbath, as a day of worship and devotion, and this is the very reason they were to pray that it might not be necessary for them to flee on that day. To have to flee in the winter would be against their physical well-being, and to be obliged to flee on the Sabbath would be to their spiritual detriment. Therefore, they were to pray that it might not be on such a season, or on such a day.

No cause can be assigned, which has the least semblance of reason, why they were not to flee upon the Sabbath day, except its influence upon their own spiritual good; for if, as the opposer of the Sabbath affirms, the gates of Jerusalem would be shut on that day, then they could not flee, however much they might desire to do so. And if, again, they would have been immediately caught and stoned to death, then, again, they could not have fled; and then we should have Christ directing them to pray that their flight be not on the Sabbath day because then they could not flee. That is, they were to pray that something might not be, which could not be. Such argument is folly.

We have said that these words were spoken to the twelve apostles. They, of course, stood as representatives of all those for whose benefit the words were uttered, that is, the church of that time, and subsequent times; and among them would be some in the condition referred to, but as compared with the whole body, such would be only a few. The far greater part would be in a situation and condition altogether different; and hence to try to confine the words of Christ exclusively to women, and to such only as were in the condition referred to, would seem to be the last resort of desperation, and of all Antinomian misnamed arguments, the weakest of the weak.

To be obliged to flee in the winter would subjectp. 105 them to much physical suffering; and the Saviour showed his care for his people by a solicitude that they might not be obliged to flee at such a time. But to flee on the Sabbath would involve no physical inconvenience, and they would be subjected to no obstructions; for the Jews had so little regard for the Sabbath themselves that at the very time when the sign was given (verse 15), they rushed out of the city on the Sabbath day to pursue the army of Cestius Gallus, leaving the gates of the city open (see Josephus); and none would molest them going through the country. The only reason, therefore, for that prayer, which would keep them in mind continually of the Sabbath, was that they might have the spiritual benefits of that institution, which was not to pass away, but which would be to them a special help and blessing in their time of tribulation. What a solace it would be to them to have the privilege to spend the hours of the Sabbath, though trouble reigned around, in quiet religious devotion and communion with their Maker.

So will it be with the remnant in the closing scenes of their earthly pilgrimage. Rev. 7:3; 14:12. And so have we reason now to pray that no vicissitudes may arise which will make it necessary ever to use the hours of the Sabbath other than as becometh the Sabbath of the Lord, “the Lord’s day,” the holy of the Lord, and honorable, the day which is a refreshing oasis in our pilgrimage here, and which will be a day of worship and access to the tree of life in the kingdom of God forever and ever. Isa. 66:22, 23; Rev. 22:2.