AGE-TO-COME FALLACIES

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 14, 1893

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 11.

Read the full edition

AGE-TO-COME FALLACIES.

The doctrine commonly called the “Age-to-Come,” which embraces the notion of the return of the Jews to Palestine, and the establishment of another theocracy on the earth, over which Christ and some few especially favored saints shall reign, while yet the majority of the earth’s inhabitants are in rebellion against Christ and refuse to accept him as their Saviour or to obey his laws, is a doctrine, which, in some of its various and changeable forms, either lightly or tenaciously, is held by many people. We have before stated, and we repeat it, that we believe it to be an error and only an error, and that it has no consistent support in the Scriptures. We have before noticed some points of this doctrine, and if we now notice others, it is only done with the sincere hope of helping those who are unacquainted with their arguments, to be better prepared to meet them. It will be impossible to notice all the fallacies in the doctrine of the Age-to-Come in one article; so we shall only attempt in this to notice a few of them. We shall not make up an Age-to-Come argument ourselves, and then reply to it; for that would not be fair; but we will take some extracts from an Age-to-Come Bible reading, which a brother has secured and sent to this Office. We will first give the following statements:—
“All who are called are not chosen. Matt. 20:16; 22:14.
“Who, then, are the chosen?—Those who make their calling and election sure, and show forth the virtues of Him who hath called them. 2 Peter 1:10, 11; Heb. 6:11-15; 1 Peter 2:9.
“Jesus is the author and finisher of their faith. Heb. 12:1-3.”
The drift of the above question is for the purpose of showing that a special class are now being gathered out who will occupy a higher position than others in a future age,—an age where immortal saints, associated with Christ, will reign over mortal sinners, and will endeavor to bring them to Christ with varying degrees of success. But the texts quoted entirely fail of teaching any such doctrine. They do teach that God is gathering out a special people; but they are a special people in relation to this present world, and not in relation to a future age or world. This idea of a special people who are to be a blessing to others is made prominent in the following quotation:—
“We learn that whosoever has faith in the Lord Jesus Christ is called and chosen of God, and is a member of the church, or body, of Christ, also is of that class of Abraham’s seed, in whom all the families of the earth are to be blessed; therefore let us who have this faith, praise his name, ‘and rejoice in the hope of the glory of God.’ Rom. 5:2.”
These quotations are sufficient to show the scope of the Age-to-Come teaching. A special class is now being chosen which is to be, in some future age, a blessing to those who during this age have rejected the offers of salvation. We do not take such a view of the subject. We believe that all mankind are called. Rev. 22:17. But even though they heed the call and make their “calling and election sure,” that does not make them chosen in the sense used in Matt. 20:16. We understand this to refer to cases where God calls men, and endows them for special work he has for them to do, notable instances of which are the choice he made of Jeremiah (Jer. 1:5), and Saul of Tarsus. Acts 9:15. All of the children of God are a chosen generation, but not in the sense that Jeremiah and Saul were.
The other texts referred to in the first quotation contain nothing that is not alike applicable to all saints.
The second quotation contains a grievous error, a wide departure from the truth of the gospel. Please read again. It is stated that those who have faith in Christ constitute a “class of Abraham’s seed, in whom all the families of the earth are to be blessed.” There is no such class brought to view in the Bible, and the text quoted (Rom. 5:2) teaches nothing of the kind. The “seed” in whom the world is blessed is Christ. Says Paul, “He saith not, and to seeds, as of many; but as of one, and to thy seed, which is Christ.” Gal. 3:16. Those who are Christ’s are Abraham’s seed, and heirs with Christ of the inheritance, but the families of the earth are not blessed in them, but in him, the one seed. All Christians are, of course, a blessing to the world while they live in it; but there is no Bible evidence that the Christians of one age will excel in glory the Christians of any other age. Every attempt to prove that the Christians of one age will be higher than those of another age is exalting self, and by so doing is detracting from the glory which belongs to Christ alone.
The same idea of an exalted and favored class who at some future time are to bless the world, is thus declared in the following quotation:—
“There are Scriptures showing that the children of men, and all Israel, the seed of Jacob, are waiting for the sons of God, or the Christ seed of Abraham, head and body to come and bless them. Rom. 8:19-21; 11:26.”
The above statement is far stronger than the texts quoted as proof. The Scriptures cited say nothing about “the sons of God, or the Christ seed of Abraham head and body” coming to bless any one. That is all pure imagination. To be found, it must be read between the lines. Paul in Rom. 8:19-21 contrasts the present with the future condition of the saints. Now there is suffering; then there will be glory. Now we are creatures subject to vanity; then we shall be “delivered from the bondage of corruption into the glorious liberty of the sons of God.” In this earthly condition we “groan and travail,” and will until our body is redeemed. Then it will be manifest that we are the sons of God. Now as creatures of earth, liable to suffering, sickness, and death, we wait for the glorious day of deliverance,—for the coming of our glorious head; but we do not wait for the body, the church, nor will any one ever so wait. There is no promise comprehending such an idea. “All Israel will be saved;” for those who are gathered by the gospel will constitute Israel, whether they be Jews by nature or Gentiles.
Again we read:—
“The special salvation as alluded to in 1 Tim. 4:10, reading in this wise, ‘God, who is the Saviour of all men, specially of those that believe.’
“Those who believe now in this accepted time and day of salvation are saved to a special salvation; viz., to be a ruling element in his kingdom or government over men; and that present belief in his Son Jesus is the means to that kind of salvation and royalty.”
We do not doubt that those who now accept Christ are the recipients of a “special salvation,” received because they have believed; but the same reason holds good that all who have in past ages accepted him are also sharers of the special salvation; and if a future probation were promised, those who are saved under that salvation must also be sharers of the “special salvation;” for they will also be saved by believing, and he is the special Saviour of those that believe.
Really, Paul’s words to Timothy (1 Tim. 4:10) do not teach a special salvation confined to our time. While mercy is offered to men, it is “the day of salvation,” and men may be saved.
He is the “Saviour of all men.” He has died that all may live. As the life of Jesus was worth more than the lives of all the world, his life as our substitute fully pays the price for all mankind. The salvation thus purchased at such an infinite cost he offers freely to all mankind. He is thus the Saviour of all men. But some will not believe, will not accept. By their unbelief they nullify the particular benefit they might receive by believing. They lose what is theirs if they will receive it. On the other hand, those who believe, make the salvation offered to all mankind their own by their faith and acceptance of the plan. “Whom having not seen, . . . ye love; in whom, though now ye see him not, yet believing, ye rejoice with joy unspeakable and full of glory: receiving the end of your faith, even the salvation of your souls.” 1 Peter 1:8, 9. Thus Christ is the special Saviour of every one who believes; and he always has and always will be the special Saviour of those who believe, because their faith receives what he offers to them.
We have not space to notice all the fallacies contained in the “reading.” Those we have noticed are specimens of all the rest. One of the positions taken is that the Sodomites are to be restored. We noticed this position in the REVIEW, of Nov. 22, 1892, under the heading of “Jerusalem, Samaria, and Sodom.” When we carefully examine the arguments used to sustain the Age-to-Come doctrine, one thing we shall not fail to notice,—that the would-be evidence is in the statement or assumption, but not in the Scriptures quoted as proof. Like the texts used to sustain Sunday-keeping, they lack the very essentials they ought to have to sustain the position which is taken. There is no plain “Thus saith the Lord” for any of their theories.
M. E. K.