AdventAI

IN THE QUESTION CHAIR.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 3., January 17, 1893

[Designed for the consideration of such questions as will be of interest and profit to the general reader. All correspondents should give their names and correct post-office address, that queries not replied to here, may be answered by mail.]

285.—PREACHING TO THE DEAD. 1 PET. 3:19.

Will you please explain what is meant in 1 Pet. 3:19 and 4:6? I have a friend who believes strongly in purgatory and praying for the dead, and relies on these texts for proof of that doctrine. Mrs. H. C.

Answer.—The mistake your friend makes is in supposing that because it says that “the gospel was preached to them that are dead,” it was preached to them while they were dead, and not while they were still living, before they died. Christ preached to the antediluvians by his Spirit, which was in Noah, in the days of Noah, while the ark was preparing, as stated in verse 20. They were said to be “in prison,” because they were shut up to a limited time, 120 years, to hear the warning of the coming flood, and prepare for it and be saved, or disbelieve and be lost. (See this subject discussed at length in the work entitled, “Here and Hereafter, or Man’s Nature and Destiny.” Price $1.)

286.—THE IMPRECATORY PSALMS.

Why does David pray the Lord, as recorded in Psalm 109, to curse his enemies, when he professed to love them? Mrs. M. J. C.

Ans.—This is one of what are called “the imprecatory psalms,” out of which skeptics attempt to make so much capital; but there is no ground for cavil. It is not a denunciation against any who are still on probation. In its general application it sets forth God’s displeasure against sin; and verses 16–18 describe the character of those against whom the denunciations are directed. The persons denounced are such as “remembered not mercy,” “persecuted the poor and needy,” would even “slay the broken in heart,” “loved cursing” and “clothed themselves” with it as with “a garment.” And this describes their condition, not merely at some particular period in their lives, after which they might have repented and become righteous, but their character and course of action through their whole life, and with which they went down into the grave. Such of course will meet the deserts of sin in the future world; and the language of the psalm describes it none too strongly; for it is but a just recompense of reward for such a course of life. But some of the psalm may apply to particular cases, as Acts 1:20 applies some of it to Judas. According to this, verses 8–11 of the psalm, apply to Judas; of course after he had fully sold himself to his iniquitous course. And this throws light on his history, for it appears that he had a family, and as he is called “a thief,” the inference is that he took the Lord’s money and applied it to his own personal and family uses, his wife and children knowing, and participating in, the wrong, as Sapphira did in that of Ananias. Acts 5:1, 2. Hence they would come under the same condemnation, and be subject to consequent punishment. Their source of supply being cut off in the exposure and suicide of Judas, they would very naturally come to poverty. Thus, regarded in its true light, the psalm does not express the personal feelings of David, or of any Christian, against those who are living around him, and still in a state of probation; but it is only the expression of God’s displeasure against sin, showing how he will deal with sinners, after they have slighted and abused his mercy so long as their probation lasted.

287.—EATING PORK. ROM. 14:14.

Please explain Rom. 14:14, 1 Cor. 10:25, and 1 Tim. 4:4. Some endeavor to defend the practice of eating pork from these Scriptures. G. S. R. AND J. E.

Ans.—There is no more argument to be drawn from these texts for eating pork than there is for eating rats, rattle snakes, angle worms, or strychnine, chewing tobacco or drinking whisky. Rom. 14:14 refers to the ceremonial distinctions of the Jewish law, which ceased with the introduction of the gospel. 1 Cor. 10:25 refers to the scruples which might arise concerning eating meats which had been offered to idols; and 1 Tim. 4:4 refers to certain distinctions and restrictions which would be brought into the church by a class of apostates. But none of them treat upon the question of the healthfulness or unhealthfulness of different kinds of food, which should govern every one in the selection of his articles of diet.