AdventAI

THEY ADMIT IT.

By L. A. S.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 7., February 14, 1893

Some of the zealous ecclesiastics by whose efforts Congress was made to take the action which it did last August respecting the World's Fair, are honest enough to admit that the action was unconstitutional, both on account of its touching a religious question, and as an interference with the legal authority of the State of Illinois. Such are the editors of the Political Dissenter (National Reform organ), published in Pittsburgh, Pa.

The Dissenter fears that “the Illinois legislature will put itself in direct opposition to Congress by enacting a bill authorizing the keeping of the Fair open on the Sabbath,” in which case “the directors of the Fair will not be slow to avail themselves of such State authority, in the face of any national opposition.” “For our own part,” says the Dissenter, “we believe that the commonwealth of Illinois would be able to make out a strong case in its interpretation of the national Constitution, and of the powers of Congress under it. Congressional legislation on behalf of the Christian Sabbath, or any other Christian institution in the life of our nation, has no adequate legal basis in our written Constitution.”

The Dissenter hopes that “if Illinois raises this issue, the Supreme Court of the nation may decide that this is a Christian nation, with an unwritten, vital, historical, and providential constitution that is distinctively and undeniably Christian, although much in our national life is out of harmony with it.”

That indeed would satisfy the most ardent longings of a National Reform heart.

But as a matter of fact, we have no unwritten part of our national Constitution. It is wholly expressed. And the powers not expressly granted by it to the United States, or prohibited to the States, are reserved to the States respectively or to the people.

Nor does the Supreme Court need to render any such decision; for a power (the church power) which has already forced Congress to violate the Constitution as it stands, can doubtless do so again; and the Dissenter and all others allied with it in its desires and aims may as well see now that a violated Constitution is as good for their purposes as an amended one, and go to work accordingly. L. A. S.